Yankees have both Plan B and enough room for free-agent Cody Bellinger
Table of Contents
Follow UsNEW YORK — The New York Yankees enter this offseason with something rare in baseball: both leverage and flexibility. They have the payroll space to re-sign Cody Bellinger and the depth to walk away if negotiations turn costly.
Bellinger’s choice to opt out of his $25 million player option for 2026 surprised no one. The veteran outfielder is now a free agent after a strong first season in pinstripes. He hit .272 with 29 home runs and 98 RBI while playing Gold Glove-caliber defense at multiple positions.
Financial room to maneuver on Bellinger
The Yankees start the winter with an estimated $63 million in available budget for 2026, according to team payroll data. FanGraphs lists their 2025 payroll at about $296 million. With several contracts expiring, including Marcus Stroman’s, they have room to retain Bellinger without compromising other upgrades.
Early projections suggest Bellinger could command around six years and $180 million — more than double his last deal of three years and $80 million. For the Yankees, a five-year, $175 million offer might strike the balance between commitment and flexibility.
General manager Brian Cashman and his staff are in position to re-sign both Bellinger and center fielder Trent Grisham while leaving room for pitching reinforcements. Grisham, coming off a breakout 34-homer season on a one-year, $5 million deal, is projected to earn at least $48 million over four years.
“Grish and Bellinger, two guys that had incredible years,” Aaron Judge said after the Yankees season ended. “It was fun to watch them, fun to learn from them and hopefully we can run them back. We’ll see what happens.”
Young Yankees talent waiting in the wings
The Yankees are not desperate. Two highly regarded prospects are ready to take on bigger roles if needed.
Jasson Dominguez, just 20 years old, appeared in 123 games during the 2025 regular season. The switch-hitter showed steady offensive growth while starting 100 games. His defense remains below average, and he hits better from the left side, but the organization views him as a future cornerstone.
Spencer Jones provides another option. The 6-foot-7 slugger, ranked the Yankees’ No. 2 prospect by MLB Pipeline, excelled across Double-A and Triple-A last season. He hit .274 with 35 home runs, 80 RBI, and 29 stolen bases in 116 games, producing a .932 OPS.
Jones turns 25 in May. The 2022 first-round pick from Vanderbilt has drawn comparisons to Aaron Judge because of his frame and power potential. His one concern is strikeouts — he fanned 179 times in 506 plate appearances, a 35.4 percent rate.
“I’m not really worried,” Jazz Chisholm said when asked about roster changes. “I feel like we’ve built a pretty good family in here. I feel like a lot of guys will want to come back just to keep on trying to push for that World Series.”
Making the right choice for 2026
The Yankees must strike a balance between development and urgency. Judge turns 34 in April, and the window to win with him in peak form is closing. They cannot risk wasting a prime season relying solely on youth.
Starting Dominguez and Jones alongside Judge is appealing for the future. But does it make the Yankees better in 2026? The team must rebound after falling short of another World Series run.
Bellinger offers the safest middle ground. A five-year deal keeps him through Judge’s prime while allowing Dominguez and Jones time to mature without pressure to anchor the lineup.
If Bellinger re-signs, the Yankees can field one of the league’s most complete outfields — defense, power, and balance. If not, other affordable veterans like Cedric Mullins, Starling Marte, or Harrison Bader could provide short-term stability, though none match Bellinger’s all-around value.
Competition for Bellinger’s services
Bellinger will have multiple suitors. The Mets, Phillies, Giants, and Tigers are all expected to pursue him and Astros star Kyle Tucker. His agent, Scott Boras, will explore every opportunity to maximize the payday.
Still, the Yankees have an advantage: familiarity. Bellinger thrived in the Bronx atmosphere and enjoyed playing alongside Judge. While his 29 home runs may have been aided by Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch, his defensive versatility and contact skills remain elite.
The Yankees won’t need to act rashly. Their cap space and deep system give them leverage. A strong, fair offer early could seal the deal before other clubs drive the price higher.
Cashman’s strategy likely includes contingency plans. If Bellinger’s market inflates, the team can pivot to Grisham or promote Jones. If the price aligns, the Yankees can move aggressively to keep their roster intact.
What’s certain is the Yankees won’t stand still. Cashman intends to add another impact outfielder to push for a 2026 World Series return — whether that’s Bellinger or someone else.
Is Kyle Tucker an option?
The most expensive alternative on the market is Kyle Tucker. The Yankees have admired him for years. Tucker’s 2025 season with the Cubs was disrupted by injuries, but he remains one of baseball’s premier left-handed bats. However, his projected $40 million annual salary likely makes him too costly for a Yankees team already managing several large contracts.
Bellinger’s flexibility adds appeal. He plays elite defense across all three outfield spots and at first base. Tucker, primarily a right fielder, lacks that versatility.
The Yankees have also explored power bats like Kyle Schwarber, who hit 54 home runs for the Phillies last season. But with Giancarlo Stanton locked into the DH role, Schwarber’s fit is limited.
For now, Bellinger remains the most realistic and balanced option. He blends power, defense, and clubhouse leadership — traits the Yankees prize.
As the offseason unfolds, the front office will weigh price against performance, risk against reward. With payroll room, prospect insurance, and a clear plan, the Yankees find themselves in an ideal position. Whether they keep Bellinger or pivot elsewhere, their foundation for 2026 looks strong.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
