Cody Bellinger opts out of $25M option, Yankees stare at Soto-like standoff
Table of Contents
Follow UsNEW YORK — The Yankees are back in a familiar spot, staring at another offseason filled with uncertainty surrounding a star outfielder. Cody Bellinger has declined his $25 million player option for the 2026 season and will enter free agency, according to ESPN’s Jorge Castillo.
The 30-year-old’s decision comes after his most complete campaign in years, marking a major comeback in pinstripes. Bellinger hit .272 with 29 home runs, 98 RBIs and 13 steals across 152 games. His .480 slugging percentage and 4.9 WAR were his best since his 2019 MVP season. Among Yankees hitters, only Aaron Judge posted a higher WAR.
The move now puts the Yankees at risk of losing another middle-of-the-order force just one year after Juan Soto departed for the New York Mets.
History repeats itself in the Bronx
Bellinger’s choice echoes last winter’s heartbreak when Soto crossed town to sign a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million contract with the Mets. While Bellinger will not approach that figure, his departure would again leave a massive gap in the Yankees lineup — one that has leaned heavily on Judge for run production.
New York traded for Bellinger last December, hoping to fill the offensive void Soto left behind. The plan worked during the regular season, as Bellinger became a steady force at the plate and a defensive anchor across multiple positions.
But in the postseason, his bat cooled off. Bellinger hit only .214 with a .651 OPS as the Toronto Blue Jays eliminated the Yankees in the ALDS. Even so, his regular season success reminded fans why New York took the gamble to bring him to the Bronx.
Bellinger keeps the door open for a return
Even after opting out, Bellinger made it clear that he enjoyed his first year with the Yankees.
“I had an unbelievable time putting on this uniform,” he said after the team’s playoff elimination. “Yankee Stadium, the fans, the organization, the culture that these guys have created in this locker room. It really is special. It’s such a fun group, it was a fun group to be a part of. Came up short and that part stinks for sure, because we had a really, really good group here.”
Bellinger’s performance against left-handed pitchers set him apart. He led all left-handed hitters with a .415 on-base percentage and .601 slugging percentage versus lefties. His strikeout rate dropped to a career-low 13.7 percent, and his whiff rate to 18.1 percent — both signs of a more mature, contact-driven approach.
There is also a family tie to the Yankees. His father, Clay Bellinger, played for the team from 1999 to 2001 and was part of two World Series championship rosters.
Scott Boras adds another layer of risk
Negotiating Bellinger’s next deal won’t be simple. His agent, Scott Boras, is known for extracting maximum value from the market. That could make Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner cautious, especially after last winter’s tense pursuit of Soto.
According to Spotrac, Bellinger’s next contract could land around six years and $182.7 million, with an annual value above $30 million. That would represent a significant jump from his current deal and test the Yankees’ willingness to commit long-term to a player entering his 30s.
Complicating matters further, the Collective Bargaining Agreement expires after the 2026 season. Executives across baseball expect that the possibility of a work stoppage in 2027 could influence how teams spend this winter.
“It’s going to affect free agency like you wouldn’t believe,” one MLB executive said.
Yankees must balance youth and experience
The Yankees now face a delicate choice between proven performance and future potential. Bellinger’s consistency and versatility offer stability, but the club also has young outfielders ready to step up.
Jasson Dominguez, 22, is expected to take on a larger role, while top prospect Spencer Jones is on the verge of a call-up after a strong season in the minors. Keeping Bellinger would ease pressure on Jones and preserve lineup depth, particularly as the Yankees navigate other roster needs such as first base, with Paul Goldschmidt hitting free agency.
Defensively, Bellinger was one of the Yankees’ best in 2025. He saved 12 runs and posted a +9 fielding run value, ranking in the 91st percentile leaguewide. His ability to play all three outfield positions and first base made him a cornerstone of the team’s defense, which otherwise ranked just 21st in MLB.
Multiple teams ready to make a move
The Yankees won’t be the only club chasing Bellinger this winter. Several contenders view him as the type of player who can stabilize both their lineup and defense.
The Philadelphia Phillies are expected to explore adding another outfielder, and the Cleveland Guardians could make a push to strengthen their offense around Jose Ramirez. Meanwhile, the Mets remain a possible suitor if they lose slugger Pete Alonso. Bellinger’s positional flexibility makes him attractive to teams looking for lineup versatility.
The Yankees will have to act quickly if they want to prevent another repeat of the Soto saga.
Decisions piling up in the Bronx
Bellinger’s choice comes amid several offseason questions for the Yankees. Outfielder Trent Grisham, who hit a career-high 34 homers, is also entering free agency. Key relievers Luke Weaver and Devin Williams will hit the market as well.
Last offseason, New York tried to make up for losing Soto by acquiring multiple impact players rather than a single superstar. The approach worked for much of 2025 — Bellinger, Max Fried and Paul Goldschmidt combined for 10.7 WAR, surpassing Soto’s 7.9 from his final year in the Bronx.
But sustaining that model requires keeping core contributors, and Bellinger’s departure would leave a hole difficult to fill. His .348 average with runners in scoring position led the Yankees, even topping Judge by eight points. His knack for clutch hits, strong defense, and clubhouse presence make him one of the team’s most valuable assets.
Now, the question shifts to the Yankees’ front office: will they be willing to spend to retain him? With Boras at the negotiating table and multiple teams ready to spend, the Yankees could again find themselves watching a star walk away — just like Soto.
If that happens, history won’t just repeat itself in the Bronx — it will haunt it.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
