Yankees’ not in race for Tarik Skubal trade, 2024 lesson deters pursuit
Table of Contents
Follow UsNEW YORK — The New York Yankees have backed away from serious talks to acquire Detroit Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, even as speculation across the league continues to link the Bronx Bombers to the reigning Cy Young contender. Team insiders say the decision stems from hard lessons learned from past blockbuster trades that cost top prospects but failed to bring championship results.
The Yankees’ cautious stance marks a philosophical shift inside the front office. After Carlos Rodon’s elbow surgery and Gerrit Cole’s ongoing recovery from Tommy John surgery, the team faces uncertainty in its rotation heading into the 2026 season. Still, general manager Brian Cashman appears unwilling to risk the farm system again for a short-term move.
Yankees cool on Skubal sweepstakes
Industry sources confirm that New York has stepped back from pursuing Skubal due to Detroit’s steep demands and the Yankees’ intent to protect their young core. Skubal, 28, has established himself among the best pitchers in baseball, winning the 2024 AL Cy Young Award unanimously and putting up another elite season in 2025.
He went 13-6 this year with a league-best 2.21 ERA, 241 strikeouts, and only 34 walks across 195.1 innings. His 0.891 WHIP and 6.6 WAR led all American League pitchers. Those numbers, combined with two years of team control, have made Skubal one of the most valuable arms on the market.
The Tigers hold contractual control of Skubal through the 2026 season before he reaches free agency. That gives Detroit leverage as it explores an extension or trade. Reports indicate Skubal’s agent, Scott Boras, and the Tigers are about $250 million apart in extension talks, with Boras expected to pursue a deal topping $400 million once his client hits free agency.
Cashman and his front office understand Skubal’s ace-level talent. But they are prioritizing payroll balance, cost control, and farm depth instead of another all-in move. It’s a sharp change from the franchise’s old habit of chasing every big name on the market.
Painful memories shape current strategy
The Yankees’ experience with Juan Soto remains fresh. New York traded multiple pitching prospects to land Soto from San Diego before the 2024 season. The move worked on the field — Soto hit .288 with 41 home runs and finished third in AL MVP voting — but not long term.
After one season, Soto signed a record 15-year, $765 million contract with the New York Mets, leaving the Yankees empty-handed. That misstep made the team more cautious, especially when dealing with Boras clients nearing free agency.
As MLB insider Sean McAdam noted earlier this month, any team trading for Skubal “would be foolish and deserves what it gets.” His point reflects Boras’ long history of steering clients to free agency rather than early extensions. That makes it unlikely the Yankees could keep Skubal long term if they traded for him now.
Given that history, the Yankees want to avoid another short-term rental at the expense of their farm system. The organization understands how costly that mistake can be — especially with pitchers who carry durability questions.
Internal options provide rotation depth
The Yankees remain confident in their current pitching group. Max Fried, signed through 2031, anchors the rotation. Luis Gil, who won the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year Award, showed flashes of brilliance in 2025 despite inconsistency after his injury comeback. Prospects Cam Schlittler and Will Warren continue to develop and could fill in when needed.
Carlos Rodon underwent surgery in October to remove bone spurs and loose bodies in his left elbow. Manager Aaron Boone expects him to miss Opening Day but return by late April or early May. Rodon finished 2025 at 18-9 with a 3.09 ERA in 33 starts, offering optimism for his return.
Cole, recovering from elbow surgery in March, is also expected back early next season. His return would stabilize a staff that still carries front-line potential.
Upper-minor league arms such as Brendan Beck and Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz could also contribute if injuries persist. The Yankees see internal development and mid-range signings as smarter paths forward than headline-grabbing trades. It’s a patient approach that contrasts with their once-spending-heavy identity.
Detroit’s demands price out Yankees
Detroit isn’t under pressure to move Skubal. As one of baseball’s top trade chips, the Tigers can afford to wait. Their price remains sky-high — reportedly asking for multiple top-100 prospects, including names like George Lombard Jr. or Spencer Jones.
That request effectively rules out the Yankees. Teams such as the Dodgers, Orioles, and Cubs have deeper systems to meet those demands. Even the Mets, armed with Steve Cohen’s financial muscle, could make a stronger play.
Skubal’s postseason success only boosts his value. He dominated this year’s playoffs, including a 14-strikeout performance in the Wild Card round. Detroit’s rise has given the front office every reason to demand a premium return. But whichever team lands him will face the same problem: locking him up long term.
Cashman prioritizes financial balance
Cashman’s offseason focus is maintaining financial flexibility while reinforcing depth. Big deals for Aaron Judge, Fried, and others already strain the payroll. Ownership is reluctant to cross another luxury tax tier without guaranteed long-term value.
That’s why the Yankees are targeting affordable veteran arms rather than pursuing Skubal or other top-tier names. The goal is sustainability — not shock value.
Pressure from fans and media after the Yankees’ ALDS loss to the Blue Jays has been intense, with calls for aggressive moves. Yet Cashman’s restraint signals a calculated commitment to avoiding desperation.
Strategic patience guides offseason approach
By passing on Skubal, the Yankees continue a more deliberate team-building strategy. Their farm system has rebounded through strong drafts and international scouting. Trading that progress for a short-term arm doesn’t fit the plan.
Fans may crave a splash, but the front office believes discipline will pay off later. The Soto trade showed how expensive rentals can derail long-term goals. This time, Cashman wants the Yankees to stay competitive without repeating the same mistakes.
Once Cole and Rodon return, the Yankees expect a strong rotation built around stability and youth. Holding onto prospects keeps options open for future trades or extensions. It’s a subtle but meaningful change in philosophy for a franchise known for its impatience.
The offseason is still developing, and situations can change. If Detroit lowers its price or other options disappear, the Yankees could revisit the discussion. For now, their message is clear: they won’t chase Tarik Skubal at any cost.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Aaron Judge, Carlos Rodón, Gerrit Cole, Juan Soto, Luis Gil, Max Fried, News
- Tags: ALDS, Brian Cashman, Carlos Rodon, Detroit Tigers, gerrit cole, Juan Soto, luis gil, max fried, MLB trade rumors, New York Yankees, Scott Boras, Tarik Skubal
The Yankees have the pieces to make a trade, but the better question is, with the having all these SP prospects, and 3 SP already signed for at least the next three seasons, do they want to add a 4th? Because one thing is for sure, the price they will be willing to pay DET goes way down without Skubal signing an extension at the trade time.