CHICAGO — Gerrit Cole spent his second inning Tuesday doing an impression of a football referee. He spent the minutes right after it hollering at a real one.
The night had everything but calm. A bare-handed grab off his own shoe tops. A mock penalty flag thrown at his catcher. A pitch-timer violation that set him off at the umpire. For a pitcher still finding his footing after major surgery, it was equal parts circus and command performance.
Through all of it, the Yankees veteran kept the White Sox off the scoreboard. The theatrics never bled into the pitching, and that separation is what made the outing stand out on a night New York could not spare a single run.
The stakes gave every inning an edge. With the middle of the Yankees order banged up, the offense has gone quiet for stretches, leaving no cushion for a starter to lean on. Cole pitched like a man who understood that.
Six scoreless innings, and a season first
The line was the headline. Cole tossed six scoreless innings, allowing four hits and two walks while striking out seven on 99 pitches, and earned the win in the Yankees’ 3-2 decision over the White Sox at Rate Field.
It was also a marker in his comeback. This was his first scoreless start since May 27, not long after he returned from the injured list. In his 12th start back from Tommy John surgery, he looked the part of the pitcher the Yankees have been waiting to see again. For a rotation carrying a contender, that version of Cole changes the math.
The turnaround shows up in the monthly splits. Cole finished July with a 2.97 ERA over five starts, a steep drop from the 6.12 mark he carried across five June starts. His final pitch of the night was a 97 mph fastball for his seventh strikeout to close the sixth.
The length mattered as much as the zeros. The Yankees’ previous two starters had lasted a combined six innings, taxing a bullpen that has been worked hard. Cole’s six frames gave manager Aaron Boone room to breathe with his relief corps late in a tight division race.
The umpire, the pitch clock and a lengthy argument
The flashpoint came in the second. Moments after his glovework, Cole was flagged for a pitch-timer violation, and the call did not sit well. It led to a long conversation at home plate, and the frustration lingered after the inning ended.
Television cameras caught Cole barking toward home-plate umpire Roberto Ortiz from the Yankees dugout once the frame was over. It was not his first run-in with the clock this season, and the sight of him jawing at an official has become a familiar one.
Afterward, though, Cole did not hide behind the equipment. He acknowledged the Yankees had been slow to get set, taking ownership of the violation rather than blaming the timing system alone. It was a small admission, but a telling one from a pitcher who rarely concedes ground to the clock.
He also described a pitcher whose feel for the game is returning, the instincts that were dulled by a long absence coming back into focus. He credited the work behind the plate for the results.
“My instincts are sharper, my reads are better, I’m in the flow of things, I’m getting pitch ideas or pitch locations that are proving to be the right ones,” Cole said. “That comes with sharpening up all facets of the game. Bringing the stuff in tighter, bringing the location in tighter. And to be honest, our catchers have been great. They deserve a lot of credit for the run prevention.”
A juggling act near the mound
The moment Yankees fans will replay came just before the argument, right after the offense handed Cole a 3-0 lead. Colson Montgomery lifted a pop-up in front of the mound, and Cole and catcher Austin Wells both converged on it.
Cole waved Wells off, but not before the catcher stepped on his foot. The ball glanced off his glove. He recovered, snatched it with his bare right hand while backpedaling, then held out his arms and jokingly signaled Wells for pass interference.
Cole made light of the near-disaster afterward, describing a play that nearly got away from him.
“I started to work back into the ball after I called it and Austin stepped on my foot,” Cole said. “I thought I was cooked, thought I was going down, but luckily I made some juggling act and saved it.”
The one true test of his command came in the fourth. Munetaka Murakami opened with a double, and Cole walked Miguel Vargas. He walked Braden Montgomery later in the frame but escaped by getting Tristan Peters to pop out to third baseman Amed Rosario. It took a season-high 32 pitches, then Cole came back out for two more clean innings.
A gritty win keeps the Yankees on the Rays’ heels
All the Yankees offense arrived in the second. Anthony Volpe and Max Schuemann each delivered run-scoring doubles, with Schuemann’s two-run double clearing the third-base bag for the decisive runs. That was the entire output, and it held.
It nearly did not. Angel Chivilli, on his 24th birthday, and Brent Headrick kept the shutout intact before David Bednar took the ninth. Bednar surrendered a two-out, two-run homer to Chase Meidroth, his first runs allowed since May 18 and the end of a 21-game scoreless streak, but he closed it out for the save. Anthony Kay took the loss for Chicago.
The win fit a quiet surge. Despite the injuries and an uneven lineup, the Yankees have won 11 of their past 15 games and sit at 61-46. The White Sox dropped to 55-51.
With the trade deadline days away, the standings sharpen the stakes. The Yankees sit 1 1/2 games behind the Rays for first place in the AL East. Volpe said the grind-it-out wins have become the team’s calling card.
“I think it’s becoming part of our identity and we’re taking pride in it,” Volpe said. “That’s all that matters. As long as we get the job done, we’re just going to keep working on that.”
For Cole, the night ended in high fives rather than a shouting match. The Yankees will take the whole package, referee impressions included.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
