Analyst sounds alarm over Yankees putting all eggs in Aaron Judge’s basket

Follow Us

Despite an aggressive offseason roster overhaul, the New York Yankees face growing skepticism about their championship aspirations as injuries pile up and concerns mount over their dependence on superstar Aaron Judge.

The narrative surrounding the 27-time world champions has shifted dramatically in recent weeks, with one prominent analyst now predicting the perennial contenders could miss the postseason entirely for just the second time in nine years.

Will Leitch of MLB.com raised eyebrows throughout the baseball community with his assessment that the Yankees’ postseason streak might end in 2025, citing vulnerability in their lineup and an alarming reliance on their captain.

“As active, and successful, as the Yankees were in adding players in the wake of losing Juan Soto, this team still has plenty of questions, particularly in that lineup,” Leitch wrote, noting these concerns have only intensified following recent injury developments.

Yankees’ Judge factor

Judge, who turns 33 next month, remains one of baseball’s most dominant forces when healthy. However, his injury history and advancing age present legitimate concerns for a team constructed around his elite production.

“The question always looms over this franchise: What if something happens to Judge?” Leitch wrote. “He’s a player who has dealt with injury issues in the past, he’s getting older and, lest you forget, he’s huge.”

The analyst pointed to the Yankees’ struggles during Judge’s abbreviated 2023 campaign as evidence of their vulnerability. That season, the team posted a mediocre 82-80 record overall, including a dismal 25-31 mark in games without their franchise cornerstone.

“That’s a lot riding on one player,” Leitch continued. “It’s going to be hard enough to repeat with him. The fall would be dramatic without him.”

Injury bug bites early in Tampa

The Yankees’ spring training has been marred by a wave of medical setbacks that threaten to derail their season before Opening Day.

Designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton is battling tennis elbow in both arms with no clear timeline for return. Reigning American League Rookie of the Year Luis Gil has been diagnosed with a lat strain that will sideline him until at least June, creating a significant void in the rotation.

Further compounding these issues, starting pitcher Clarke Schmidt has been limited by persistent back stiffness, while veteran infielder DJ LeMahieu is awaiting MRI results on a troublesome left calf injury that could jeopardize his availability for the season opener.

These health concerns come at a particularly challenging time for an organization still processing its five-game World Series defeat to the Los Angeles Dodgers last October.

Offseason acquisitions miss core vulnerability

Following Juan Soto’s departure to the crosstown Mets on a record-breaking $765 million contract, the Yankees responded with several high-profile moves. They secured left-handed ace Max Fried with an eight-year, $218 million deal — the largest ever for a southpaw pitcher — while adding former MVP Paul Goldschmidt on a one-year contract and trading for former MVP Cody Bellinger.

The bullpen received a significant boost with the acquisition of All-Star closer Devin Williams from the Milwaukee Brewers, completing what appeared to be a comprehensive roster revamp.

However, these additions may not adequately address what Leitch identifies as the team’s fundamental vulnerability: an overwhelming dependence on Judge’s availability and production.

AL East gauntlet throws additional challenges

The Yankees‘ path to October becomes even more treacherous considering the competitive landscape within their division. The Baltimore Orioles continue to build on their young core led by Gunnar Henderson and Jackson Holliday, while the Boston Red Sox have shown marked improvement under new leadership.

The Tampa Bay Rays maintain their reputation for maximizing resources, and the Toronto Blue Jays have assembled a talented roster capable of competing for a playoff berth.

This divisional gauntlet, combined with the Yankees’ injury concerns and Judge-dependent roster construction, creates a legitimate reason for the skepticism surrounding their playoff prospects.

Organizational pressure plays a role

A potential postseason absence would likely trigger significant organizational fallout. General manager Brian Cashman and manager Aaron Boone already face scrutiny from a passionate fanbase growing increasingly impatient with the franchise’s championship drought, which would extend to 16 years should they fail to secure a title in 2025.

For an organization with the Yankees‘ resources and expectations, missing the playoffs would represent a stunning failure that could potentially accelerate calls for change in the leadership structure.

The road ahead

As the regular season approaches, the Yankees face critical decisions regarding their injured players and roster depth. The team’s medical staff will be tasked with navigating Stanton’s elbow issues and determining whether Gil requires extended rehabilitation for his lat strain.

The organization’s response to these challenges will shape its competitive outlook for 2025, with Judge’s health remaining the single-most consequential factor in its championship equation.

For a franchise defined by championship expectations, merely reaching the postseason is considered the minimum standard. Whether the Yankees can overcome their mounting injury concerns and potential overreliance on their captain remains baseball’s most compelling storyline heading into the new season.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us