NEW YORK — The Mets have committed $95 million to a center fielder with less than one full major league season. Across town, the Yankees have a newly crowned Cy Young Award winner still working under the club’s standard years of team control.
The contrast became sharper Saturday when the Mets reached an eight-year agreement with A.J. Ewing, a 22-year-old outfielder who made his major league debut in May. The agreement includes a $25 million club option for 2035.
New York’s American League club has considerably stronger proof of immediate star-level performance in Cam Schlittler. The 25-year-old right-hander finished his first full season with one of the most dominant pitching lines in franchise history.
Schlittler is not approaching free agency. The Yankees retain control through 2031. But another successful season could alter the price of extending the pitcher, making the Mets’ decision relevant to how the Yankees evaluate an early deal.
Mets commit early while Yankees hold a Cy Young winner
Ewing hit .252 with 11 home runs and 25 stolen bases in 2026. He finished ninth in National League Rookie of the Year voting, yet the Mets guaranteed him $95 million before he reached arbitration.
The agreement, which was reported Saturday but had not been officially confirmed by the Mets, exceeds the club’s previous record for a pre-arbitration extension. David Wright signed a six-year, $55 million contract in 2006.
The arrangement gives the Mets cost certainty and the chance to keep Ewing beyond his initial years of club control. For Ewing, it converts several years of uncertain future earnings into a substantial guarantee.
The Yankees face a different decision. Schlittler already has an award-winning season on his resume, which strengthens his negotiating position. He went 14-6 with a 1.95 ERA and 239 strikeouts in 193 2/3 innings across 33 starts.
On Nov. 11, he became the third Yankees pitcher to win the Cy Young Award unanimously, joining Ron Guidry and Gerrit Cole. The performance gave the Yankees an ace they developed internally rather than acquired through a nine-figure free-agent contract.
A $115 million benchmark predates Schlittler’s award
A seven-year, $115 million extension was floated in August, before Schlittler finished the season and before voters made him the unanimous AL Cy Young winner. The estimate was based on the rising cost of elite young pitching and recent contracts elsewhere in baseball.
Tim Britton projected that figure after considering the market established by Cincinnati’s seven-year, $105 million agreement with Chase Burns and Tarik Skubal’s record-setting $32 million arbitration salary.
Britton described the potential contract as a seven-year commitment that would buy out arbitration years and reach into free agency.
“Put that all together, and you’re talking about seven years and $115 million,” Britton wrote.
That figure is a projection, not an offer from the Yankees or an indication that negotiations have begun. A later valuation placed a possible extension between $115 million and $125 million over seven seasons.
At $115 million, the average annual value would be about $16.4 million. The Mets’ $95 million guarantee for Ewing averages about $11.9 million across eight years. The comparison is not position-for-position, but both deals illustrate the cost of guaranteeing future performance before arbitration.
The Yankees could pay more for the same free-agent years
Schlittler’s remaining years of club control are the key distinction. A seven-year agreement beginning in 2027 would run through 2033, covering the five seasons the Yankees already control and only two additional seasons beyond 2031.
That makes the decision more complicated than simply locking up an emerging star. The Yankees could allow Schlittler to earn salaries through the existing system and retain flexibility. An extension would instead shift injury and performance risk to the club in exchange for predictable costs and additional seasons.
Schlittler’s 2026 workload also matters. He threw 193 2/3 innings during the regular season and relied heavily on high-velocity fastballs. The Yankees would be committing long-term money to a pitcher whose recent dominance is exceptional but whose track record at this level remains comparatively short.
The other side of that calculation is already visible. Schlittler recorded 25 starts with one or fewer earned runs, a Yankees single-season record. He held opponents to three or fewer runs in 30 of his 33 starts. Another year at that level could make a $115 million framework considerably harder to negotiate.
A familiar injury risk shadows the extension debate
The Yankees have made an early bet on a homegrown starter before. They gave Luis Severino a four-year, $40 million extension in 2019, only for major injuries to restrict his availability afterward. That history provides a concrete reason to weigh the downside of an early guarantee.
The Mets, meanwhile, have accepted a different type of risk by committing nine figures in potential value to an outfielder with one partial season in the majors. Their agreement does not create an obligation for the Yankees to act, but it shows how a large-market club can use an extension to purchase control beyond the normal timetable.
For Brian Cashman, the choice is whether to establish a price while Schlittler is five seasons from free agency or wait for more evidence that his Cy Young season is repeatable. There has been no confirmed Yankees extension agreement or publicly announced negotiation with Schlittler as of Nov. 22.
For now, the Mets have secured Ewing through at least 2034, while Schlittler remains under Yankees control through 2031 following his unanimous Cy Young season.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















