NEW YORK — Brian Cashman has spent the early offseason searching for trades, but the Yankees general manager acknowledged Thursday that several of his proposals have failed to gain traction with other clubs.
The Yankees have a lineup that needs more production, an unsettled infield and a bullpen still being rebuilt. Cashman is speaking to rival executives and agents as Major League Baseball approaches another potential labor shutdown.
New York has already secured a return from closer David Bednar, who accepted the $23.15 million qualifying offer. That gives the Yankees one established late-inning answer. It does not address every opening on a roster that fell short in October.
Speaking before the Covenant House Sleep Out at Yankee Stadium on Nov. 19, Cashman disclosed that the Yankees have pitched trade concepts to other teams without landing an agreement. He did not name the players, clubs or terms involved.
Yankees are making calls, but offers have not clicked
Cashman had just finished a Zoom call with an agent that lasted more than two hours. He said his front office had also been in extensive contact with other general managers to find possible matches.
Asked about improving the offense after Hal Steinbrenner criticized the team’s production, Cashman acknowledged that the search had already produced refusals.
“I’ve had a lot of different ideas. I floated that haven’t been accepted yet,” Cashman said.
He added that he remained optimistic the Yankees would eventually find moves that improve the club. His admission establishes that the lack of completed trades has not been for a lack of conversations, although it offers no evidence about whether New York’s proposals were rejected because of price, player evaluations or competing bids.
The timing matters. Cashman described constant contact across the market rather than a deliberate decision to hold off until later in the winter. The proposed labor stoppage has not changed that approach, he said.
Cashman faces a tougher decision at third base
Third base illustrates why the Yankees might need a trading partner. Ryan McMahon is owed $16 million in 2027 after batting .213 with a .636 OPS over 124 games in 2026. He supplied defensive value, but the club cannot assume the same offensive output will be sufficient again.
Cashman acknowledged that McMahon could return or that the Yankees could install another player, depending on the available alternatives and acquisition cost.
“We’re having those conversations,” Cashman said.
The club has also examined ways to strengthen the rest of its infield. Cashman identified Anthony Volpe as a possible second-base candidate after José Caballero’s emergence changed the shortstop picture. Those overlapping possibilities make the trade search more complicated than filling one vacancy.
A proposal for an infielder could affect the roles of two existing Yankees, while a deal for an outfielder could change where Spencer Jones and Jasson Domínguez fit. Cashman has not identified which of those needs generated the declined ideas.
Where the Yankees have leverage and where they do not
The Yankees can offer pitching depth in trade discussions, but they also have to preserve enough of it to cover a full season. Cashman has previously identified Ryan Weathers as a starter and indicated that prospects Elmer Rodríguez and Carlos Lagrange remain part of the starting-pitching pipeline.
That creates an important distinction between having available arms and having arms the Yankees are prepared to surrender. A rival club may want a more valuable pitcher than New York is willing to move for a position player. No such demand has been publicly identified in the talks Cashman described.
The offense is another pressure point. Steinbrenner criticized its performance after the Yankees’ Division Series exit. Cashman said the team would pursue additional bats, but offered no promise of a major addition.
In the bullpen, Bednar’s return is firm. Tim Hill has reportedly agreed to a one-year, $2.25 million contract with a 2028 club option, though that agreement had not been formally announced as of Friday morning. Cashman continued to characterize relief pitching as a priority.
A busy offseason without a finished trade
Cashman said the pace of negotiations had accelerated unusually early in the offseason. He was still taking calls during the charity event and said he could return to his office for privacy if needed.
That activity has yet to yield the trade he is seeking. At the same time, the Yankees retain multiple ways to improve through free agency, internal competition and later exchanges with other clubs.
As of Nov. 20, Cashman had publicly acknowledged rejected ideas but disclosed no accepted trade package, target or timetable. For the Yankees, the immediate question is whether the conversations become actual roster upgrades before the market changes again.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















