NEW YORK — The Yankees cut ties with 2024 American League Rookie of the Year Luis Gil on Friday, an unexpectedly abrupt end to a once-promising tenure that cost New York a projected $2.3 million to continue. The decision came at MLB’s Nov. 20 non-tender deadline, when right-handed reliever Fernando Cruz was also allowed to become a free agent.
Gil, 28, had been reduced from rotation cornerstone to a fringe bullpen option during an injury-interrupted 2026 season. The Yankees now face a test of their evaluation: whether his diminished command and fastball justified surrendering club control, or whether a relatively modest arbitration salary could have bought another opportunity to recover.
New York did not merely bypass Gil for a postseason role. It declined to offer him a 2027 contract. That leaves the former award winner free to negotiate with every major league club, including the Yankees, who would need a new agreement to bring him back.
From Rookie of the Year to free agency in two seasons
Gil went 15-7 with a 3.50 ERA and 171 strikeouts in 29 starts in 2024, beating Baltimore outfielder Colton Cowser for the AL Rookie of the Year award. Two seasons later, he finished with a 4.61 ERA in nine major league appearances, only four of them starts.
His smaller 2026 sample was difficult to overlook: 18 walks and 17 strikeouts in 27 1/3 innings, with 21 hits allowed. The Yankees could no longer count on his swing-and-miss stuff to escape the baserunners he created.
A right lat injury delayed his 2025 season by roughly four months. Right shoulder inflammation then sidelined him for more than three months in 2026. He was sent to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in April, returned in a lower-leverage relief role and did not make the postseason roster.
Cashman described a pitcher caught between two roles
The warning signs were evident before the deadline. At Thursday’s Covenant House Sleep Out event at Yankee Stadium, general manager Brian Cashman was asked to assess Gil’s season and the difficulty of fitting him into a deep pitching staff.
“I think he was finding himself,” Cashman said.
Cashman also acknowledged the team had weighed Gil’s usefulness as a starter against a possible bullpen role. That uncertainty matters because the Yankees had once developed Gil as a top-of-the-rotation power arm, not as a pitcher used primarily in low-leverage innings.
“Do we need him as a starter? What does it look like out of the ‘pen? I think that also has a lot to do with our depth, forcing those types of decisions on what’s best for us, rather than what’s best for him,” Cashman said.
The velocity and strikeout decline changed the cost calculation
Gil’s four-seam fastball averaged 96.6 mph in 2024 and approximately 95.3 mph in 2026, according to Statcast. That 1.3 mph decline came alongside reduced strikeout production and persistent command problems. His 2026 strikeout-to-walk ratio was 0.94, a marked decline from his 171 strikeouts across 151 2/3 innings in his Rookie of the Year season.
The money involved was not substantial by Yankees payroll standards. Gil earned $2,162,500 in 2026, and his projected 2027 arbitration salary was about $2.3 million, an increase of only $137,500. Retaining him, however, also would have occupied a 40-man roster spot and committed the club to a pitcher whose health and role were unsettled.
That is the central tension in the move. Gil’s award-winning peak remains recent, but the 2026 numbers offer the Yankees a concrete performance argument for moving on. He was pitching for Tigres del Licey in the Dominican Winter League when the decision was made, giving other organizations a chance to evaluate his stuff.
Fernando Cruz also loses his Yankees place despite 2027 recovery hopes
Cruz, 36, was non-tendered at the same deadline after a partially torn right ulnar collateral ligament ended his 2026 season. The Yankees acquired him from Cincinnati for catcher Jose Trevino after the 2024 season. He struck out 72 batters in 48 innings in 2025, but the elbow injury clouded his value for 2027.
Cruz chose a nonsurgical rehabilitation plan after consulting Dr. Keith Meister. At Thursday’s event, Cashman described an encouraging recovery and said the reliever expected to pitch again next season.
“He’s currently rehabbing and, I think, feeling good and expecting to pitch in 2027,” Cashman said.
Yet the Yankees declined his projected $2.3 million arbitration commitment. Cruz’s decision illustrates that New York was unwilling to carry even modest uncertainty on two pitchers whose recent contributions had been overtaken by injury concerns.
Clarke Schmidt stays while Gil is cut loose
The Yankees made a different choice with Clarke Schmidt. They tendered the right-hander a contract, along with Anthony Volpe, Austin Wells, José Caballero, Luis García Jr. and Ryan Weathers. Schmidt, projected to earn about $4.5 million, was retained despite a lengthy recovery from elbow surgery and a later biceps issue.
Cashman said Thursday that Schmidt was healthy and progressing in his rehabilitation. The difference between the two decisions is not simply salary: New York retained a pitcher it evidently still views as useful rotation depth while making Gil available to the rest of the league.
The Yankees’ decision is final for the tender deadline, but not necessarily for either player’s relationship with the club. Gil and Cruz can sign anywhere, and New York could pursue a new deal at a different price. As of Nov. 21, neither had been announced as re-signed, leaving the Yankees’ rejection of their arbitration salaries as the defining development.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















