NEW YORK — Generations of Yankees pitching greats built careers around championships, dominant seasons and some of baseball’s most recognizable October performances. Yet one distinction remained beyond the reach of nearly all of them.
Cam Schlittler achieved that with his first Cy Young Award.
Whitey Ford won six World Series titles and a Cy Young Award. Roger Clemens collected another during his Yankees tenure. Mariano Rivera became the sport’s most accomplished closer, while Andy Pettitte helped define a championship era. None achieved the particular honor now attached to a 25-year-old pitcher in his first full major league season.
The Yankees’ newest ace had already pushed his name into the franchise record book before the votes were announced. His season brought comparisons spanning the club’s earliest years, its 1940s championship teams and Ron Guidry’s famous 1978 campaign.
On Wednesday night, Nov. 11, Cam Schlittler completed that climb. He captured the 2026 American League Cy Young Award with every first-place vote, becoming only the third Yankees pitcher to win it unanimously. The Baseball Writers’ Association of America gave him all 30 first-place votes and the maximum 210 points.
Schlittler enters Yankees club that excludes several icons
Only Guidry, in 1978, and Gerrit Cole, in 2023, had previously secured unanimous Cy Young recognition while wearing Yankees pinstripes. Schlittler joined them 123 years after the franchise began play in 1903.
The distinction is narrower than simply winning the award. Ford earned the Cy Young in 1961, Clemens in 2001, Bob Turley in 1958 and Sparky Lyle in 1977. None swept the first-place voting for the Yankees. Rivera and Pettitte never won a Cy Young Award.
Clemens did receive unanimous Cy Young honors twice, in 1986 and 1998, but both came before his Yankees career. That makes Schlittler’s accomplishment specifically a franchise first-place-vote milestone, rather than a claim that no Yankees legend ever received unanimous honors anywhere.
Toronto’s Dylan Cease finished a distant second with 110 points. Cleveland’s Parker Messick placed third with 84. The ballots were submitted before the postseason, so Schlittler’s October performances did not influence the award.
One-word reaction followed by a family tribute
Schlittler reduced the landmark voting result to one word in a post on X after the announcement.
“Unanimous,” Schlittler wrote.
He later appeared with his parents, John and Christine, during an MLB Network interview and credited the people who helped him reach the majors. He also made clear that the award had not satisfied his larger ambitions.
“My teammates, my coaches, they’ve really helped my development this year. It’s been a special thing to be a part of, and obviously the job isn’t done yet,” Schlittler said.
Manager Aaron Boone had publicly anticipated the award during the season. His assessment emphasized how rapidly the right-hander had improved since his July 2025 debut.
“Cam has a tireless appetite for hard work and refinement that has allowed his talents to truly flourish,” Boone said.
A 48-year Guidry benchmark falls in an overlooked statistic
Schlittler’s dominance reached beyond the ballot. He finished 14-6 with a league-leading 1.95 ERA, a 0.92 WHIP and 239 strikeouts in 193⅔ innings across 33 starts. He issued 49 walks, allowed only 129 hits and led AL pitchers with 6.2 FanGraphs wins above replacement.
His 215 ERA+, which measures run prevention against league and ballpark conditions with 100 as average, surpassed Guidry’s 208 in 1978. Baseball-Reference’s qualified single-season Yankees records place Schlittler ahead in that adjusted measure, despite Guidry’s lower raw ERA.
Guidry finished his Cy Young season 25-3 with a 1.74 ERA and 248 strikeouts across 273⅔ innings. Schlittler’s advantage in ERA+ does not erase the difference in workload or establish that his entire season was better. It does show that his run prevention, relative to the conditions of his era, reached a Yankees high.
Schlittler’s 1.95 ERA ranks third among qualified Yankees seasons, behind Spud Chandler’s 1.64 in 1943 and Guidry’s 1.74. His 239 strikeouts tied Jack Chesbro’s 1904 total for the fourth-most in a single Yankees season, connecting the current ace to the club’s Highlanders years.
Schlittler’s dominance also extended beyond the Bronx. He posted a 1.16 road ERA in 17 starts and held opponents to a .153 batting average away from home. He allowed one earned run or fewer in a major league-leading 21 starts.
The 1904 Highlanders record that Schlittler reached
Another statistical connection stretches back 122 years. Schlittler’s 239 strikeouts tied Jack Chesbro’s total from 1904 for the fourth-highest single-season figure in franchise history. Chesbro achieved that mark when the club was still known as the New York Highlanders.
That comparison offers a striking difference in workload. Chesbro pitched in the dead-ball era, when starting pitchers routinely worked far deeper into games. Schlittler reached the same strikeout count in 193⅔ innings in a modern rotation that carefully manages pitcher usage.
Schlittler averaged about 11.1 strikeouts per nine innings in 2026, a rate calculated from his 239 strikeouts and 193⅔ innings. His 49 walks gave the Yankees an unusually productive combination of power and control at the top of their pitching staff.
The right-hander was a seventh-round Yankees draft pick out of Northeastern in 2022. He made 14 starts after his major league debut in July 2025, then turned his first complete season into a unanimous award victory.
Seventh-round pick leaves 1904 and 1978 marks in view
The Yankees selected Schlittler from Northeastern in the seventh round of the 2022 draft, 220th overall. He opened 2025 at Double-A Somerset, debuted in the majors July 9 and recorded a 2.96 ERA in 14 starts that season.
In 2026, he allowed no more than one run in 21 starts, a major league high. His 1.16 road ERA over 17 starts ranked among the best performances of the live-ball era for pitchers with at least 100 road innings.
The Yankees have seven Cy Young-winning pitchers in their history and just three who received every first-place vote. Schlittler is the youngest member of that unanimous trio and the only one to enter it in his first full season.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
