PHOENIX — Cam Schlittler arrives at Chase Field found on Saturday with another chance to turn an already dominant season into something even harder for the rest of the American League to catch.
The Yankees right-hander enters his start against Arizona at 14-6 with a 1.95 ERA, 0.90 WHIP and 228 strikeouts in 184 2/3 innings. He has allowed one run or fewer in seven straight starts, a run that has pushed him from contender to the center of the AL Cy Young conversation while the Yankees have secured another postseason berth.
The contrast with his closest challenger became sharper Friday night without Schlittler throwing a pitch. Toronto ace Dylan Cease lasted only 2 2/3 innings in a 7-1 loss to Texas. He walked six, allowed four runs, only one earned, and threw just 36 of 74 pitches for strikes. Sportsnet also measured his fastball at 93.6 mph, 3.3 mph below his season average.
Cease still owns an elite season. After the loss, he stands 11-6 with a 2.40 ERA, 1.10 WHIP and an AL-leading 239 strikeouts in 169 innings. His strikeout total remains better than Schlittler’s. His ERA, workload efficiency and recent command, however, now create a wider statistical contrast at precisely the point when award impressions harden.
For the Yankees, that matters beyond hardware. Schlittler has become the most stable member of a Yankees pitching staff that has dealt with interruptions around Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Carlos Rodon. He is also lined up to pitch at the front of New York’s October rotation, giving his final regular-season starts significance for both the postseason race and the award race.
The Yankees enter Saturday at 89-64, four games behind Tampa Bay, so every remaining start still carries immediate stakes beyond the ballot conversation.
A unanimous poll changes shape of the race
The strongest signal yet arrived this week. In MLB.com’s final Cy Young poll of the season, all 32 voters selected the Yankees ace first in the American League. He received the maximum 160 points. Cease finished second with 126.
The panel asked voters to rank five pitchers on a 5-4-3-2-1 scale while considering both what had happened and how the final two weeks might unfold. That distinction matters. The survey is not the official BBWAA ballot and does not decide the award, but unanimity among 32 MLB.com voters shows how far the Yankees ace’s standing has moved.
ESPN’s latest awards model points in the same direction. Its AXE system lists Schlittler first among AL pitchers at 153.1, ahead of Cease at 145.8. ESPN noted that Schlittler was already 12-6 with a 2.09 ERA through August, then opened September 2-0 with a 0.89 ERA over his first three starts of the month.
Cone’s case explains why numbers carry extra weight
David Cone has framed Schlittler’s value around something simpler than an awards formula. The former Yankees Cy Young winner pointed to how consistently the right-hander has reduced the scoring burden on the lineup and bullpen.
“Where would the Yankees be without him?” Cone said.
Cone then placed Schlittler alongside the league’s most valuable stars when discussing how much New York has depended on him through a season of rotation churn.
“Schlittler’s right up there. He deserves, he deserves definitely strong consideration,” Cone said.
That argument is backed by the shape of Schlittler’s season. Cone noted this week that the right-hander had already made 21 starts allowing zero or one run. Over Schlittler’s last seven starts, MLB’s current split shows a 1.00 ERA across 45 innings, with 57 strikeouts and a 0.76 WHIP.
Cease’s stumble creates late separation point
The most revealing wrinkle is timing. MLB.com’s poll was published before Cease’s shortest start of the season Friday in Arlington. That means the unanimous result did not require his latest setback to separate the two pitchers.
Cease’s line remains strong enough to keep the race meaningful. He has 11 more strikeouts than Schlittler in 15 2/3 fewer innings. But he has also issued 78 walks to Schlittler’s 44, and Friday marked the third straight start in which Cease failed to complete six innings.
Schlittler gets the next chance to answer. The Yankees send him against Brandon Pfaadt on Saturday with New York 89-64, four games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East and already assured of postseason baseball. A strong outing would not make the award official, but it would leave even less room for a rival to change the late-season picture.
One final test remains before October
The Yankees still have more than a week before the regular season ends, and Yankees fans know award ballots are not cast by prediction polls. A poor final start or two can still change the discussion. That is the remaining uncertainty Schlittler must navigate.
What has changed is the burden of proof. Schlittler no longer needs to force himself into the conversation. The latest national measures already put him at the front of it, while Cease’s rough Friday has made the chase steeper.
Saturday in Arizona gives the Yankees ace another opportunity to make that gap look even larger.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
