Judge vs. Steinbrenner? Yankees clubhouse fractures over beard policy

Follow Us

For nearly 50 years, the Yankees‘ facial hair policy was as much a part of the team’s identity as the pinstripes. That changed when Hal Steinbrenner officially lifted the ban, allowing players to sport “well-groomed beards.” But while some celebrated the move as a long-overdue modernization, others—both inside and outside the Yankees organization—aren’t as thrilled.

Why the Yankees ditched the beard ban

The policy, originally implemented by George Steinbrenner in 1976, required players to be clean-shaven except for mustaches. It was meant to reflect discipline and professionalism, but in recent years, it became a controversial rule that some believed limited the Yankees’ ability to attract free agents.

Hal Steinbrenner explained his reasoning behind the change, acknowledging that the no-beard rule had become outdated in today’s game.

“This generation, the vast majority of men in their 20s, 30s, and even 40s have beards. Our new vice president has a beard, members of Congress have beards—it’s just part of today’s culture,” Steinbrenner said. “It was time to evolve, especially if it meant removing a potential obstacle in acquiring top talent.”

But was this truly about making the Yankees more competitive, or did Steinbrenner cave to external pressure?

Clubhouse divide: Not Everyone is on board

While some players welcomed the new policy, Yankees captain Aaron Judge wasn’t among them. Judge made it clear that he had asked Steinbrenner not to touch other long-standing team traditions.

“One of my big things—rules are all about discipline, especially playing with the Yankees,” Judge said. “It’s a disciplined group. That’s one thing I learned from the minor leagues up. You have those certain rules that teach you discipline, teach you a certain way.”

His comments raise the question: does this change alter the Yankees’ culture? Will the organization lose part of what made them unique? Some Yankees legends, including Derek Jeter and Johnny Damon, have weighed in with mixed reactions.

Jeter, who was known for adhering to every Yankees tradition, posted a photoshopped image of himself with a full beard, captioning it: “New Rules!!” The post was lighthearted, but it marked an unexpected departure from his usual respect for Yankees customs.

Meanwhile, Johnny Damon, who once famously shaved his beard after joining the Yankees, advocated for maintaining the old rule. He took to social media to express disappointment, arguing that the ban played a role in fostering discipline within the organization.

The reaction from former players suggests that this isn’t just about facial hair—it’s about the Yankees’ identity.

Did the beard ban actually affect the Yankees in free agency?

One of the biggest arguments in favor of lifting the ban is that it could make the Yankees a more attractive destination for players. Rumors have circulated for years that some free agents hesitated to sign with the team because of the rule.

Pinstripes Podcast co-host Terren Ten shared an anecdote about meeting Jesse Winker and asking if players actually avoided the Yankees due to the policy.

“His response was, ‘You’re never bigger than the team, so most guys will conform with the rule,’” Ten recalled. “But he did admit that for some players, like Austin Wells, who has to shave literally every day, it could be annoying.”

While it’s unclear how many players turned down the Yankees because of facial hair restrictions, the potential impact on free agency remains a lingering concern. If even one All-Star-caliber player declined an offer due to the rule, it could have affected the Yankees’ ability to compete.

Did Alex Verdugo’s beard play a role last season?

Some around the league have joked that the rule change came too late for certain Yankees. Cubs infielder Justin Turner, known for his signature red beard, offered a humorous take on the situation.

“I wonder what made them change their mind,” Turner said. “Did someone look so bad without a beard that they’re like, ‘We got to change this?’ Was it Alex Verdugo? He looked terrible.”

Verdugo, who played for the Yankees in 2024, was forced to shave his beard upon arriving in New York. The left fielder struggled offensively, hitting just .233 with 13 home runs and a career-low .647 OPS. While there’s no direct correlation between his struggles and his lack of facial hair, it was an ironic twist that one of the Yankees’ biggest offseason acquisitions saw his numbers dip after following the policy.

Could it be that the rule change is part of a broader effort to make the Yankees a more attractive landing spot for talent?

The real reason Hal Steinbrenner caved

Ultimately, the Yankees’ decision to lift the facial hair ban comes down to one thing: winning. Steinbrenner admitted that if a player refused to sign with the Yankees over the rule, it was a legitimate concern.

“If I ever found out that a player we wanted to acquire, to make us better, did not want to be here because of that policy—well, that would be very, very concerning,” he said.

That statement reveals a fundamental shift in the organization’s priorities. The Yankees, a team once defined by tradition and discipline, are now prioritizing player comfort over legacy. Whether this decision will help them break their World Series drought remains to be seen, but one thing is certain—this isn’t just about facial hair.

Will this affect future Yankees traditions?

Now that the Yankees have broken one of their long-standing rules, could more changes be on the horizon? Aaron Judge’s concerns about maintaining discipline suggest that players may push back against further shifts in team culture.

What about the strict dress code? The rules against flashy jewelry? Will the Yankees ever allow players to wear non-traditional cleats?

This change has opened the door to discussions that would have been unthinkable just a few years ago. While fans and players adjust to seeing Yankees with beards, the real question is whether this marks the beginning of a new era—or the unraveling of an old one.

During Friday’s game, ace Gerrit Cole was caught on camera reacting to the beard rule change in a subtle yet telling way. Cole was seen touching his clean-shaven face while speaking with a teammate during the Yankees’ 4-0 victory over the Rays in their Spring Training opener. The moment quickly went viral, with fans speculating whether Cole was lamenting the change or simply adjusting to the new reality of a bearded Yankees clubhouse.

The Yankees’ beard policy was more than just a grooming rule—it was part of the team’s identity. With its removal, the organization is now at a crossroads.

Some, like Hal Steinbrenner, believe that adapting to the times will help the Yankees win. Others, like Aaron Judge and Johnny Damon, feel that discipline and tradition are what set the Yankees apart.

Regardless of where you stand, one thing is clear: this decision has ignited a debate that goes far beyond facial hair. The Yankees are changing, and not everyone is ready for it.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us