NEW YORK — The Yankees face a costly decision at third base after Ryan McMahon followed his encouraging arrival in the Bronx with a season that exposed problems on both sides of the ball.
New York acquired McMahon from Colorado at the 2025 trade deadline to stabilize the infield. Now the club is considering how to improve the position without allowing another contract to restrict its offseason spending.
The stakes extend beyond one struggling veteran. General manager Brian Cashman must also address uncertainty at second base and reinforce a roster that has fallen short in October.
That leaves the Yankees weighing whether a replacement would justify paying two players for one starting position. A trade might clear a roster spot, but it might not clear the full financial commitment.
Cashman confirmed this week that third base is under review. Separately, reporting on the trade market indicates the Yankees are prepared to listen on McMahon and understand they may have to absorb salary or accept another unwanted contract to move him.
Cashman acknowledges need for a third-base upgrade
Asked at the general managers meetings whether third base required improvement, Cashman acknowledged that the Yankees got less than they expected from McMahon in 2026.
“We’ll look at it, without a doubt. We struggled there this year a little bit more than I would’ve expected. That doesn’t mean Ryan McMahon’s not capable of a lot more, too,” Cashman said.
The Yankees executive also emphasized McMahon’s contribution after arriving in 2025 and left open the possibility of a rebound. His comments, however, did not guarantee McMahon the starting job in 2027.
“We acquired him and he had a positive impact in 2025 when we got him. 2026 wasn’t the same follow-up. I know he’s capable of a lot more. So we’ll see how this shakes out but we’re open minded to see what we can do to improve the overall club. He’s signed through next year,” Cashman said.
The distinction matters. The Yankees have confirmed they are evaluating the position, not announced an agreement to trade their incumbent third baseman.
McMahon trade carries a $16 million obstacle
McMahon is owed $16 million in 2027, the last season of his six-year, $70 million contract. His performance makes an ordinary salary-clearing trade difficult.
MLB insider Jon Heyman reported Thursday that the Yankees appear ready to move on and recognize that a deal could require them to pay down his salary or receive another unfavorable contract. Pat Ragazzo previously reported that a league source considered New York likely to cover part of McMahon’s remaining money.
That creates a choice between accepting less financial relief now and carrying an underperforming starter into next season. Neither path would automatically solve the offense at third base.
Any trade would also require an interested club. St. Louis has been mentioned as a possible fit for a short-term third-base solution, but no agreement involving McMahon has been reported.
Offensive decline makes his glove less persuasive
McMahon hit .213 with a .279 on-base percentage and .357 slugging percentage in 124 games in 2026. He finished with 11 home runs, 41 RBIs and a .635 OPS.
The Yankees initially valued his defensive reputation. Yet his 2026 fielding measures included zero Outs Above Average and minus-three Defensive Runs Saved at third base. By comparison, he registered six Outs Above Average in 2025.
The combined decline leaves a narrower argument for retaining him as an everyday starter. In 178 games across his Yankees tenure, McMahon has produced approximately 1.1 Baseball-Reference wins above replacement.
There is also a roster-value problem that is easy to overlook: paying down his salary could make McMahon a more attractive acquisition without making him a better option for New York. The Yankees would need a credible replacement to turn a financial concession into a baseball improvement.
Replacement market adds a second complication
The Yankees have investigated alternatives. MLB.com reported interest in free agent Alec Bohm. Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato is another name on the market, though questions remain about his fit at third base in MLB.
Texas third baseman Josh Jung has appeared in trade speculation. Jung hit .299 with an .827 OPS in 2026, but his defensive results were uneven, so acquiring him would involve a different kind of compromise. Those links do not establish that talks have advanced.
New York could also shift Anthony Volpe or Jose Caballero around the infield, depending on how the club fills second base. Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s free agency adds another unresolved position to Cashman’s planning.
The Yankees therefore have intertwined decisions: whether to pay to move McMahon, which alternative can provide more offense, and whether a reshuffled infield can withstand another postseason test.
For now, McMahon remains under contract, Cashman has acknowledged the need for improvement, and the trade market has put a price on New York’s effort to change direction.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















