NEW YORK — The Yankees entered the week with a familiar third-base problem and a chance to address it through the trade market. By Wednesday, one of the most attractive options had landed with an American League rival.
New York missed their chance to acquire Kansas City infielder and 2026 World Baseball Classic MVP Maikel Garcia after the Royals dealt him to Seattle.
The Yankees now face a more complicated market. But there is another trade candidate with more power than the player Seattle acquired. The 21-home-run infielder available commands a smaller projected salary and the ability to handle several positions.
Casey Schmitt emerges after Maikel Garcia trade
San Francisco has floated Casey Schmitt in trade discussions as it searches for pitching, according to ESPN’s Jeff Passan. The development gives the Yankees a possible alternative after their inquiry about Maikel Garcia failed to produce a deal. They have pitching depth that could make a deal possible.
MLB Network’s Jon Morosi reported Thursday that the Yankees checked in on Garcia before Kansas City sent him to Seattle on Nov. 18. The Mariners obtained Garcia, James McArthur and prospect L.P. Langevin. Kansas City received pitchers Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and José A. Ferrer.
Garcia, who helped Venezuela win the 2026 WBC, is under contract through 2030 with a club option for 2031. He won a Gold Glove in 2025 and had a .268 average with a .715 OPS across 82 games in an injury-shortened 2026 season.
For the Yankees, Schmitt offers a different profile. The Giants’ 27-year-old infielder hit .271 with a .301 on-base percentage, .483 slugging percentage, 21 home runs and 55 RBIs in 98 games in 2026. His 21 homers exceeded Garcia’s 2026 output, although their defensive records and roles differ.
Seattle’s pitching payment establishes a demanding benchmark
The Mariners’ willingness to move two starters and a reliever explains how Kansas City landed the pitching it wanted. Seattle president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto addressed the trade after it was completed.
“It picked up steam very, very quickly,” Dipoto said, “because once we showed that we were willing to engage and add to one of our starting pitchers, it got the conversation going, and we were obviously able to get it done pretty quickly thereafter.”
The Yankees could explore a different structure with San Francisco. Will Warren posted a 3.92 ERA with 158 strikeouts over 156 innings in 2026. Left-hander Ryan Weathers finished with a 3.60 ERA and 143 strikeouts across 137 1/3 innings. Both have been identified as hypothetical trade fits, not as pieces in a reported offer.
San Francisco has Logan Webb and Landen Roupp near the top of its projected rotation but is searching for more dependable arms. That need makes a Yankees pitching proposal plausible. It does not establish that either club has started Schmitt-specific negotiations.
A 21-homer breakout hides a critical lineup trade-off
Schmitt’s power and defensive flexibility are the obvious attractions. His plate discipline is the less flattering number: he walked in only 2.7% of his 409 plate appearances in 2026, the lowest rate among 205 major leaguers with at least 400 plate appearances, according to the MLB Trade Rumors analysis of the season.
That works out to roughly one walk every 37 plate appearances. Despite 21 home runs and a .483 slugging percentage, his .301 on-base percentage left a considerable gap between hard contact and overall offensive value. For a Yankees lineup trying to create steadier traffic on the bases, that distinction matters.
The Yankees must also account for Schmitt missing the final portion of the season after tearing the lateral meniscus in his left knee in July. The Giants activated him from the 60-day injured list on Nov. 2. Any acquiring team would have to evaluate his medical outlook alongside his bat.
Yankees can target Schmitt without committing to another star price
McMahon batted .213 with 11 homers and a .636 OPS in 2026. Schmitt’s .784 OPS would represent an offensive upgrade over that production, although an entire season as an everyday third baseman remains unproven.
Schmitt has played third, second, shortstop, first and left field in the majors. His natural position is third base, where Matt Chapman is established in San Francisco. The Giants also have Willy Adames at shortstop and could create opportunities for Marcelo Mayer at second.
A less obvious advantage for the Yankees is roster flexibility: Schmitt could cover third while remaining an option at second if the club reshapes its middle infield. That would limit the need to find separate solutions at two positions. It would not erase the cost of trading a controllable starter.
Schmitt is entering his first year of salary arbitration, with a projected $2.5 million salary, and is under team control through 2029. That price and his 2026 power give him appeal beyond New York. San Francisco has not announced a deal, and no agreement with the Yankees has been reported as of Nov. 20.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















