NEW YORK — The play itself was nothing. A ground ball, a double play, the end of an inning. What came next turned Yankee Stadium into a shoving match.
Pirates reliever Dennis Santana wheeled toward Jose Caballero and started shouting. Both dugouts emptied. A catcher had to wrestle Santana back, not once but repeatedly.
The Yankees shortstop said he barely heard a word of it. He was too far away to make out the message.
But by the time he reached the microphones, Caballero had a message of his own, and it was aimed at everyone.
After the Yankees’ 8-5 win over the Pirates on Monday night, Caballero defended the pitch-clock tactics that set off the eighth-inning scrum and issued a blunt warning to the rest of the league: get used to it.
What set off the scrum
The flashpoint came in the bottom of the eighth. With one out and Austin Wells on first, Caballero grounded into a 1-6-3 double play to end the inning against Santana.
As Caballero turned toward first-base coach Dan Fiorito, Santana blew a kiss and began jawing at him. The two started toward each other, and the benches and bullpens spilled onto the field. Pirates catcher Rafael Flores Jr. held a furious Santana back three separate times.
No punches landed, and no one was ejected. The home crowd fed on the tension, and chants of “Let’s Go Yankees” rolled through the ballpark before play resumed.
The trigger was Caballero’s habit of running the pitch clock to its limit. By rule, a hitter must be in the box and alert to the pitcher with eight seconds left, and Caballero has made an art of waiting until the last instant, hoping to bait pitchers into a violation.
Caballero’s warning to the league
Caballero said he could not hear what Santana yelled, and that he was caught off guard by how fast it escalated. He framed the tactic as a fair fight he intends to keep winning.
“I take my time. I don’t want them to mess with my time. I do my routine as always,” Caballero said. “If you get frustrated, I’m winning.”
He grew more pointed when asked about Santana’s reaction, arguing the anger was aimed at the wrong target. Then came the line that framed his night.
“We all should know about the rules. The whole league should know who I am, what I do in the box,” Caballero said. “For you to get mad about something the league implements, you should be mad at someone else.”
He went further, suggesting Santana was fortunate the umpires had not penalized him on the spot for the delay.
“At this point, he’s lucky he doesn’t get a ball right away,” Caballero said.
In Caballero’s telling, Santana even walked the wrong way after the play, toward the Yankees rather than his own dugout.
“For me, I grounded out into a double play. He got what he wanted. He should go to the other side, and he was walking to the wrong side,” Caballero said.
Santana points at himself
Santana did not deny his frustration, and he mostly blamed his own boiling point. He said the timing of the tactic, late in a game the Pirates were losing, rubbed him wrong.
“It’s nothing against him. I got caught up in the game,” Santana said.
He admitted he was not accustomed to a hitter stalling that long, and that he simply told Caballero to pick up the pace.
“Baseball games have to be quick. It was the eighth inning, losing by three,” Santana said. “We got the quick double play, so I just said, ‘Speed up, my guy.’”
Santana, who owns a 6.05 ERA in 44 games, has struggled through the season, though he said that had nothing to do with the flare-up. Asked whether he owed Caballero an apology, he offered a wry deflection.
“Do you see Pedro Martinez apologize?” Santana said.
Where the Yankees stand
Manager Aaron Boone waved off the dust-up and made clear he backs his shortstop’s approach. He has defended the tactic before, after Caballero drew an umpire’s warning for delay earlier this season in Toronto.
“Frankly, I think more guys should employ it,” Boone said. “That way you take the pitcher out of all the ability to disrupt timing.”
There is a subplot, too. Santana pitched in 23 games for the Yankees in 2024 before Pittsburgh claimed him, so Monday marked a former teammate turning combustible in the Bronx.
The victory pushed the Yankees to 56-44 and kept them 1.5 games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East. Caballero, a utility infielder who has carved out a role with his glove and his edge, left no doubt he plans to keep testing pitchers the same way.
The Yankees and Pirates meet again Tuesday, with the warning already on the record.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
