The Yankees’ tumultuous opening stretch of 2025 has laid bare an uncomfortable truth: Brian Cashman can no longer afford to delay addressing the team’s pitching shortfall.
While Max Fried delivered the club’s first quality start of the season during Wednesday’s victory over Detroit, this momentary bright spot doesn’t mask the fundamental issue confronting the Yankees’ general manager. The next day, Marcus Stroman unraveled making his outing the worst ever since 2023 season.
Decisive action, not patient optimism, is what the situation demands.
Yankees rotation in disarray
The Yankees constructed their 2025 blueprint around ace Gerrit Cole anchoring the staff. That plan disintegrated when Cole underwent Tommy John surgery, sidelining him for the entire campaign. Compounding this devastating blow, Luis Gil’s early-season lat strain has removed another projected starter until at least mid-summer.
This double setback has forced the Yankees to navigate April with a makeshift rotation. Carlos Carrasco has faltered in his veteran role, while rookie Will Warren has shown predictable growing pains that suggest he isn’t prepared for the sustained rigors of a major league starter’s workload.
Although Clarke Schmidt’s return next week offers a glimmer of hope, his presence alone cannot salvage a rotation posting a collective ERA exceeding 5.50 beyond Fried’s contributions. Facing an unforgiving AL East schedule and 13 consecutive games without rest, Cashman must begin exploring the trade landscape immediately rather than later.
Four viable trade candidates for Yankees
While the trade market typically doesn’t fully materialize until mid-season, several high-caliber arms could be available sooner. Here are three potential acquisitions worthy of Yankee pursuit:
#1. Sandy Alcantara (Miami Marlins)
Alcantara’s comeback from Tommy John surgery has shown promising early returns, with an impressive spring followed by a solid start to his 2025 campaign. His 11 strikeouts across 9.2 innings suggest the electric arsenal that earned him the 2022 NL Cy Young Award remains intact.
Miami’s competitive outlook remains dim for 2025, potentially positioning Alcantara as available. Under team control through 2027 at a reasonable salary, he represents the caliber of frontline starters the Yankees desperately require. The acquisition cost would undoubtedly be substantial, centered around premium prospects. However, if the Yankees are serious about their championship window, this represents the bold move their situation demands.
#2. Dylan Cease (San Diego Padres)
Cease presents another frontline option potentially available in the near term. San Diego’s apparent reluctance toward long-term financial commitments, coupled with Cease’s escalating arbitration costs, creates a potential opening. His sluggish 2025 beginning, marked by a troubling 7.98 ERA, might allow teams like the Yankees to strike before his market value potentially rebounds.
Despite these early struggles, Cease’s ceiling remains considerable. His runner-up finish in the 2022 AL Cy Young voting underscores his potential, while his strikeout-generating repertoire offers high-reward possibilities. Should the Padres drift from contention, Cease could emerge as one of the market’s most coveted arms.
#3. Erick Fedde (St. Louis Cardinals)
For a more measured approach, Cashman might consider Erick Fedde. After revitalizing his career with an outstanding season in Korea, Fedde has transitioned back to MLB effectively with the Cardinals. His pending free agency naturally positions him as a likely trade piece.
Fedde wouldn’t command the prospect package that Alcantara or Cease would necessitate, potentially appealing to a Yankees front office hesitant to part with elite prospects. While not profiling as a postseason ace, he could provide crucial stability and innings throughout the demanding summer months.
#4. Michael King (Padres)
Michael King has quietly built a reputation as one of Major League Baseball’s most effective starting pitchers, largely thanks to his devastating offspeed repertoire.
Through two starts this season, King has registered a 3.52 ERA. While slightly elevated in the early going, his track record suggests this is a temporary fluctuation. Historically, he’s maintained a sub-3.00 ERA for much of his professional career, reinforcing his status as a dependable force on the mound.
In 2024, King stepped up as a full-time starter, delivering 30 strong outings. He compiled an impressive 2.95 ERA over 173 2/3 innings, while racking up 201 strikeouts — a testament to both his command and swing-and-miss ability.
Bronx anxiety intensifies
The Yankees‘ struggle to consistently cover innings has become increasingly apparent. Beyond Fried, the rotation lacks dependability, placing mounting strain on the bullpen. As the offense cools following its scorching start, effective pitching becomes even more critical.
While Yankees manager Aaron Boone has attempted to downplay these concerns publicly, the situation’s gravity is undeniable. Stroman’s health remains questionable, Carrasco has proven unreliable, and the team faces an exhausting upcoming schedule without adequate pitching depth.
Cashman’s calculated gamble
Historically, Cashman has adopted a conservative approach to early-season trades, typically waiting until the deadline for significant acquisitions. However, with the Yankees firmly in win-now mode and Cole’s injury fundamentally altering the equation, this traditional patience may prove untenable.
The front office confronts the classic dilemma of balancing long-term prospective assets against immediate rotation needs. While targeting someone of Fedde’s tier might keep the team competitive, only acquiring a pitcher of Alcantara or Cease’s caliber would meaningfully transform their October prospects.
The conclusion appears inescapable: the Yankees must secure pitching reinforcements promptly or risk watching their 2025 championship aspirations dissolve before reaching the All-Star break.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
