Trade talk: Yankees could tap Reds’ infielder to fix third base problem

The New York Yankees find themselves in a crucial position as they prepare for the 2025 campaign, with a conspicuous gap at third base threatening to undermine their otherwise formidable infield lineup. While the team has secured impressive talent with Anthony Volpe manning shortstop, Jazz Chisholm Jr. controlling second base, and Paul Goldschmidt anchoring first, the hot corner remains a pressing concern for Brian Cashman’s front office as spring training approaches.

In their quest to complete their infield puzzle, the Yankees have begun exploring potential trade partnerships, with the Cincinnati Reds emerging as a particularly intriguing possibility.

Understanding the Yankees’ third base riddle

Despite an aggressive offseason that has seen the Yankees dramatically improve their roster through high-profile acquisitions, including the addition of ace pitcher Max Fried and slugger Cody Bellinger, the absence of a reliable third baseman stands out as a significant vulnerability in their championship aspirations.

Initial efforts to secure Nolan Arenado from the St. Louis Cardinals have hit a roadblock, with discussions failing to progress due to complexities surrounding contract terms and prospect valuations. This impasse has prompted the Yankees to pivot their attention toward the Cincinnati Reds, an organization currently experiencing an abundance of infield talent.

Exploring Cincinnati’s surplus infielders

The Reds find themselves in an enviable position with more qualified infielders than available positions. The dynamic Elly De La Cruz has established himself as the franchise shortstop, while recent acquisition Gavin Lux is poised to take control of second base duties. Jeimer Candelario currently occupies third base, while an intriguing competition between Christian Encarnacion-Strand and Spencer Steer has developed at first base.

This wealth of infield talent, combined with the organization’s recent willingness to make bold moves – as evidenced by their trade of Jonathan India to the Kansas City Royals for Brady Singer – suggests the Reds might be open to discussing creative solutions that could benefit both clubs.

Spencer Steer emerges as primary target

Among the potential trade candidates, Spencer Steer has captured the Yankees’ attention. At 27, Steer represents an ideal combination of established production and future potential, offering defensive versatility with his ability to handle both third and first base effectively.

His offensive credentials from the 2024 season speak volumes about his capabilities:

• A robust .275 batting average
• 23 home runs demonstrating significant power
• 87 RBIs highlighting his run-production abilities
• An impressive .820 OPS showcasing his overall offensive impact

Unlike the pursuit of the veteran Arenado, acquiring Steer would align perfectly with Cashman’s strategic vision of building a younger, more sustainable core to complement existing young talents like Chisholm and Volpe.

Recent trade history hints at viable partnership

The groundwork for a potential deal may have already been laid through recent transactions between the two organizations, most notably the Yankees’ acquisition of reliever Fernando Cruz. This established working relationship could facilitate smoother negotiations for a more significant trade involving Steer or another Cincinnati infielder.

The Reds’ potential willingness to part with Steer likely hinges on receiving substantial pitching prospects or bullpen reinforcements in return. Given the Yankees’ well-regarded farm system, they appear well-positioned to construct an attractive trade package.

Strategic benefits for New York

Acquiring Steer would provide the Yankees with multiple advantages. Beyond securing a young, controllable talent at third base, it would allow them to address their immediate needs without committing to an expensive, long-term veteran contract. This approach harmonizes with their dual objectives of competing for championships in the present while maintaining flexibility for the future.

The move would also represent thoughtful planning for the Yankees’ future competitiveness, particularly as they prepare for the eventual decline of cornerstone players like Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole. Integrating rising talents like Steer helps ensure a smooth transition while maintaining the team’s competitive edge.

Analyzing the likelihood of a deal

As negotiations continue, several factors suggest a deal could materialize before Opening Day. The complementary needs of both organizations – Cincinnati’s potential interest in moving an infielder and New York’s urgency to solidify their third base situation – create natural momentum toward an agreement.

Whether the final deal centers on Spencer Steer or involves another member of Cincinnati’s talented infield group, the Yankees appear determined to make the necessary moves to complete their roster construction. With their sights set firmly on ending their World Series drought, which extends back to 2009, Brian Cashman and the Yankees’ front office are methodically exploring every avenue to strengthen their championship aspirations for 2025 and beyond.

The potential acquisition of a Reds infielder represents more than just filling a positional need – it symbolizes the Yankees’ commitment to building a sustainable contender through a blend of strategic veteran additions and emerging talent. As spring training approaches, the baseball world watches with interest to see if these two historic franchises can forge a deal that shapes both their immediate and long-term futures.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.