Yankees not done with Nolan Arenado, revival of trade talks on the horizon

Follow Us

As the 2025 MLB season nears, the New York Yankees are making last-ditch yet significant moves to bolster their roster, with a clear focus on improving their defense. Recent reports suggest that the Yankees could be biding their time, waiting for an opportunity to acquire one of baseball’s premier defensive infielders via trade—Nolan Arenado.

The 33-year-old third baseman, known for his elite defensive skills, could provide the Yankees with a much-needed upgrade at the hot corner. MLB insider Bryan Hoch predicted while speaking on SNY that the New York team would revisit the trade deal with new offers to the Cardinals as the spring training nears.

Nolan Arenado: Defensive prowess and leadership for Yankees

Nolan Arenado’s defensive abilities are widely regarded as some of the best in baseball. In 2024, he logged 1268.1 innings at third base, showcasing his unparalleled glove work with a .977 fielding percentage, six defensive runs saved, and nine outs above average. His defensive metrics put him at the top of his position, and his presence at third base would immediately upgrade the Yankees’ infield. With the team placing a significant emphasis on run prevention, Arenado’s addition could be the defensive boost they need to make a deep playoff run in 2025.

Beyond his defensive skills, Arenado brings valuable experience and leadership to the table. Having played in numerous postseason games and earned multiple Gold Gloves, his pedigree as a winner would be an asset to a Yankees team looking to compete for another World Series title. His veteran presence could also help solidify the clubhouse and provide guidance to the team’s younger players, much like recent Yankees addition Paul Goldschmidt. The Yankees’ interest in Arenado likely stems from his ability to bring both defensive excellence and leadership to the team.

Offensive concerns: Can Arenado still hit?

While Arenado’s defense is a sure thing, his offensive performance has been a topic of concern in recent seasons. In 2024, he played 152 games and hit .272/.325/.394, with 16 home runs, 71 RBIs, and a 102 wRC+. While these numbers are still slightly above the league average, they represent a significant decline from his prime years. Arenado’s isolated slugging percentage, which measures his power, dropped to .123 in 2024, a sharp decline from the .241 mark he posted in 2022.

This decline in power has mirrored the drop in production from his former teammate, Paul Goldschmidt, who also joined the Yankees this offseason. The question remains whether Arenado’s bat can still provide a significant impact in the Yankees’ lineup. While his power numbers have decreased, he still maintains a solid batting average and a strong on-base percentage. His ability to drive in runs and provide consistency at the plate could still make him a valuable asset, especially if the Yankees can complement his offensive output with other power hitters in their lineup.

One factor working against Arenado’s offensive fit with the Yankees is his approach at the plate. He is a pull hitter, known for driving the ball to left field. However, Yankee Stadium’s dimensions favor right-handed pull hitters, and the short porch in right field tends to be more accommodating for hitters who can drive the ball to the opposite field. This discrepancy raises questions about how well Arenado’s hitting profile would translate to the Bronx. His batting struggles in recent seasons may not be an ideal fit for a ballpark that is known for rewarding right-handed power.

Financial and contractual considerations for Yankees

Arenado is under contract with the St. Louis Cardinals through 2027, with an annual salary of $25.5 million, which could be a significant commitment for the Yankees. However, the Rockies, who traded Arenado to the Cardinals in 2021, are still paying a portion of his deal, contributing $5 million toward his 2025 salary. This reduces the Yankees’ financial burden slightly if they decide to acquire him.

Despite this, Arenado’s contract is still a considerable commitment, and the Yankees would need to weigh the financial implications of taking on his salary for the next few seasons. Adding a player with a significant contract like he could limit the Yankees’ ability to make further moves in the offseason, particularly in areas where they may need additional upgrades.

Furthermore, there is the possibility that the Cardinals might be willing to cover a portion of Arenado’s salary in a trade. While the specifics of this potential arrangement remain unclear, such a deal would help ease the financial strain on the Yankees and make the trade more palatable. Even so, the Yankees would still need to make a decision on whether the long-term commitment to a 33-year-old third baseman with declining offensive numbers is the right move.

Is Nolan Arenado worth the gamble?

The Yankees’ interest in Nolan Arenado raises important questions about the team’s long-term strategy. While his defense and leadership could make an immediate impact, the Yankees must consider whether the risk of his declining bat and large contract is worth it. If the Yankees are willing to gamble on Arenado’s offensive resurgence, they could acquire one of the league’s best defenders for the hot corner. However, the potential for continued offensive regression, combined with the hefty financial commitment, makes this a high-risk, high-reward move.

If the Yankees are to move forward with this trade, they will need to manage expectations surrounding Arenado’s offensive contributions. His defense, leadership, and postseason pedigree are invaluable assets, but the Yankees may need to look elsewhere for the power numbers that the St. Louis star has struggled to produce in recent years. The team’s focus on run prevention may be the key driving factor in their interest, as Arenado’s glove would elevate their defense and improve their ability to stifle opposing offenses.

Why Arenado makes sense for the Yankees

Despite the concerns surrounding Arenado’s bat, the Yankees’ primary need is defensive stability, particularly at third base. The Yankees have dealt with defensive inconsistency in recent years, and Arenado’s elite glove work would immediately strengthen the team’s infield. Additionally, with the Yankees’ commitment to maximizing run prevention, Arenado could be the defensive centerpiece the team needs.

Moreover, Arenado’s connection with Goldschmidt could be a major factor in fostering team chemistry and leadership in the clubhouse. Both players bring experience, professionalism, and a winning mindset to the team, qualities that could be invaluable as the Yankees aim for their 28th World Series title.

A trade to watch

The Yankees’ pursuit of Nolan Arenado is a story that will continue to develop as the offseason progresses. While the trade’s potential remains fluid, Arenado’s defensive brilliance and leadership qualities make him an enticing option for the Yankees. However, the financial and performance-related concerns surrounding his declining bat and hefty contract must not be overlooked. For the Yankees, the decision will ultimately come down to whether the defensive upgrade is worth the risk and financial commitment.

As the offseason unfolds, fans and analysts alike will be keeping a close eye on whether the Yankees move forward with a trade for Arenado. If they do, it could be the defensive game-changer the team needs to make a championship push in 2025. However, if the concerns surrounding his bat persist, the Yankees may look for other options to complete their roster. Only time will tell if Arenado will be wearing pinstripes next season, but one thing is certain—the decision to acquire him will have lasting implications for the Yankees’ future.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us