NEW YORK — For three seasons, one job on the Yankees was never really in question. The shortstop was set, the glove was trusted, and the lineup card wrote itself at that spot almost every night. That certainty is gone.
Now the Yankees, at 54-43 and trailing the first-place Tampa Bay Rays in the American League East, are quietly reshuffling the position that once felt untouchable. The change has happened in small doses, a start skipped here, a lineup card without a familiar name there.
The pattern is hard to miss. Across the last three series, against Tampa Bay, at Washington and now at home versus the Los Angeles Dodgers, the same player has started just one game in each set. For a former everyday fixture, that is a striking demotion in all but name.
The message, however unspoken, seems clear. And it arrives at the worst possible moment for the player on the wrong end of it, with the Aug. 3 trade deadline closing in and his name surfacing in deal chatter.
A benching that speaks louder than words
The player is Anthony Volpe, the Yankees’ 2019 first-round pick who won the everyday shortstop job in spring training 2023 and rarely ceded it since. He appeared in 472 of a possible 486 games from 2023 through 2025, a nightly presence up the middle.
That grip has loosened. Volpe sat for a second straight game as the Yankees prepared to host the Dodgers on Saturday, a contest later postponed by rain and folded into a Sunday doubleheader. He had not started Friday’s 2-1 loss to Los Angeles either.
In his place, Jose Caballero has been drawing the bulk of the work and, by the numbers, has separated himself. Caballero carries a .688 OPS to Volpe’s .668, a slim edge, but paired with steadier defense and a stronger arm it has been enough to tilt the playing time.
Volpe’s recent form has not helped his case. He has slashed .222/.276/.222 over his past 10 games, numbers that can suffer when a hitter plays only sporadically. Manager Aaron Boone still calls it a day-to-day arrangement, but the split has tilted.
Boone frames it as a team-first situation
Pressed on the arrangement after Saturday’s rainout, Boone declined to frame it as a benching. He instead cast both infielders as professionals accepting their roles for the good of a club chasing October.
“I think both guys have come in with a focus and are ready to play and all hands on deck,” Boone said. “In both cases, I feel like [they] have a very team-first attitude, and that’s the way we need it.”
Boone also explained why Volpe, once a candidate to move around the diamond, has stayed put at short. The manager pointed to Caballero’s utility background as the reason the veteran is the one who shifts positions when a need arises elsewhere.
“I view Caballero’s versatility right now, because of the experience, so on the days I want to do something like that, I can move Caballero and then play Anthony at short,” Boone said. “When Grish came back, and McMahon, we got a little more holes, so it changed the shortstop situation a little bit.”
Those chances to rotate have dried up since Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon returned from injury, giving the Yankees more stability and less need for a utilityman. The result is less shuffling for Caballero and less time on the field for Volpe.
The trade whispers grow louder
The reduced role has fed a second storyline. With the Yankees expected to be active before the deadline, some analysts believe Volpe could be moved rather than kept as a part-time piece.
SI.com’s Devon Platana named Volpe among four Yankees who could be dealt, pointing to a season line of .246/.342/.326 with one home run and 13 RBIs in 45 games. Platana noted a 12.7 percent walk rate as the lone bright spot, alongside weak hard-contact numbers.
Still, the case for value exists. Platana cited Volpe’s above-average defense, his age at 25 and two remaining years of arbitration control as reasons a rebuilding club might take a chance. He floated the Atlanta Braves, Colorado Rockies and Cincinnati Reds as possible landing spots.
Even a Yankees great has weighed in on the position. Appearing on WFAN, Alex Rodriguez said the club needs a rock-solid presence up the middle and pushed for a splashier fix.
“I would go get Mason [Miller] and [Jeremy] Peña,” Rodriguez said. “Everything starts with that leader up the middle, but you need that guy to be rock solid.”
A prospect and a deadline that could decide it
Looming over all of it is George Lombard Jr., the Yankees’ top prospect, who homered in his first Triple-A at-bat back from a finger injury and went 2-for-3 with a walk on Friday. Boone acknowledged the 21-year-old is forcing his way into the discussion.
“It’s no secret how highly we think of George,” Boone said. “He’s certainly more and more in his development pushing himself into the conversation.”
Boone said a debut this season is possible and that the club is having those conversations internally, though a promotion would land in the middle of a playoff chase. That leaves Volpe squeezed from two directions at once, by a veteran beside him and a prospect behind him.
For now the Yankees insist nothing is settled and that no move to another position is planned for Volpe. Yet the lineup cards keep telling their own story. With the deadline two weeks out, the player who never had to look over his shoulder suddenly has company on both sides.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
