NEW YORK — The captain was back, the ballpark was full, and for most of the night the noise did not match the scoreboard.
A sellout crowd of 46,211 came to Yankee Stadium on Tuesday to cheer Aaron Judge‘s first game in 100 days. What it watched instead was a grind, a low-scoring test the Yankees nearly let slip.
Judge went hitless. The lineup around him managed little for six innings. The Rockies, owners of one of baseball’s worst records, out-homered New York and hung within a run into the late innings. This was not the coronation the building wanted.
It became a 5-3 win anyway, and the reasons had less to do with the marquee names than with the players whose work rarely leads a recap. A defensive gift here, a quiet reliever there, a bottom-of-the-order swing that a healthy Judge might otherwise have rendered unnecessary.
That is the story of how the Yankees pulled through. Not the home run that will lead the highlight shows, but the connective tissue around it. The AL East race gave them no room to be sloppy, and they were sloppy enough to make the margins matter.
A quiet eighth inning that made win possible
Cam Schlittler had handed the Yankees a 2-1 lead after seven innings. The Yankees bullpen still had to hold it, and the first bridge arm was Brent Headrick.
The left-hander drew little attention, but his eighth inning was flawless. He faced three Colorado batters and retired all three, striking out two.
Headrick’s clean frame preserved the one-run edge and set the stage for everything that followed. Had Colorado nicked him for the tying run, the Yankees’ bottom-of-the-eighth burst would have carried far less weight.
Instead, New York came to bat still ahead, and the game cracked open.
The rally began without a swing. Ben Rice opened the eighth with a walk off reliever Brennan Bernardino. Cody Bellinger followed by dunking a double into the left-center gap, pushing two runners into scoring position in what is normally Judge’s spot in the order.
The swing Judge could not provide
Judge was already out of the game, lifted after six innings in right field. Heliot Ramos had taken his place, and Ramos delivered for the Yankees what the captain could not. He turned on a hanging curveball and drove it the other way for a three-run home run, snapping a 2-1 nail-biter into a 5-3 cushion.
The insurance proved necessary. Hunter Goodman launched a two-run homer off Tim Hill in the ninth to pull Colorado within two, forcing manager Aaron Boone to summon closer David Bednar. Bednar struck out Mickey Moniak on three pitches for his 32nd save, ending it.
Ramos’ blast was the swing of the night, but Bellinger’s fingerprints were all over the scoring. He had scored the game’s first run in the first inning after a two-error play, then doubled ahead of Ramos in the eighth. His night bookended the Yankees’ offense.
Judge speaks after a frustrating return
Judge finished 0-for-3 with two strikeouts and a flyout in his first game since May 31, when a stress fracture in his right rib ended his spring and cost him 100 days. He was candid afterward about both the joy of returning and his displeasure at an early exit.
“I feel great. I played half a game, so I don’t know what to say about that,” Judge said. “I respect Boonie, so whatever he says I’m going to do, but I’m not happy about it. But that’s where my boy Ramos picked me up.”
Judge described the timing challenge of facing live pitching for the first time in months, a reminder that his ramp-up will take time even as the postseason nears.
“I just haven’t been in a live game or seen live pitching in three months, so it’s kind of like the start of the year,” Judge said. “But I got work to do.”
Boone, who pulled his captain to protect him, kept the focus on the bigger picture. Asked about clinching another winning season on the same night Judge returned, he framed it as one step, not a destination.
“Off we go,” Boone said. “Obviously, excited to have our captain back.”
The bottom-order fingerprints no one is talking about
Here is the detail that separates this win from a routine one. Every Yankees run traced back to the bottom third of the order or to Colorado’s gloves, not to the middle of the lineup. The first run scored when Luis García Jr.’s soft single to left-center was booted and then misplayed by Jake McCarthy, letting Bellinger race home from first.
The go-ahead run in the fifth was cut from the same cloth. George Lombard Jr., the rookie shortstop, slapped a single up the middle. Ryan McMahon then roped a double to the right field corner against his former club, and when Zac Veen misplayed the carom off the wall, Lombard scored all the way from first.
It added up to a night where the Yankees collected eight hits, committed no errors and let Colorado’s two miscues do heavy lifting. The Rockies out-homered New York 2-1, an unusual power reversal for a Yankees club built on the long ball, yet lost because they gave the game away in the field.
A milestone reached, a bigger one still chased
Schlittler was the engine, as he has been all season. The right-hander struck out 10 over seven innings, allowing one run and no walks, and lowered his ERA to 2.01. He notched his 20th start of allowing one run or fewer, a Yankees franchise record and the most in the majors this year, and picked up his 13th win.
The victory carried a piece of history. The Yankees clinched their 34th consecutive winning season, the second-longest streak in the four major North American sports leagues, trailing only their own run of 39 in a row from 1926 to 1964. Their last losing season was 1992.
Judge, who has chased bigger goals his whole career, kept the milestone in perspective when he addressed it after the game.
“We’re the Yankees, and we’re going to win,” Judge said.
The win moved New York to 82-62, a season-high 20 games over .500. The Yankees remain four games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East with 18 to play, but they opened a three-game lead over Boston for the top American League wild card and hold the tiebreaker. Their captain is back, their ace is peaking, and the margin for error is shrinking by the day.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
