‘Soto the traitor replaces Altuve the cheater’ as Yankees fans’ enemy No. 1

Follow Us

Despite claiming to be prepared for his homecoming, ex-Yankees and current Mets’ slugger Juan Soto departed Yankee Stadium this weekend looking more shell-shocked than steady. The former Yankees sensation, now wearing Mets colors, endured a three-day gauntlet of hostility that transformed the typically composed slugger into a visibly rattled competitor.

What was anticipated as a dramatic return evolved into something far more visceral. Seasoned baseball observers watched in astonishment as the Bronx crowd systematically dismantled the confidence of a player who just months ago commanded their adoration. By Sunday evening, Soto had earned a distinction no player desires – successor to Jose Altuve as the primary villain in Yankees lore.

Bob Klapisch of NJ Advance Media summed it up emphatically, “With only one hit in the Subway Series, Soto couldn’t have picked a worse time to slump. The army of Yankees loyalists crowned him as the new Jose Altuve. But this is a far worse sentence. Altuve the cheater has been replaced by Soto the traitor.”

The crucial difference? While Altuve’s vilification stemmed from perceived cheating, Soto’s crime in fans’ eyes was something more personal – disloyalty.

The $5M decision that changed everything

When Soto inked his mammoth 15-year, $765 million contract with the Mets last December – rejecting the Yankees’ marginally longer but slightly less lucrative $760 million proposal – he inevitably invited backlash. Yet the reception awaiting him in the Bronx exceeded even the most pessimistic expectations.

The numbers tell part of the story: a dismal 1-for-10 performance across three games, punctuated by three strikeouts and four walks. But statistics fail to capture the caustic atmosphere, with profanity-laced chants drowning out any lingering goodwill from his contributions to the Yankees’ 2024 World Series run. His attempts to acknowledge the crowd through helmet tips only seemed to amplify their displeasure.

Cracking under crosstown pressure

The emotional toll became increasingly evident as the series progressed. Friday’s initial wave of disapproval evolved into Saturday’s crescendo, culminating in Sunday’s breaking point.

Soto had initially agreed to wear a microphone for ESPN’s Sunday Night Baseball broadcast – typically an opportunity for players to showcase their personality and connect with viewers. Minutes before the broadcast, however, he withdrew. Reports from NJ.com indicated he expressed frustration about “tired of answering questions about Aaron Judge” and repeatedly explaining his free agency choice.

The sudden reversal spoke volumes.

A former Yankees staff member noted that the moment revealed how deeply this affected Soto. The staff member added that Soto typically embraces attention rather than avoids it, but this time, the spotlight proved overwhelming.

Further confirming his discomfort, Soto bypassed mandatory postgame media availability, briefly informing staff he would return after visiting family members. He never reappeared.

Yankees dominate former teammate

While Soto struggled, the Yankees organization demonstrated resilience through dominant pitching and timely hitting.

Max Fried, whose $218 million contract effectively replaced Soto’s allocation in the Yankees’ financial framework, thoroughly controlled the Mets’ lineup in the decisive contest. The left-hander dispatched Soto twice via strikeout while surrendering just two earned runs over six frames, improving to 7-1 with a league-best 1.29 ERA.

Cody Bellinger – once considered Plan B after Soto’s departure – delivered the definitive statement with an eighth-inning grand slam on Sunday, cementing an 8-2 victory and 2-1 series advantage. Bellinger’s current 13-game hitting streak and .887 OPS powerfully validate the Yankees’ revised roster construction.

“He 100 percent won us the game with that at-bat,” Bellinger said of Jorbit Vivas’ critical 11-pitch duel with Ryne Stanek that set up the scoring explosion.

Captain’s diplomacy can’t mute fans’ verdict

Before Sunday’s finale, Yankees captain Aaron Judge briefly engaged his former teammate during pregame activities. “Just said hello to him… just kind of wished him the best,” Judge later explained. “Things are going to happen. Just keep playing your game.”

This professional courtesy did nothing to temper the spectators’ reaction, as “F—k Juan Soto” chants reverberated throughout all three contests.

“This is probably the way it’s going to be for Juan,” Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor candidly assessed. “He knows that now.”

The crowd’s response transcended typical sports rivalry, reflecting a sense of personal betrayal that elevates Soto’s status in Yankees infamy beyond even Altuve’s controversial legacy.

Mounting evidence of regret

Meanwhile, Soto maintains respectable production, a .246/.379/.443 batting line with 8 home runs and 20 RBIs – these figures pale compared to the .989 OPS he posted during his Yankees tenure. Most concerning is his .132 average with runners in scoring position, drawing disapproval not just in the Bronx but increasingly at Citi Field, where fans demand playoff-caliber performance.

Sources within the Mets organization express growing unease.

One Mets insider revealed that there’s concern about Soto’s lack of enthusiasm. The source indicated that his body language speaks volumes and that he seems fundamentally different.

Observers have noted physical changes, diminished concentration, and even speculation that family preferences rather than baseball considerations influenced his decision to join the Mets.

A potential World Series subway confrontation remains plausible, with both franchises leading their respective divisions. Both rosters feature star power. But should Soto return to Yankee Stadium wearing blue and orange in October, the reception might reach unprecedented levels of intensity.

As former Yankees reliever Clay Holmes, who previously shared a clubhouse with Soto, succinctly observed: “This is New York.”

And here, nothing fades from memory.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us