The Kansas City Royals’ visit to Yankee Stadium has intensified the American League MVP race, fueling debates between supporters of Bobby Witt Jr. and Aaron Judge. Both players have delivered standout performances this season, sparking heated discussions over who deserves the top individual honor.
The controversy was further ignited when Nick Kappel, the Royals’ director of media relations, shared a social media post comparing Judge’s and Witt’s home run totals. The post speculated that if the two players swapped home ballparks, their home run counts would be identical—a claim that quickly drew backlash.
Yankees fans criticized the comparison, arguing it failed to account for the 81 road games each player plays, making it an incomplete analysis. Additionally, they contended that focusing solely on home run totals oversimplifies the broader criteria that should define MVP candidacy.
In the series opener, the Yankees defeated the Royals 10-4, with neither Witt nor Judge hitting a home run. Judge contributed with an RBI single in the seventh inning, but the spotlight belonged to Austin Wells, who drove in four runs, including a three-run homer. On the mound, Carlos Rodon struck out nine over six innings, allowing just three runs. The Royals’ bullpen faltered, surrendering seven runs across the seventh and eighth innings, sealing their defeat.
The game underscored the complexities of the MVP debate, illustrating the challenges of comparing players across different environments and the multifaceted nature of assessing baseball talent. As the season winds down, the debate over Witt and Judge continues to highlight the subjective nature of MVP evaluations, where raw stats only tell part of the story.
Yankees nation rises to support Aaron Judge
Beyond fans: Judge, rival admire each other
The 2024 MLB season has witnessed an extraordinary performance from New York Yankees captain Aaron Judge, positioning him as the frontrunner for his second American League MVP award in three years. Judge’s impressive statistics, including a .322/.456/.694 slash line, 51 home runs, 126 RBI, a remarkable 214 wRC+, and 9.7 fWAR, have solidified his lead in the MLB.com MVP poll with 31 votes.
However, Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. has emerged as a formidable contender, garnering six votes and earning praise from Judge himself. The Yankees slugger commended Witt’s continuous improvement and versatility on the field, expressing admiration for his exceptional season.
Judge particularly highlighted Witt’s extraordinary speed, referencing a recent game where Witt scored from first base on a pop-up that fell between Yankees fielders. While acknowledging his own baserunning abilities, including 16 stolen bases during his record-setting 62-home run season in 2022, Judge humbly admitted that Witt’s speed is in a league of its own.
Indeed, Witt’s baserunning prowess is unparalleled. With a sprint speed of 30.5 mph, ranking in the 100th percentile on Baseball Savant, Witt has amassed 107 stolen bases in just three seasons. He’s on the verge of his second consecutive 30-30 season and leads the majors with 119 runs scored.
Witt’s exceptional season extends beyond his speed. He currently leads MLB with a .335 batting average, has hit 30 home runs, and provides stellar defense at shortstop. His overall performance has resulted in a 9.6 fWAR, marking one of the greatest seasons ever by a shortstop.
As the 2024 AL MVP race unfolds, both Judge and Witt continue to astound each other and baseball fans alike with their Hall of Fame-caliber performances, regardless of who ultimately claims the award.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
