Insider warns Yankees: ‘Stanton can’t play a full year anymore’

Follow Us

Bronx, NYC — The New York Yankees have grown used to a seasonal cycle with Giancarlo Stanton: a hot start in spring training optimism, an inevitable midseason injury, and a late-year redemption arc—if health allows. But this year, insiders are warning the Bronx Bombers not to dream too big.

An anonymous veteran scout recently delivered a sobering assessment of Big G’s future: “Stanton can’t play a full year anymore.” While that may echo what frustrated fans have murmured for seasons, the context adds nuance. For the Yankees, this isn’t just disappointment—it’s strategy.

“This elbow injury? The timing was perfect,” the scout said via Bob Klapisch of NJ Advanced Media. “Instead of six or seven months, the Yankees are getting him for the last three. If I’m Cashman, I’m thinking this is going to work out.”

In other words, for general manager Brian Cashman and the front office, Stanton’s latest ailment—bizarre tennis elbow in both arms—might actually serve a purpose: preserve the slugger for October, when he traditionally becomes a one-man wrecking crew.

A reluctant acceptance

To those following Stanton’s Bronx narrative since his arrival in 2018, the concept of “load management” is no longer foreign. It’s survival. The 2022 season was the last time the Yankees slugger appeared in over 120 games. Since then, injuries ranging from hamstrings to Achilles tendons—and now elbows—have created a career full of starts, stops, and streaks.

The Yankees aren’t banking on Stanton giving them 140+ games anymore. They’re hoping for 60 elite ones down the stretch.

Still, there’s concern.

Another scout monitoring Stanton during his rehab stint in Double-A Somerset this week offered a grim technical critique: “The Schwarzenegger swing isn’t close to being ready.” He even warned the Yankees against rushing Stanton to debut in the Red Sox series.

So while the front office may be eyeing a three-month contribution from Stanton, the path there—both physically and mechanically—remains uncertain.

Polarizing among Yankees fans, respected in the clubhouse

No Yankee divides opinion like Stanton. His tape-measure home runs ignite Stadium crowds. But his slumps—and frequent IL stints—turn those same fans hostile.

“People have no idea how banged up G has been over the years,” Aaron Judge said during spring. “The work he puts in to get ready—it’s all in every day. And he never complains.”

That behind-the-scenes grind remains invisible to most. Stanton doesn’t seek sympathy, and he certainly doesn’t court public adoration. Unlike Judge, who thrives in the public eye, Stanton is more stoic than showman. His rare media sessions are brief, his demeanor serious.

“All of it is just noise,” Stanton once said. “If you’re going to react every time the fans get on you, you’re never going to focus.”

Instead, he spends his time in the cage and in the film room—focused, quiet, and determined.

Stanton: Old-school Yankee in a new-school game

In an era where flash often triumphs over fundamentals, Stanton remains rooted in old-school ethos. No TikTok antics. No walk-up dance routines. Just tape, swings, and strength.

“He would’ve fit in perfectly with the Jeter-O’Neill-Posada crowd,” one longtime Yankees observer noted.

But fans are growing weary of patience. Stanton, now in his mid-thirties, is still under contract through 2027 with a club option for 2028. That long-term financial commitment from the Yankees continues to haunt the franchise, especially when injuries sideline him for chunks of the season.

Even so, the value proposition shifts when October arrives.

The postseason pedigree few possess

Few hitters elevate their game like Stanton in the playoffs. He was electric in the 2024 postseason: seven home runs in 14 games, including four blasts in the ALDS against the Guardians. His raw power and plate discipline became a centerpiece of the Yankees’ run to their first World Series appearance since 2009.

One scout remembered the early years skeptically.

“The first couple of times I saw Stanton with the Yankees, I thought, ‘This guy is not a good hitter,’” he said. “But I came to realize how afraid pitchers are of him. Even when he fouls it off, it rattles you.”

When locked in, Stanton’s presence changes the dynamic of an entire lineup. The fear factor alone forces pitchers into mistakes—mistakes he can still punish.

Where the Yankees stand now

Ironically, Stanton’s absence may have provided an unintended boost for the Yankees. It opened the door for Ben Rice to prove his mettle at the major league level. The rookie catcher has emerged as a key contributor, potentially nudging ahead of Austin Wells on the depth chart.

And even without Stanton’s bat, the Yankees’ offense leads the American League in runs, homers, and OPS. The lineup has clicked—Juan Soto has been worth every penny, Judge is back in MVP form, and DJ LeMahieu has stabilized second base since returning from injury.

But the Yankees know a healthy Stanton in October could be the difference between another heartbreak and a parade.

The stakes and the gamble

The question isn’t whether Stanton can return. It’s whether he can stay back. From June to October. No setbacks. No breakdowns. Just one more run of health and havoc.

The Yankees are betting on it.

They’ve accepted that Stanton isn’t a full-season player anymore. That’s no longer the requirement. They just need the slugger who can hit bombs into orbit and silence stadiums with one swing—when it matters most.

It’s a gamble.

But it might be the one that puts banner No. 28 in the Bronx.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us