NEW YORK — Every contender wants a problem like the one the Yankees suddenly have in their bullpen. The late innings are supposed to belong to certain arms, with roles neatly defined. But Fernando Cruz keeps blurring those lines, and he is making the ninth inning a genuine question for manager Aaron Boone to answer.
The veteran reliever is not asking for a job. He is simply taking the biggest outs whenever they appear, and the more he does it, the harder he is to ignore.
A five-out save that changed the math
The moment that crystallized the conversation came in Tuesday’s 3-2 win over the Guardians. With the Yankees bullpen gassed after burning through arms on back-to-back nights, Boone needed someone to carry the finish, not just record a clean inning.
Cruz answered the call and then some. He recorded a five-out save, striking out four across 1 2/3 hitless innings. The biggest came in a high-stakes spot against Jose Ramirez, one of the most dangerous hitters in the American League, before Cruz struck out the side in the ninth. It was the kind of escape act that wins close games, and it was his first save of the season.
A hot streak too loud to dismiss
Here is what makes the Cruz case so compelling for the Yankees. This was no fluke night. He has been one of the best relievers in baseball for weeks, and the numbers are staggering.
Over his last 14 games, Cruz has thrown 15 1/3 innings and allowed just one run, striking out 17 while posting a microscopic 0.59 ERA and a 0.72 WHIP. Those are dominant figures for any reliever, let alone one operating outside the traditional closer role. On the season, he now owns a 1.84 ERA with 37 strikeouts and a 1.16 WHIP, a line that has shed any hint of middle-relief modesty. His splitter has become one of the most unhittable pitches in the Yankees arsenal.
Boone leans on his trusted arm
Cruz’s emergence has not gone unnoticed by his manager. Boone has increasingly turned to the right-hander in the highest-leverage moments, and he made his appreciation plain after the Cleveland win, explaining the thinking behind using Cruz to close it out.
“That’s how we had to do it,” Boone said after exhausting his other relievers the night before. “I knew we wanted him if we could shorten the game enough, and I knew we were going to want the ball in his hands going through the heart of the lineup.”
That comment speaks volumes about where Cruz now ranks in the Yankees pecking order. When the toughest part of the order is due up, Boone wants Cruz on the mound, regardless of the inning.
The closer puzzle and a flexible answer
None of this means the Yankees are ready to strip David Bednar of the closer’s role. Bednar still owns much of the ninth-inning structure, and hard-throwing Camilo Doval remains a weapon. The smarter takeaway is that Cruz gives Boone a flexible option that does not require a set inning to matter.
If the most dangerous hitters are due up in the eighth, Cruz can handle that pocket. If the ninth needs swing-and-miss after a messy setup inning, he can do that too. The value lies in his strikeout pitch and his nerve to use it with runners on base. October does not care about regular-season job titles, and the Yankees cannot afford to be rigid if Bednar wobbles or Doval’s command slips. Cruz makes the whole unit more adaptable.
Why the timing matters for the Yankees
The broader context only sharpens the point. The Yankees have spent weeks searching for steadier late-game answers, and their bullpen has been stretched thin during a run of tight games. An arm like Cruz, capable of multiple innings and big strikeouts, is exactly the stabilizer they have lacked.
At 36, Cruz is not a long-term breakout story, and his rise does not erase the team’s likely need for bullpen reinforcements at the trade deadline. But it does make the internal picture far stronger than it looked a month ago. If he keeps retiring the hitters who matter most, the ninth inning may shift from a fixed nameplate to a committee built around matchups. For now, Cruz has handed Boone a tempting answer to a puzzle every contender wishes it had, and the Yankees are better for it.
The question is no longer whether Cruz can be trusted late. It is how often Boone can resist handing him the ball.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
