NEW YORK — Friday was supposed to be the day the Yankees finally got healthier. Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon came off the injured list hours before the series opener against the Twins, and both went straight into the lineup at Yankee Stadium.
The relief lasted one transaction. In the same announcement, the Yankees placed Carlos Rodon on the 15-day injured list with left elbow inflammation, a move made retroactive to June 30.
The Yankees are selling calm. The MRI showed no structural damage, the ulnar collateral ligament is intact and nobody used the word surgery.
But one detail should keep Yankees fans from exhaling completely.
The inflammation sits in the same elbow that surgeons opened up on Oct. 15, 2025, when Rodon underwent a procedure to remove loose bodies and shave down a bone spur. Eight months later, the joint that was supposed to be cleaned up has put him back on the shelf, for the second time this season.
The same elbow, eight months after surgery
The October operation was meant to close the book on Rodon’s elbow trouble. Instead, it has framed his entire Yankees season. Recovery from the procedure, along with a late-March hamstring strain, kept the left-hander from making his 2026 debut until May 10.
The elbow never fully went quiet. Rodon told reporters it had bothered him on and off for the last couple of weeks, that he felt discomfort between starts and that he did not feel 100 percent while throwing in the outfield this week. A Thursday MRI found what he described as heavy inflammation.
That history is what separates this IL trip from routine maintenance. A pitcher developing recovery problems in a surgically repaired joint, weeks after the discomfort first appeared, is carrying a different kind of risk than one with a fresh, isolated flare-up.
Rodon still managed to pitch through it. In his final start before the shutdown, he allowed one hit and two unearned runs over five innings in Boston on Sunday, and he owns a 4-2 record with a 3.30 ERA in nine starts for the Yankees.
Rodon calls the MRI result an exhale
The three-time All-Star, one of the biggest arms on the Yankees pitching staff, chose to focus on what the scan did not show. The ligament that decides whether a season becomes a lost year is undamaged.
“I think it’s a pretty big exhale,” Rodon said.
The treatment plan involves a platelet-rich plasma injection, an orthovisc injection and a shutdown from throwing. Rodon framed the length of that shutdown as an open question.
“It could be one of those things where it’s up to a week of no-throw, but it might not be that long,” Rodon said. “It’s based on how I feel.”
Aaron Boone estimated the no-throw period at a few days to a week and made clear the Yankees are thinking about the second half.
“I really feel like Carlos was throwing the ball well and doing some really good things,” Boone said. “Hopefully this is something that gets cleaned up and gets him in a better place so that he can return for the stretch drive and be even more of a factor for us.”
Why the optimism comes with an asterisk
Neither the Yankees nor Rodon offered a firm timetable, and that is where the nightmare scenario lives. Inflammation in a post-surgical elbow can clear in days or linger for months, and the club will not know which version it has until Rodon resumes throwing.
The math is already unfriendly. Rodon will miss at least two starts before the All-Star break, and even a minimum stay pushes his return into mid-July. Any setback in the buildup would drag the timeline toward August, with the Aug. 3 trade deadline forcing the Yankees front office to decide how much to trust his elbow before it has answered the question.
There is also the pattern. Rodon opened the season on the injured list because of this elbow, and the Yankees have still not had Gerrit Cole, Rodon and Max Fried healthy at the same time in 2026. Every plan the Yankees rotation has made this year has bent around that joint.
A rotation with no margin left
The rest of the Yankees rotation makes the stakes worse. Cole entered Friday with a 6.12 ERA over his previous five starts before notching a big win, Cam Schlittler is coming off a four-homer dud, Ryan Weathers has watched his ERA climb from 3.14 to 4.08 over six starts and Will Warren has allowed 13 runs in his last 16 2/3 innings.
The reinforcements are all conditional. Fried is throwing live batting practice and is not expected back until shortly after the All-Star break, Clarke Schmidt faces hitters next week for the first time since his 2025 Tommy John surgery, and Luis Gil has not pitched since April 26.
The farm just got thinner too. Triple-A flamethrower Carlos Lagrange was diagnosed with a capsular strain in his right shoulder and will not throw for approximately six weeks, ending his hopes of helping the Yankees bullpen before the deadline.
For now, rookie Brendan Beck covers Saturday against the Twins, and the Yankees wait on an elbow they thought they had fixed in October. If the inflammation clears on schedule, this is a bad two weeks. If it does not, the Yankees will spend deadline season shopping for a starter they never planned to need.
“I want to be back as soon as I can, whenever I’m ready,” Rodon said.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
