CHICAGO — For the second afternoon in a row, a Yankees starter was brilliant. For the second afternoon in a row, it did not matter.
The offense went quiet when it counted, the bullpen could not protect a late lead, and the game slipped away in the kind of slow, grinding fashion that has come to define this stretch. The result was familiar and painful.
This was not a blowout. It was a scoreless duel that stayed knotted deep into the night, then tilted the wrong way once the free runner arrived in extra innings. The margin was one run, but the sting was larger.
With Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger all on the injured list, the Yankees have no cushion. Every missed chance is magnified, and on Thursday they missed nearly all of them.
A scoreless duel turns into another extra-inning defeat
The final was White Sox 2, Yankees 1 in 11 innings at Rate Field. It sent New York to a four-game series split after the club had won the first two, and it dropped the Yankees to 61-48.
The ending was as deflating as it gets. Reliever Fernando Cruz issued a bases-loaded, walk-off walk to Tristan Peters with two outs in the 11th, handing Chicago the win without a ball leaving the infield. Seranthony Dominguez got the win, and Cruz took the loss.
The number that stung most was at the plate. The Yankees went 1-for-15 with runners in scoring position and stranded 11 baserunners. The game was scoreless entering the 10th.
Then came the record no one wants. The loss made the Yankees 1-8 in extra-inning games this season, the worst such mark in the majors. They also own a big league-high six extra-inning walk-off losses, with no other team holding more than four.
There was more history buried in the box score. According to research shared by analyst Katie Sharp, it was the first time in franchise history the Yankees lost back-to-back games despite holding a lead in extra innings in both.
Boone loses patience with the offense
Manager Aaron Boone has watched his pitchers carry the load for weeks. After another wasted effort, his frustration was plain, and he cut straight to the core problem.
“Look, we got to score a freaking point,” Boone said. “We got to score. I mean, that’s the story, the beginning and end of it. We got to find a way.”
Boone bristled at the steady drumbeat of questions about needing to add bats before the deadline. He pushed the responsibility back onto the players already in the room.
“We can’t expect or rely on anyone walking in to help us,” Boone said. “We got to find it in there. We have more than enough capable guys in there, we just got to be better across the board.”
Paul Goldschmidt, who went 0-for-5 with three strikeouts, three of them with runners in scoring position, offered no excuses. He framed the fix as simple, if not easy.
“We just got to have good at-bats and hit the ball hard. It’s not rocket science; we just haven’t done a good enough job,” Goldschmidt said. “We can’t feel sorry for ourselves.”
Wasted brilliance and self-inflicted wounds
The pitching again deserved better. Ryan Weathers threw seven scoreless innings, allowing three hits and three walks with four strikeouts on 106 pitches, lowering his ERA to 3.99. It was his first quality start since June 24.
His counterpart matched him. White Sox left-hander Sean Burke struck out 10 over six scoreless innings, and the bullpens carried the shutout into extras from there.
The Yankees finally broke through in the 10th. Trent Grisham lined an RBI single to score the go-ahead run for a 1-0 lead. It did not last. Angel Chivilli, so reliable since his recall from Triple-A, came back out for the 10th and gave up a game-tying single to Andrew Benintendi, a name Yankees fans know from deadlines past.
The night was pockmarked by mistakes on the bases. Jasson Dominguez led off the sixth with a double that should have been a triple, but he overslid third and was tagged out. An inning later, Jazz Chisholm Jr. singled, then was picked off. Chisholm later left the game in the 11th with right hamstring cramps.
The bullpen usage told its own story. For the second straight day, Boone kept closer David Bednar out of the game, protecting an arm that had pitched four of the previous six days. The Yankees keep leaning hard on their relievers because the lineup keeps forcing tight, late situations.
A lineup running out of time before the deadline
The context makes the slump urgent. The Yankees have averaged just 3.4 runs per game since the All-Star break, though strong starting pitching has kept them at 7-6 in that span. Over Wednesday and Thursday alone, they went a combined 4-for-31 with runners in scoring position and left 21 men on base.
The standings add pressure. The loss left the Yankees chasing the Rays in the AL East with the trade deadline set for Monday. Judge, Stanton and Bellinger may not return until September, leaving the current group to hold the line.
Chisholm, for his part, argued the team is closer than the results suggest, while acknowledging the sloppy details that keep costing them.
“I think one to two guys in the lineup doesn’t change much, yes, it makes a big difference with the two guys we have out of the lineup, but at the same time, there’s a lot of plays we could do a lot better and play a lot more team ball with,” Chisholm said.
The Yankees now head to the North Side for a three-game set against the Cubs beginning Friday, still searching for offense and still waiting to see whether help arrives by Monday. The pitching has done its part. The bats have not, and time is short.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
