NEW YORK — The Yankees have a decision to make before their closer makes his own. An opening in the trade market could give Brian Cashman another way to protect the ninth inning while David Bednar weighs his future.
The attraction is a championship-tested arm Trevor Megill, with a salary projected well below Bednar’s qualifying offer. The cost would come in young talent, putting another portion of the Yankees’ farm system into play.
New York offered Bednar $23.15 million on Nov. 2. His Nov. 17 deadline leaves the Yankees balancing a free-agent negotiation against a trade market that other clubs can enter immediately.
That tension follows Milwaukee’s 4-1 victory over Tampa Bay in World Series Game 5 at Tropicana Field on Oct. 28. Its closer entered in the eighth inning and recorded the final six outs of the franchise’s first championship.
Brewers open door for Yankees to pursue championship closer
The 32-year-old right-hander was at the center of the Yankees interest last winter. Joel Sherman’s latest assessment points to Milwaukee exploring his trade value.
The report addresses whether the Brewers would consider moving their closer immediately after winning a championship.
“There is a sense that the champion Brewers will at least explore what is available for Trevor Megill,” Sherman wrote, as quoted by @NYYWorldwide.
Megill recorded 30 saves with a 2.63 ERA, 69 strikeouts and 15 walks in 61 2/3 innings in 2026. His career-best 0.89 WHIP and 1.85 FIP strengthened a résumé already featuring a 2025 All-Star selection, 30 saves and a 2.49 ERA.
He has 81 saves over three seasons. In October, he added five saves, 11 strikeouts and a 2.00 ERA over nine innings. Richie Palacios’ groundout to Brice Turang ended the clincher after Tampa Bay scored in the ninth.
For the Yankees, Megill represents a possible replacement for Bednar or a partner in Aaron Boone’s late-inning bullpen.
Other bullpen needs could shape the Yankees’ price
Chicago, San Francisco and Detroit have surfaced as proposed destinations, creating several plausible competitors for the Yankees.
The White Sox reached the postseason with a young roster and a bullpen that led MLB in strikeouts. Their saves leader had only 12, making an established closer an obvious potential upgrade.
San Francisco needs pitching help after a difficult season. A one-year commitment could appeal to a club already carrying substantial long-term obligations.
Detroit declined Kenley Jansen’s $12 million option, opening its ninth inning as it attempts to contend in the AL Central. Megill’s projected salary would leave room for other additions.
Those roster needs create the possibility of competition. Milwaukee also can retain Megill for its title defense, giving the Brewers a reason to demand a meaningful return.
What would Milwaukee realistically want from Yankees?
One published proposal sends Yankees infielder Core Jackson and pitcher Carlos Lagrange to Milwaukee for Megill.
Jackson offers athleticism, a strong arm and infield versatility. Lagrange brings a promise and another developing pitching option. Both appeared in the Yankees’ 2026 prospect rankings.
MLB Pipeline ranks Jackson 11th and Lagrange third in the organization. Jackson reached Double-A, while Lagrange advanced to Triple-A, giving Milwaukee two players at different stages of development.
The proposal illustrates the central exchange: multiple years of potential player control for one season of established relief pitching. Milwaukee’s history of trading players approaching free agency makes that structure relevant.
Milwaukee has an internal closing option in Abner Uribe, who remains under club control through 2030. That flexibility helps explain why exploring Megill’s market can coexist with defending a championship.
Yankees face competition as other clubs eye Megill
The Yankees are among several teams identified as logical destinations for Megill.
Chicago has emerged as another potential fit after reaching the 2026 postseason with an improving young roster. Although the White Sox enjoyed strong bullpen production, their leading reliever recorded only 12 saves, leaving room for an established ninth-inning specialist.
San Francisco presents a different challenge. The Giants are seeking ways to improve their pitching after a difficult season, and Megill’s projected salary could make him more attractive than a lengthy free-agent commitment.
Detroit also has a potential opening after declining its $12 million club option on veteran closer Kenley Jansen. The Tigers remain positioned to contend in the American League Central but need to address their late-inning pitching situation. Megill could provide an immediate solution without requiring the kind of multiyear expenditure normally associated with an established closer.
The Devinin Williams shadow
Megill is projected to earn approximately $8 million in arbitration, up from $4.7 million in 2026, before becoming eligible for free agency after 2027.
Megill’s 69 strikeouts against 15 walks also translate to a 4.6-to-1 ratio. That supplies a performance measure beyond saves for evaluating how he could fit a pitching staff already built around strong relief work.
The Yankees’ previous Milwaukee deal supplies a relevant comparison. They acquired Devin Williams in December 2024 for Nestor Cortes, Caleb Durbin and cash. Williams posted a 4.79 ERA in 2025, lost the closer role and left for the Mets.
Milwaukee later used Durbin in another trade that brought back pitching talent. Megill arrives with a different recent performance record, but the same one-season runway before free agency.
Bednar deadline leaves two bullpen paths open
Bednar recorded 35 saves and a 2.47 ERA in 64 appearances in 2026. Since arriving from Pittsburgh in July 2025, he has delivered 45 saves and a 2.39 ERA for the Yankees.
His return would allow Boone to pair two established closers if Cashman also acquired Megill. His departure would make a ninth-inning replacement more urgent.
The Yankees posted MLB’s second-best bullpen ERA at 3.13, but several contributors have reached free agency. Their AL Division Series exit against Tampa Bay adds postseason stakes to those decisions.
Bednar’s offer remains pending. Milwaukee’s willingness to explore Megill’s value gives the Yankees another option while the Brewers assess what one season of their championship closer could bring.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
