As the Opening Day draws near, the Yankees continue to grapple with mounting rotation injuries. This has intensified trade whispers involving the pitching-abundant Los Angeles Dodgers—particularly centered around former All-Star hurler Tony Gonsolin potentially relocating to New York.
A recent report in Dodgersnation suggests the Yankees and Dodgers have emerged as natural trade partners during the season’s final preparation phase. New York desperately seeks rotational reinforcements while Los Angeles manages an enviable surplus of starting arms. A transaction involving Gonsolin heading east and promising Yankees outfield prospect Everson Pereira traveling west could materialize as spring training concludes.
Yankees’ rotation needs a boost
The Yankees approach the 2025 campaign facing significant pitching shortages. Ace Gerrit Cole, fresh off his AL Cy Young triumph, will miss the entire season recovering from Tommy John surgery. Luis Gil, who captured AL Rookie of the Year honors in 2024, remains sidelined with a lat injury likely keeping him inactive until July. Clarke Schmidt, projected as a mid-rotation contributor, continues battling shoulder issues that may postpone his season debut.
This leaves New York with a thin starting quartet of Carlos Rodon, Max Fried, Carlos Carrasco, Marcus Stroman, and Will Warren. While Rodón demonstrated resilience last season, Fried continues building strength following limited spring activity. Given these circumstances, the Yankees clearly require an experienced, reliable arm to bolster their depleted rotation.
Dodgers have rotation depth to deal
Across the country, the Dodgers have assembled what many consider baseball’s most formidable pitching collection.
After winning the 2024 World Series with Walker Buehler, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Jack Flaherty, and Dustin May holding rotation spots, Los Angeles still possesses the flexibility to trade a starter without compromising their front-line strength. They have Blake Snell, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Tyler Glasnow, Dustin May, and Roki Sasaki ready to lead the 2025 campaign after trading Buehler and Flaherty.
Bobby Miller begins the year at Triple-A after recovering from a comebacker injury, while Tony Gonsolin currently occupies the 15-day IL with minor back discomfort.
The Dodgers’ extraordinary depth extends to promising prospects Landon Knack, Nick Frasso, and Ben Casparius, with superstars Shohei Ohtani and Clayton Kershaw anticipated to join the rotation by midseason.
This abundance positions Gonsolin, earning $5.4 million this season with another arbitration year remaining, as a prime trade candidate.
Why Gonsolin fits for the Yankees
At 30, Gonsolin made his mark as a 2022 All-Star after compiling an impressive 16-1 record with a 2.14 ERA, establishing himself among the National League’s most efficient starters. Injury troubles in 2023 led to Tommy John surgery, causing him to miss the entire 2024 campaign. However, his early spring training return featured three scoreless innings that showcased glimpses of his pre-injury prowess.
When healthy, Gonsolin offers playoff experience, strikeout capability, and team-friendly contract terms—attributes particularly attractive to a Yankees organization seeking immediate rotational help.
Proposed exchange: Pereira for Gonsolin
The trade scenario gaining momentum involves outfield prospect Everson Pereira departing New York in exchange for Gonsolin.
Pereira, 23, impressed in Triple-A last season with a .292/.365/.494 slash line (.859 OPS) and sits on the cusp of major league readiness. However, with Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Jasson Domínguez penciled into starting roles, Pereira’s path to consistent playing time in New York appears limited.
Meanwhile, the Dodgers seek outfield reinforcements, particularly in center field where Andy Pages presents defensive questions. Pereira would provide immediate competition or platoon possibilities in the center while offering long-term value as a controllable young talent.
To balance the exchange, New York might include a developing pitching prospect like Brock Selvidge or Zach Messinger to enhance Los Angeles’ return.
Evaluating risks and benefits
This potential transaction carries calculated considerations for both organizations.
For New York, Gonsolin’s recent medical history introduces uncertainty. However, a healthy Gonsolin could provide 120-140 quality innings at a relatively modest cost—a crucial factor for a team already approaching luxury tax thresholds.
For Los Angeles, trading an experienced starter reduces their depth cushion but addresses immediate outfield needs, particularly given uncertainties surrounding Pages’s health status.
Will a deal happen before Opening Day?
With New York facing urgent pitching requirements and Gonsolin recovering from a minor setback, this trade could materialize during spring training’s final days or early in the regular season, especially if Schmidt’s return faces further delays.
Both clubs enter 2025 with championship aspirations—the Yankees aiming to overcome their 2024 World Series disappointment and the Dodgers targeting another deep October run with their revitalized rotation.
If the Yankees determine Gonsolin can contribute by mid-April, acquiring him could stabilize their rotation immediately while preserving long-term roster flexibility.
As Opening Day approaches, circumstances favor a mutually beneficial Yankees-Dodgers transaction. New York needs dependable pitching immediately. Los Angeles has surplus arms and requires young outfield talent. Should executives find common ground, a Gonsolin-for-Pereira exchange could emerge as 2025’s first significant baseball transaction—one potentially influencing both pennant races.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
