Yankees’ PVS leaderboard stuns: Volpe outshines Judge, Chisholm, and Bednar

NEW YORK — The Yankees reached the All-Star break at 54-42 while carrying one of the largest payrolls in baseball. Three starters missed extended time. The captain sat out two months with a rib stress fracture. The team stayed in the AL East race anyway.

Someone had to hold it together, and the answer is not obvious from the payroll sheet. Sorting the roster by production against cost tells a different story than sorting it by salary.

That sorting is PVS, a contract-efficiency index measuring value returned per payroll dollar. It draws plate appearance, innings and WAR inputs from FanGraphs and salary figures from RosterResource, then benchmarks them against 2026 free-agent valuation tiers and the $780,000 league minimum.

Twenty-three Yankees cleared the playing-time thresholds through the July 14 cutoff. The resulting top 10 contains the names you would expect at the summit, and then it contains five that require an explanation.

How to read the board before you argue with it

PVS is not a talent ranking. It measures how much the Yankees got back for every dollar committed, which means a modest producer on a minimum deal can outrank a superstar.

That is the design, not a defect. Schlittler at 98.9 and Rice at 98.8 lead the board, and neither is a shock. Both made the All-Star team, and both did it on salaries near $800,000.

The qualified pool covers 11 hitters, four starters and eight relievers. Gerrit Cole, Giancarlo Stanton and Carlos Rodon fell short of the thresholds. Paul Blackburn registers as a reliever because 30 of his 32 appearances came from the bullpen.

The five that break the pattern

The first jolt lands at No. 3, where Brent Headrick scores 97.5. Ask a Yankees fan to name the club’s most valuable players and a middle reliever rarely makes the list. Headrick produced 1.2 fWAR over 46 1/3 innings on a $793,000 salary, and he did it while leading the league in appearances.

His placement carries extra weight because of who he passed. A middle reliever outranks two starting pitchers here, and finishes ahead of every high-leverage arm the Yankees paid real money to acquire.

Will Warren is next at No. 4 with a 97.2, and his ranking sits at odds with how he has been discussed all year. Warren went 7-4 with a 4.15 ERA through his first 18 starts, numbers that drew shrugs and landed him on more than one list of the rotation’s problems. The index does not care. He delivered 1.3 fWAR across 98 1/3 innings for $827,000.

Ryan Weathers follows at No. 5 with a 96.3, and the gap between reputation and value is even wider. One social media post this month labeled him a failed acquisition. His 1.6 fWAR over 97 2/3 innings on a $1.35 million salary says otherwise, and it tops Warren’s output.

Neither pitcher was billed as a rotation anchor in March, and neither is discussed as a strength now. Both still outrank every established starter on the roster except Schlittler, because both filled innings at a fraction of what the veterans ahead of them cost.

Paul Blackburn is the fourth surprise at No. 9. A depth arm who registers as a reliever because 30 of his 32 appearances came from the bullpen, he posted 0.4 fWAR across 48 2/3 innings for $2 million. His 84.5 clears every expensive option in the bullpen.

Why Volpe’s number is the strangest of all

The strangest name sits at No. 10. Anthony Volpe scores 82.7, and the Yankees spent the first half trying not to play him. He opened the season on the injured list after October shoulder surgery, and when his rehab window closed in May the club optioned him to Triple-A rather than call him up.

He did not make his season debut until May 13, and only because Caballero fractured a finger. Since then he has split time at shortstop rather than reclaiming it outright. The small sample that resulted is exactly what pushed his score up.

The 1.1 fWAR he produced in 158 plate appearances on a $3.48 million deal is precisely the kind of small, cheap sample the index rewards. Caballero, the man who took his job, ranks two spots higher at No. 8.

Caballero, the man who took his position, sits two spots higher at 87.3 on a $2 million salary. The two players who spent the first half competing for one job both rank inside the top 10 on the same efficiency board.

The bottom of the leaderboard tells the opposite story. Cody Bellinger, fresh off All-Star Game MVP honors, ranks 16th at 56.1 because of a $44.75 million salary. Ryan McMahon sits 19th, Camilo Doval 21st, and Austin Wells and Tim Hill share the floor at zero after posting negative WAR.

Who is missing tells the sharper story

The absences are the reason this board raises eyebrows. Cody Bellinger, days removed from All-Star Game MVP honors, ranks 16th at 56.1, his 2.6 fWAR erased by a $44.75 million salary. Aaron Judge sits 18th at 53.6 despite posting 2.1 fWAR in 261 plate appearances through a rib injury.

Neither ranking is an argument that they played poorly. The board charges for payroll, not performance.

David Bednar ranks 13th at 74.4, because $9 million is steep for a reliever in a model that values relief wins at $15 million each. Jazz Chisholm Jr. lands 11th at 82.6, one tick behind Volpe, with double the WAR and triple the salary. Max Fried, excellent when healthy, sits 14th on a $27.25 million deal.

What the leaderboard establishes is where the Yankees‘ surplus actually came from. Six of the top nine players earn less than $2.1 million. With the trade deadline set for Aug. 3 and a Dodgers series underway in the Bronx, that cheap production at the top is what gives the front office room to spend at the other end.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.