Yankees’ Ottavino stunt casts shadow over credibility, free agent pursuits

Follow Us

Adam Ottavino episode exposes Yankees’ personnel flaws, endangers future signings.

While the New York Yankees battle for victories between the foul lines, their front office is demonstrating equal prowess in maneuvering through baseball’s regulatory framework. Their recent treatment of seasoned reliever Adam Ottavino has illuminated a growing phenomenon across Major League Baseball: strategically navigating roster rule gaps to maintain bullpen flexibility, potentially at the expense of player stability and career predictability.

Ottavino, 39, found himself in the unusual position of being designated for assignment twice by the Yankees within an eight-day span. Initially signed to a major league contract on April 1, he was DFA’d just three days later, then re-signed, only to be designated again on April 9. The veteran right-hander has become the unwitting poster child for an emerging roster strategy that challenges conventional notions of free agency and veteran treatment.

Yankees’ revolving door hurts Ottavino

During his abbreviated Yankees stint, Ottavino’s performance appeared serviceable—1 2/3 innings without allowing a run, three batters struck out, and no hits surrendered. However, his four walks raised concerns, and perhaps more significantly for the organization, he had made two appearances in a three-day window, rendering him temporarily unavailable. Rather than retaining a roster spot for a pitcher needing recovery time, the Yankees opted for complete removal.

“Every day in the big leagues is precious,” Ottavino said in an interview with Foul Territory. “I’ve had a lot of them, but I don’t take them for granted. Yeah, it’s a weird situation, but I think I handled it as good as you can. Went in there and did what I could.”

Ottavino’s position was understood to be temporary from the outset. His initial appearance coincided with closer Devin Williams‘ paternity leave. He briefly returned when the bullpen required fresh arms, only to be released again when Ian Hamilton was activated from the injured list.

The Yankees management maintained transparency about the situational nature of the arrangement.

“I talked to [Aaron Boone] when they DFA’d me and told me to keep going,” Ottavino said. “I was kind of on the fence at that moment, but it was great. I knew what it was.”

Strategic innovation or CBA exploitation?

The Yankees’ approach doesn’t violate any rules—it’s actually remarkably shrewd. With the most recent collective bargaining agreement limiting option assignments to five per season per player, teams can no longer freely shuttle relievers between the majors and minors. In response, organizations are increasingly turning to veterans like Ottavino—players without minor league options who have sufficient service time to elect free agency—to temporarily fill roster gaps.

This practice extends beyond the Bronx. The Atlanta Braves recently employed similar tactics with Jesse Chavez, signing him to a minor league contract, promoting him for a single-game appearance, and then designating him for assignment to accommodate a fresher arm. Chavez eventually re-signed and rejoined the club.

This approach provides two key benefits:

1. Maximum roster efficiency — Teams can ensure every bullpen slot is filled by game-ready pitchers.
2. Financial flexibility — Veterans like Ottavino can be repeatedly signed and released without ongoing financial obligations.

However, the strategy treads a fine line regarding player treatment. Is this practice sustainable in the long term? More critically, does it respect the players involved?

The personal impact of roster manipulation

Ottavino has accumulated experience with six MLB franchises across 15 seasons. He understands baseball’s business realities, and at 39, maintains a practical outlook. Nevertheless, he acknowledged the emotional toll of being treated as an interchangeable roster component.

“I never saw myself back with pinstripes again, to be honest,” he said. “And it felt great. It was something that was pretty special.”

Veteran pitchers with diminishing career runways are increasingly viewed as valuable yet disposable assets—ready for immediate deployment, briefly celebrated, then discarded when rest requirements or roster activations necessitate changes.

Paradoxically, this approach may actually generate more employment opportunities overall. Teams constantly refreshing their bullpen personnel will likely sustain an active free-agent marketplace, providing fringe or aging relievers additional chances to demonstrate their value, particularly in lower-pressure situations where teams prefer to conserve their premium bullpen assets.

Players association monitoring developments

The MLB Players Association’s stance on this emerging trend remains unclear. While the increase in short-duration opportunities benefits veterans who might otherwise remain unemployed, utilizing players as “temporary fillers” potentially undermines job security and diminishes the dignity of full-time professional roles.

Should more organizations adopt the Yankees’ strategy, future collective bargaining discussions may need to address how modern roster utilization impacts service time accrual, arbitration eligibility, and player movement rights.

Ottavino’s career trajectory uncertain

As May begins, Ottavino remains without a team. Earlier this offseason, he signed a minor league agreement with Boston but struggled during spring training, recording a 10.80 ERA across five innings. However, his brief effectiveness with the Yankees—despite control issues—indicates potential remaining value.

His career statistics show a 3.47 ERA with 772 strikeouts in 663.2 innings pitched. With the Mets last season, he logged 56 innings with a 4.34 ERA. While no longer the dominant force he once was in Colorado or during his previous Yankees tenure (1.90 ERA in 2019), he continues to offer serviceable relief options.

Yankees’ approach signals broader industry shift

In a campaign already marked by widespread pitching injuries and roster fluctuation, the Yankees have identified a legitimate, if contentious, method to maintain bullpen freshness. Their utilization of Ottavino as a transactional buffer has exposed a strategic ambiguity in contemporary MLB roster management.

Whether this becomes standard practice or prompts regulatory adjustments remains uncertain. The approach is effective now, and the Yankees are operating within established parameters, even as those parameters appear increasingly malleable.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us