Yankees’ Martian knot: Can Dominguez’s dazzling bat right wrongs of gloomy glove?

Follow Us

The Bronx has found its newest spark plug, and his name still echoes with cosmic potential — Jasson “The Martian” Dominguez. But as the 22-year-old rookie begins to build a case for offensive consistency, his glove is fast becoming the elephant in left field for the New York Yankees.

On Wednesday, Yankee Stadium exploded as Dominguez launched a 398-foot walk-off homer into the second deck against Texas Rangers reliever Luke Jackson. It was Dominguez’s sixth homer of the season and one that capped a thrilling 4-3 comeback win over Texas.

With a 109.7 mph exit velocity, the swing encapsulated everything the Yankees dreamed of when they invested $5.1 million in him as a teenage prodigy from the Dominican Republic. With his blast, Dominguez ended the 974-day wait for the Yankees for the walk-off homer.

“As soon as I hit that, I knew it was my first walk-off. I enjoyed it,” Dominguez said, moments before Aaron Judge and Anthony Volpe drenched him with a cooler during a postgame interview.

Judge, who has become a vocal supporter of the young outfielder, praised his growth.

“Just continuing to improve on his approach,” he said. “The swings he’s taking on pitches in the zone — he’s hammering them. That’s the biggest thing: approach.”

Offensive star power thrills Yankees

The Yankees, now 29-19 and atop the American League East, are watching a potential offensive force blossom. Dominguez is slashing .241/.342/.421 with a 117 OPS+, meaning he’s been 17% better than the average big-league hitter.

Against right-handers, he’s been lethal: a .310 average, .402 OBP, and .506 SLG for a .908 OPS and 160 wRC+. That production places him among the best left-handed bats in the league, especially impressive considering he’s still technically a rookie.

“He’s got a good outlook on things,” manager Aaron Boone said. “You’re really starting to see just how good a talent [he is]. You see the speed. You see the power.”

His performance has helped keep the Yankees’ offense humming — currently ranking second in MLB in runs per game, just behind the Dodgers.

But trouble looms in the grass

Offensive fireworks aside, Dominguez’s defensive performance has been under a harsh spotlight — and not without reason.

According to FanGraphs, Dominguez ranks dead last among American League left fielders in Defensive Runs Saved at -3. Statcast’s Outs Above Average has him at -5. He’s also bottom-ranked in Fielding Run Value and Success Rate Added, tied for last among all outfielders with at least 200 innings. Baseball Savant finds him 8% below what he should be contributing to the Yankees.

In short, his glove has been a liability.

Michael Douglas of the “Made the Cut” podcast didn’t hold back: “He’s tied for dead last among all major league outfielders with at least 200 innings played right now in fielding run value at –4, outs above average at –5, and success rate added at -8%. He’s the only outfielder to be tied for dead last in all three.”

It’s a brutal assessment, and one that’s hard to dismiss when even the eye test shows recurring lapses — poor reads, weak routes, and occasional misplays, like one against the Mets where Cody Bellinger was forced to make a tough angle catch after Dominguez missed a routine setup.

A logjam is coming for Dominguez

The clock is ticking for Dominguez’s defensive growth, particularly with Giancarlo Stanton set to return as the full-time DH. That pushes the outfield rotation into a bind: Judge in right, Bellinger likely in center, and Trent Grisham fighting for playing time.

Boone’s current outfield alignment has little room for error. And while Dominguez’s bat has carried weight, his glove may force the Yankees to reevaluate his usage, especially in tight defensive matchups or late-game scenarios.

“There’s no way the Yankees can be feeling that great about their former top prospect holding down left field when the games start to matter more and more,” wrote Thomas Carannante of “Yanks Go Yard.”

Switch-hitting dilemma?

Dominguez’s split performance as a switch-hitter is another pressing concern. While dominant from the left side, he’s been dreadful from the right: hitting just .109/.212/.261 with a 35 wRC+ against left-handed pitchers.

That’s not just a blip. It’s a pattern stretching back through his minor league career.

At some point, the Yankees might have to confront a hard truth — is it time to abandon the switch-hitting experiment and focus exclusively on maximizing his dominant left-handed swing?

“It’s upside versus consistency,” noted Yankees analyst Giovanni Panicola. “From the left side, he is not far off from being the All-Star left fielder he was always painted to be.”

Still, hope remains

Even with these blemishes, Dominguez is proving he belongs — at least at the plate.

His hard-hit rate sits in the 91st percentile. He’s got top-tier sprint speed. He’s already had a three-homer game this season. And most importantly, he’s 22.

“He’s just not affected by great results or a struggling day,” Boone reiterated after the walk-off. “He just goes to work and plays the game with joy.”

Cody Bellinger, after a recent fielding gaffe, offered reassurance to the rookie: “It’s gonna be good for the future to have that happen right now.”

Indeed, mistakes can be stepping stones. And in the case of Dominguez, the Yankees are betting the upside will far outweigh the growing pains.

The Martian dilemma

The Yankees find themselves in a peculiar but promising bind. In Jasson Dominguez, they have a raw gem who’s lighting up scoreboards — but also testing patience with his glove.

As his bat gains orbit, the franchise must decide how long it can live with the drag of his defense. Can “The Martian” land among the stars, or will his shaky glove keep him tethered to Earth?

Either way, Dominguez is no longer a prospect. He’s a player. And his evolution — or revolution — may determine how far the Yankees go this season.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us