Coordinated Yankees fan conspiracy against Juan Soto, claim WFAN hosts

Follow Us

Juan Soto is facing heat from the Yankees fans over his Mets move and failure with them. This has led to rumors of coordinated fan anger against him.

In a city where sports talk is louder than subway brakes and hotter than a July afternoon at Yankee Stadium, a conspiracy theory aired on WFAN this week has both stunned and amused listeners on both sides of the baseball divide. The claim? That New York Yankees fans might be plotting to infiltrate Citi Field dressed as Mets fans — just to boo Juan Soto.

Yes, you read that correctly.

WFAN’s Evan Roberts, typically regarded as one of the station’s more level-headed voices amid the daily sports chaos, unveiled this startling hypothesis during Thursday’s broadcast. As the Mets navigate both on-field challenges and the emotional burden of Soto’s recent performance struggles, Roberts proposed that Yankees enthusiasts could be deliberately planting negativity at Citi Field to undermine the slugger’s confidence — perhaps even nudging him back toward the Bronx when free agency arrives in 2026.

From 0-for-5 to outrage against Soto

This radio firestorm ignited following a particularly difficult Mets defeat, during which Soto endured an 0-for-5 night with three strikeouts in an extra-inning loss to Minnesota. Adding narrative fuel, Aaron Judge delivered a walk-off home run for the Yankees that same evening — just one day after Soto commented on the adjustment of batting without Judge’s protection in the lineup.

Cue the overreaction, and enter the conspiracy theories.

Roberts’ suggestion that Yankees supporters might disguise themselves as Mets fans to boo Soto wasn’t merely speculative — it ventured into full-blown paranoia territory. Yet in New York’s media landscape, where inflammatory takes and cross-town antagonism drive engagement, the segment rapidly gained traction.

Yankees reaction: Laughter, then fire

If Roberts intended to provoke Yankees supporters, he succeeded — though perhaps not as anticipated. Rather than responding defensively, the Bronx faithful countered with a blend of mockery and astonishment.

One fan sarcastically remarked on social media that Yankees supporters are too occupied with leading the AL East to engage in costume games at Citi Field, suggesting critics should focus less on who might be booing and more on understanding the legitimate reasons behind fan dissatisfaction.

Numerous Yankees supporters pointed out that Mets fans have historically demonstrated remarkable self-sufficiency when expressing displeasure with underperforming stars — particularly those commanding substantial salaries. From early criticism of Francisco Lindor to current scrutiny of Soto, the Queens fanbase has consistently delivered swift judgment.

From the Yankees’ perspective, their focus remains fixed on October aspirations, not elaborate disguise operations in Queens.

Soto’s saga: From Bronx lore to flushing frustration

Juan Soto’s decision to sign with the Mets for a historic 15-year, $765 million deal reverberated throughout baseball circles. The Yankees reportedly came close, offering $760 million across 16 years. Ultimately, Soto selected the Mets, citing opportunity, organizational stability, and the chance to become the cornerstone of an ascending franchise.

However, as the 2025 campaign has progressed, initial excitement has rapidly diminished. Despite a promising beginning, the Mets have stumbled into May amid escalating pressure. While Soto’s overall statistics remain solid, his recent cold stretch — combined with public comments about missing Judge’s lineup presence — has created tension within both the Queens clubhouse and the fan community.

WFAN: Feeding the fire or fueling ratings?

Sports radio thrives on confrontation. Unsurprisingly, WFAN has embraced the Yankees-Mets dynamic now that both organizations field competitive rosters. However, this latest conspiracy theory ventures into unprecedented territory — prompting questions about the station’s boundaries in pursuit of listener engagement.

Roberts wasn’t alone in stirring this particular pot. Fellow WFAN personality Sal Licata has repeatedly criticized Soto’s decision to reject the Yankees’ offer. The narrative that Mets fans are turning against their prized acquisition — while blaming Yankees influence for this development — exemplifies New York’s uniquely volatile baseball environment.

Yankees stay focused amid distractions

While the Mets navigate internal challenges, the Yankees have methodically accumulated victories, powered by a pitching staff anchored by Max Fried and an offense reinvigorated by Anthony Volpe’s development, Cody Bellinger’s production, and Aaron Judge‘s consistent excellence.

DJ LeMahieu represents another storyline developing in the Bronx, as he prepares for rehabilitation games after missing April with a calf strain. Manager Aaron Boone recently indicated LeMahieu could begin his assignment imminently — likely returning to a utility role given strong performances from Oswaldo Cabrera and others.

With championship aspirations clearly established, the Yankees maintain their baseball-first approach — not fabricated booing expeditions to Queens.

Mets must own their narrative

For the Mets organization, this situation transcends one disappointing game or scattered jeers. It centers on managing the immense pressure accompanying astronomical expectations. Soto chose Queens for a competitive opportunity, not protection from criticism.

If fan anxiety surfaces in May, this signals the organization must better insulate players from external noise, rather than amplify it through radio-fueled speculation.

Attributing Citi Field tensions to Yankees influence doesn’t alter fundamental realities: The Mets haven’t met expectations, and Soto’s performance fluctuations have drawn scrutiny. The audience reaction isn’t a Yankees conspiracy — it’s simply the natural consequence of New York’s unforgiving spotlight.

No conspiracy, just baseball in NYC

In the city renowned for sleepless nights and ceaseless conversation, outlandish sports opinions constitute part of daily life. However, Evan Roberts’ “false flag” theory suggesting Yankees fans masquerading as Mets supporters to boo Soto represents a remarkable entry into the ongoing borough rivalry.

Yankees supporters have articulated their position clearly: they’re prioritizing championship pursuits over elaborate Citi Field infiltration schemes. If Soto encounters criticism in Queens, it stems not from pinstriped plots but from Mets fans demanding the elite production their record investment promised.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us