NEW YORK — The number everyone reaches for is 8-4. Twelve World Series meetings, eight won by the Yankees, more Fall Classic showdowns than any other pair of teams in baseball. It is the first fact in every retelling of this rivalry.
It is also the least useful thing you can know about the three games starting tonight in the Bronx.
Because underneath that number sits a second one nobody quotes, and it points the other way.
The two clubs have played 96 times. New York leads 50-46. That is a four-game margin built across 85 years, two boroughs, one relocation and a 43-year gap in October. Strip out the black-and-white footage and the rivalry is close to a coin flip that has been landing on the wrong side lately.
What the record actually says
The split is the story. In the postseason, New York is 38-33 in games and 8-4 in series. In the regular season, the Dodgers lead 13-12. One of those samples is mythology. The other is the only version of this matchup that exists now, and it belongs to Los Angeles.
The rivalry they only just started playing
Strip out October and the two clubs have played 25 games against each other. Ever.
That is the fact that reframes everything else. The 12 World Series meetings produced 71 games. The regular season, across the entire 20th century, produced none. Interleague play arrived in 1997 and still kept them apart, because the schedule paired the Dodgers with the Angels and New York with the Mets. The first regular-season meeting in either franchise’s history came June 18, 2004, at Dodger Stadium. Los Angeles won 6-3.
Before 2023, the clubs had played five interleague series total. The Dodgers never played a single regular-season game at the original Yankee Stadium in 85 years of coexistence.
Universal interleague scheduling changed that. The teams have met every season since 2023, and the sample built since has run against New York.
Yankees vs. Dodgers, regular season only
| Season | Yankees | Dodgers | Venue | Runs for | Runs against |
| 2004 | 1 | 2 | Los Angeles | 13 | 13 |
| 2010 | 2 | 1 | Los Angeles | 14 | 16 |
| 2013 | 2 | 2 | Split | 11 | 13 |
| 2016 | 1 | 2 | New York | 5 | 10 |
| 2019 | 2 | 1 | Los Angeles | 16 | 5 |
| 2023 | 2 | 1 | Los Angeles | 14 | 12 |
| 2024 | 1 | 2 | New York | 10 | 17 |
| 2025 | 1 | 2 | Los Angeles | 14 | 29 |
| Total | 12 | 13 | 25 games | 97 | 115 |
Game-by-game results compiled from StatMuse’s Yankees-versus-Dodgers regular-season log, which lists all 25 meetings since 2004. Postseason games are excluded.
The table holds the argument. New York was 8-8 against Los Angeles from 2004 through 2019. Since the annual format began in 2023, it is 4-5. The gap is narrow. The way it was built is not.
The Yankees have been outscored 115-97 in these 25 games, and nearly the whole deficit is one night: the 18-2 loss on May 31, 2025. Remove that result and the run margin is essentially even. This has not been a rivalry of beatings. It has been a rivalry of near-misses, and the near-misses have gone one way.
Five of the 25 games have been decided by one run. The Yankees have won one of them.
The number that flips the story
Which brings up the split that gets almost no attention, and it is the one that should worry New York.
New York is 26-17 against the Dodgers in its own ballparks. Los Angeles is 29-24 in its own. Home field has been worth something to both. But the recent trend runs one way: in regular-season play only, the Dodgers hold a 5-3 edge in games at Yankee Stadium.
The Bronx has stopped being a fortress in this matchup. Los Angeles took the 2024 regular-season series in New York two games to one. The Dodgers won two of three at Yankee Stadium in the 2024 World Series. The building that hosted Larsen’s perfect game and Jackson’s three swings has, in the modern era, been a place where the Dodgers do fine.
Los Angeles has also authored the most lopsided result in the history of the series, an 18-2 win on May 31, 2025. No Yankees win against the Dodgers has ever been that emphatic. New York’s largest is 12-2, in the 1978 World Series.
Where the ledger and the memory disagree
The Dodgers won the 2025 season series two games to one at Dodger Stadium. But the last game the clubs played was a 7-3 Yankees win on June 1, 2025, in Los Angeles, which means New York carries a one-game win streak into tonight. That is the entire active edge: one game, 13 months old.
The historical pattern here is not about talent. It is about margin.
In 1941, a passed ball on a swinging third strike turned Game 4. Mickey Owen could not hold the pitch, Tommy Henrich reached first, and the Yankees scored four in the ninth to win 7-4.
In 1947, Al Gionfriddo robbed Joe DiMaggio of a game-tying three-run homer in Game 6 and forced a Game 7 the Dodgers still lost. In 2024, the margin ran the other way.
Jeff Passan of ESPN made that point in writing after Game 5, and it remains the most precise summary of how the 2024 series was actually decided.
The Dodgers “scored 25 runs to the Yankees’ 24 … the Dodgers won the World Series in convincing fashion, over five games, because they were better in close contests,” Passan wrote.
The specifics were brutal for New York: a walk-off grand slam surrendered to Freddie Freeman in Game 1, and a 5-0 lead surrendered in Game 5. One run of separation across an entire World Series, and none of it went the Yankees’ way.
What the Bronx is actually playing for
The Yankees open the second half at 54-42, second in the AL East behind Tampa Bay at 56-38. The Dodgers arrive as the best team in baseball at 61-36, holding the largest division lead in the sport.
First pitch is 7:05 p.m. Friday at Yankee Stadium, the opener of a three-game set running through Sunday. No results exist yet. Anyone framing this weekend as a verdict is guessing.
What can be said is narrower. The Yankees own the record and has lost the recent argument. It leads 50-46 overall and trails 13-12 in the only format the clubs now play regularly. It has eight series wins and none since 1978. It has the building and has not been protecting it.
Three games in July do not settle an 85-year ledger. They do decide whether New York closes a one-game gap in the modern column, or whether Los Angeles takes a lead in the Bronx that the record book will keep.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
