NEW YORK — The Yankees went shopping for a right-handed catcher last summer and ran into a Colorado team unwilling to part with its best power hitter. The Rockies may now be prepared to listen, and New York has a resource that could make a return call worthwhile: starting pitching.
Colorado is facing a difficult choice with Hunter Goodman after a 58-104 season. The 27-year-old catcher hit 41 home runs in 2026, but the Rockies have far more pressing problems on the mound than behind the plate. Rival clubs believe Colorado is more receptive to moving him than it was at the trade deadline.
Yankees wanted Goodman before Colorado shut the door
The Yankees were one of three American League East clubs linked to Goodman in July. The Red Sox and Rays also showed interest, according to reporting by Ken Rosenthal. Colorado sought ambitious, multipiece returns, with rival teams’ top prospects figuring in the demands. Goodman stayed put.
His production has since made him more expensive, not less. Goodman followed 31 homers in 2025 with 41 in 2026 and finished the latest season with an .839 OPS and 88 RBIs. Twenty-five of those home runs came away from Coors Field, an NL record for a primary catcher that surpassed Johnny Bench’s 24 road homers in 1972.
That road total matters to the Yankees. A large part of the usual objection to acquiring a Rockies hitter concerns how much of his offense will travel. Goodman provided unusually direct evidence that his home-run power was not limited to Denver.
A 41-homer catcher could change the Yankees’ AL East equation
Goodman would supply a type of offense few catchers can match. His right-handed power also fits a specific Yankees need. Cashman said after the general managers meetings that the club wanted a right-handed-hitting catcher to pair with Austin Wells.
The attraction extends beyond the Yankees’ lineup. Boston and Tampa Bay were involved in the summer market, so a New York deal would also prevent a known division rival from acquiring the same bat. There is no confirmation those clubs have renewed their pursuits this month.
The fit is not entirely clean. Goodman is a more potent hitter than a proven finished product defensively. He has spoken about improving his game-calling, while Colorado has emphasized his development behind the plate. New York would have to decide whether to use him as its primary catcher, pair him with Wells or spread some of his at-bats between catcher and designated hitter.
Rockies’ pitching crisis gives Cashman another opening
The central change is Colorado’s willingness to consider what Goodman could bring back. MLB Network’s Jon Morosi reported that opposing clubs believe the Rockies are more open to a trade this winter. Ken Rosenthal also outlined the logic of moving a star hitter to address a deeply deficient rotation.
“If you can get multiple starting pitchers for him, and succeed in that quest, well that’s something maybe you should consider doing,” Rosenthal said.
Colorado’s staff finished 2026 with a 5.59 ERA, worst in the majors, and its starters posted a 6.28 ERA. That gives president of baseball operations Paul DePodesta an incentive to consider something other than an offer built mainly around position-player prospects.
New York can construct several versions of a pitching-led proposal. Will Warren made 29 starts and recorded a 3.92 ERA in 2026. Ryan Weathers is another major league-ready left-handed option. Brian Cashman has also identified Elmer Rodríguez as a future starter, while Clarke Schmidt offers an alternative with a more complicated injury history.
A possible framework would pair one of Warren or Weathers with Rodríguez and outfielder Jasson Domínguez. Schmidt could be explored as a different major league arm, though health and availability would shape his value. That is a hypothetical package, not a request from Colorado or an offer made by New York.
What would Colorado realistically demand for Goodman?
The Rockies have good reason to hold out for a premium return. Goodman is under team control through 2029, and a 41-homer catcher with multiple years of control is not a player a rebuilding club must sell cheaply. Colorado also has younger catchers moving through its system, which gives the front office some flexibility if it receives the right pitching offer.
The Yankees face their own limits. Rodriguez is one of their better pitching prospects. Warren and Weathers are part of the rotation competition for 2027. Trading both a current starter and a future one would weaken the depth Cashman has publicly described as a strength. Adding Domínguez would make the decision more consequential.
For now, there is a renewed opening. Colorado appears willing to hear offers for Goodman, and the Yankees have the pitching inventory to make one serious. Whether Cashman is willing to sacrifice enough of it is the unresolved part of this trade discussion.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
















