WASHINGTON, D.C. — Cam Schlittler spent the first half building a resume that pointed straight to a mound in Philadelphia. He led the American League in ERA. He piled up strikeouts. He looked like the obvious choice to start the All-Star Game on Tuesday.
Then he walked into the Yankees manager’s office Sunday morning and asked to step back from all of it.
The 25-year-old right-hander told Aaron Boone he did not plan to pitch in the Midsummer Classic at Citizens Bank Park, even though he was healthy and technically available. It was a stunning turn for a pitcher who had earned every bit of the spotlight.
What he said next explained why. His answer had nothing to do with snubs or slights and everything to do with the state of a rotation held together by tape.
A decision made before the starter was named
The timing looked suspicious from the outside. Late Saturday night, Blue Jays manager John Schneider, running the American League squad, tabbed his own ace, Dylan Cease, to start. Many assumed Schlittler pulled back only after losing the assignment.
Both the pitcher and his manager pushed back on that read. The Yankees right-hander said he reached his conclusion first, then learned about Cease afterward.
Two days before the All-Star break started, Cam Schlittler made it clear that he was not going to start All-Star game despite his first selection and a chance, “It’d be a cool experience. Not gonna lie, I’m not too worried about it. I got more things to worry about in terms of just this team and how we’ve been playing, and I like how it’s been the last couple days.”
“Congrats to Dylan. He’s been great this year. He deserves that,” Schlittler said.
Schneider, for his part, said the choice was never a fallback. He pointed to Cease leading the league in strikeouts as the reason, and said the outcome would not have changed.
“If Cam was going to pitch, my decision was still going to be Dylan,” Schneider said.
The numbers make it a genuine debate. Cease carries a 2.56 ERA with 148 strikeouts in 98 1/3 innings. Schlittler counters with a league-best 2.05 ERA, 137 strikeouts and a 0.94 WHIP across 20 starts. Cristopher Sanchez drew the National League nod at his home park. Either way, the Yankees had a legitimate Cy Young contender left out of the starting picture.
Why the arm mattered more than the honor
Strip away the starter drama and Schlittler’s reasoning came into focus. The exhibition would have fallen on his normal between-starts throw day. Ramping up to full intensity in that setting is where the risk lives.
He was blunt about the danger of pushing it. “I don’t want to put that risk in there of letting the team down,” Schlittler said. “If I were to not recover the right way, and I’m dragging a little bit, then that wouldn’t benefit anyone. But I’m on the roster, and if they need me, then I’ll throw.”
Boone backed his young starter without hesitation. The Yankees manager said his pitcher was fine physically but had grown wary of treating a recovery day like a max-effort start.
“I just wanted him to be thoughtful in how he came to that decision,” Boone said.
He was satisfied his pitcher had weighed it fully and was healthy either way. “There’s nothing wrong with him, he feels good,” Boone said.
A rotation running on fumes
The context behind the caution is heavy. The Yankees are without Carlos Rodon, who is dealing with elbow inflammation, and Max Fried, who has an elbow bone bruise.
The arms that remain are stretched. Gerrit Cole is only nine major league starts removed from Tommy John surgery, while Will Warren and Ryan Weathers have already pushed past their previous workload highs.
Schlittler himself is climbing into new territory. He has thrown 118 2/3 innings this season and is on pace to blow past his career high of 149 2/3, which he set last year between the majors and minors.
There was also a warning sign on Saturday. Even while averaging nearly 99 mph, Schlittler gave up two first-inning homers and walked four in his final start before the break. A national broadcast analyst noted that something seemed off. For a Yankees rotation with no margin, resting a prized arm made plain sense.
Where Schlittler goes from here
Skipping the game does not mean skipping the week. Schlittler still plans to travel to Philadelphia for the festivities. He has volunteered to serve as Ben Rice’s helper during Monday’s Home Run Derby, and his parents, siblings and other family will be on hand.
He made clear the Yankees star sees the trip as one to soak in, not sulk through. “The whole experience will be great,” Schlittler said.
Rice enters the break second in the American League with 29 home runs, and Cody Bellinger joins them as a three-time All-Star. The Yankees will have a presence in Philadelphia even without their best pitcher on the mound.
The bigger prize sits five days out. Schlittler is lined up to start the Yankees‘ first game of the second half, a Friday night showdown with the reigning champion Dodgers in the Bronx. That is the outing he chose to protect.
The Yankees finished the first half at 54-42, second in the AL East and three games behind the Tampa Bay Rays after sweeping the Nationals. Their young ace has decided the race in front of him matters more than the stage he passed up.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
