NEW YORK — The Yankees left the Bronx with almost everything they wanted from the wild-card round. They scored 18 runs in two games, held Boston to two, protected home field and avoided the stress of a winner-take-all Game 3. The 9-0 opener and 9-2 clincher at Yankee Stadium also bought Aaron Boone’s club two full days before Saturday’s AL Division Series opener at Tropicana Field.
Cam Schlittler controlled Game 1 with 6 1/3 scoreless innings and 10 strikeouts, while Ben Rice drove in six runs with two homers. Max Fried followed with six innings of one-run ball in Game 2. Cody Bellinger drove in four runs, Luis García Jr. homered, and the Yankees broke the game open with a six-run sixth. Fried was the winning pitcher, Sonny Gray took the loss, and no save was credited.
The Yankees also answered several questions that had followed them into October. Their lineup handled Boston’s left-handed pitching, their rookies looked comfortable in their first postseason assignments, and their starting pitching carried the series without asking the offense to win a close game late. New York hit .382 in the series and went 9-for-20 with runners in scoring position.
Now the setting changes. Tampa Bay finished 98-64, won the AL East and took the season series from the Yankees 7-6. The Rays will start Drew Rasmussen in Game 1 after he went 16-5 with a 2.67 ERA. New York enters with momentum and rested arms, but a two-game demolition can hide questions just as easily as it answers them. Tampa Bay clinched the division at Yankee Stadium on Sept. 22, when Rasmussen struck out 11 and carried a no-hit bid into the seventh in a 6-1 win. That result reinforced how little separation may be available in the rematch.
One Yankees October question survived the sweep
That unchecked box is the Yankees bullpen under postseason pressure.
An opposing National League scout raised that concern after watching Boone allow Schlittler to reach a career-high 117 pitches in Game 1. The Yankees led only 2-0 when Schlittler returned for the seventh, and Boone did not make the move until a one-out single put a runner aboard.
The scout viewed the decision as potentially revealing despite New York’s regular-season relief numbers.
“Yankees look formidable,” the scout told Yanks Go Yard. “The left handed weakness question appeared answered. This is a team built for the bright lights offensively. However, one telling sign was their fear of going to the bullpen.
The concern centered on how far Boone was willing to push his ace before turning the game over.
“Despite good results this year, they let Cam Schlittler go 117 pitches (in Game 1). Really wonder their confidence in the ‘pen if they are willing to stretch their ace out that far in the first game of what needs to be a championship or bust season for their front office/coaching staff.”
The numbers complicate scout’s warning
The Yankees bullpen was not poor against Boston. It was barely tested in situations that define October.
Paul Blackburn inherited Schlittler’s runner in the seventh inning of Game 1 and immediately induced an inning-ending double play. He worked a scoreless eighth after the Yankees stretched the lead to 4-0. John Schreiber handled the ninth after Rice’s grand slam made it 9-0.
In Game 2, Boone did not need a high-leverage reliever until the game was already effectively decided. Fried exited after six innings with New York ahead 8-1. Will Warren, Brent Headrick and David Bednar recorded the final nine outs.
A PinstripesNation review of MLB game logs shows the most revealing number of the sweep: Yankees relievers recorded 17 outs, but only two came while the margin was two runs or fewer. The bullpen allowed one run in 5 2/3 innings, a 1.59 ERA, yet Boston never forced Boone through a one-run eighth or ninth.
Regular-season strength still gives Boone a foundation
The larger sample offers a much stronger defense of the relief corps. Baseball-Reference’s reliever splits list the Yankees second in MLB with a 3.13 bullpen ERA during the regular season, trailing only Boston’s 3.11.
Blackburn finished the regular season with a 1.69 ERA in 57 appearances. Brent Headrick posted a 2.10 ERA across 79 games, while closer David Bednar recorded 35 saves with a 2.47 ERA, according to MLB and StatMuse data.
The question is role certainty when a postseason game compresses into six or nine outs. Boone did not have to show that map against Boston.
Tampa can force the test Boston never provided
The Rays are positioned to do exactly that. Tampa Bay finished 25-14 in one-run games, an MLB-best mark, and recorded 58 saves. The Yankees finished 17-22 in one-run games, a sharp contrast that matters if the ALDS repeatedly reaches the late innings without separation.
Tampa Bay also owned the season series and will have home field for Games 1, 2 and, if necessary, 5. The Yankees can counter with a rested rotation, and Boone has Gerrit Cole aligned for the opener. Ryan Weathers also remained a possible ALDS addition as he worked back from a left forearm flexor strain.
The Yankees may never need a bullpen referendum if their starters and lineup keep creating separation. Boston allowed them that luxury. Tampa Bay’s job is to take it away.
If the ALDS becomes a sequence of one-run decisions, the one box New York did not have to check at Yankee Stadium will move to the center of the series.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
