TORONTO — Jose Caballero did a little of everything in the Yankees’ 4-3 win over the Blue Jays on Sunday. He worked a walk, stole a base, scored a run and drove in another. He played clean defense at second base. He was, by his manager’s own account, the difference in the game.
He was also playing a position that belongs to someone else.
Caballero started at second base at Rogers Centre because Aaron Boone sat Jazz Chisholm Jr., the Yankees’ regular there, against Toronto ace Dylan Cease. New York snapped a three-game skid with the win, moving to 69-55 and pulling within 5 1/2 games of the Tampa Bay Rays in the AL East after Tampa Bay lost to Baltimore.
The move looked like a routine day off. Chisholm is left-handed and would have held the platoon edge against the right-handed Cease, so sitting him was a curious call on its face.
Boone insisted it meant nothing beyond a breather. The pile of evidence around the decision suggests otherwise.
A benching that keeps looking permanent
Boone made his stance plain when asked whether the change could stick. He wanted no part of the idea that Chisholm had lost his job.
“I expect Jazz to be back in there regularly, so just a day,” Boone said.
Yet the timing invited the question. Chisholm entered Sunday hitting .216 with a .683 OPS on the season, numbers that fall well short of what the Yankees expected. His August had been worse. He carried a .125 average with a .200 slugging mark and a 16-to-5 strikeout-to-walk ratio across 45 plate appearances in the month.
Sitting a slumping left-handed hitter against a tough righty is the opposite of standard practice. It reads less like rest and more like a Yankees manager searching for reasons to look elsewhere.
The two days off only sharpen the picture. The Yankees were idle Monday, so the Sunday benching effectively gave Chisholm consecutive days out of the lineup to reset his swing.
Caballero makes the case for himself
Whatever Boone intended, Caballero turned the day into an audition and passed. He set up the game’s first run in the third inning, working a walk, stealing third and scoring on a Luis Garcia Jr. sacrifice fly. In the seventh, his two-out single drove in George Lombard Jr. for the go-ahead run.
Boone did not hide his satisfaction afterward.
“Certainly hoping for a spark, and he was good,” Boone said. “Obviously good defense, but a big hit for us, a big walk, a steal to set up the first run, drove in the next run. A lot of really good things by him and a big difference in the game today.”
The performance mattered because it fit a larger roster reality. The Yankees have another everyday-caliber infielder in Garcia, acquired at the trade deadline, who can slot in at second base. Between Caballero’s energy and Garcia’s bat, the club has viable alternatives at the position for the first time all season.
Chisholm, meanwhile, is playing for his future. He can become a free agent after the season, which raises the stakes on every slump and every benching. A manager who benches a pending free agent against a favorable matchup is sending a message, whether he says so or not.
The bizarre bench sequence that spoke volumes
One odd moment in the seventh inning underlined how the Yankees now view Chisholm. It came without a single pitch being thrown to him.
With Cease chased from the game and lefty Brendon Little on the mound, Boone pinch-hit Paul Goldschmidt for Ryan McMahon. Toronto manager John Schneider countered by intentionally walking Goldschmidt, putting him on base without a pitch.
That is when Chisholm entered. He came in only as a pinch-runner for Goldschmidt at first base, not as a hitter.
The detail is telling. On a day the Yankees benched him, Chisholm’s first contribution was his legs, not his bat. He later singled in the ninth and stole a base, small signs of life at the end of a quiet afternoon.
The sequence captured his shrinking role in miniature. A player acquired to be a middle-of-the-order threat spent the biggest rally of the game as a courtesy runner.
What the Yankees decide next
Boone may well return Chisholm to the lineup on Tuesday. The Orioles are lined up to start three right-handers in the series at Camden Yards, matchups that favor the left-handed hitter and give the manager an easy reason to write his name back in.
That would not erase the direction of travel. The Yankees have spent the second half searching for offense, and Chisholm has been part of the problem rather than the solution. Every day Caballero sparks a win or Garcia produces at the plate, the argument for a permanent change grows louder.
For now the Yankees are treating it as roster management, not a divorce. Chisholm remains their second baseman on paper. But the Sunday lineup card, and the way the game unfolded, offered a preview of what life without him could look like. The final six weeks will decide whether that preview becomes the plan.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
