NEW YORK — The Yankees’ last game of 2026 ended with a familiar problem exposed. Their season was over, their pitching staff had been pushed through another October test, and the relief corps that helped produce 93 victories faced an uncertain winter.
Tampa Bay completed its American League Division Series sweep at Yankee Stadium, ending New York’s hopes of another championship run. The defeat put the roster back under scrutiny, with attention turning to the late innings as much as the lineup.
David Bednar helped stabilize the ninth inning during the regular season, but his approaching free agency complicates the picture. Paul Blackburn also faces an uncertain return, while a heavy workload leaves questions about how much New York can demand from its remaining relief depth.
For general manager Brian Cashman, the next decision is not simply choosing a closer. The Yankees must determine how to protect leads before the ninth, how much they can spend on a specialist and whether another postseason contender will drive the price beyond their comfort zone.
A bullpen need meets free-agent speculation
The larger challenge is finding dependable innings around Bednar, should he remain in New York. In his Pinstripe Post discussion, Joel Sherman identified the bullpen as one of the Yankees’ most pressing offseason needs and pointed to Morejon as a particularly attractive pitcher on the market.
Sherman also questioned whether New York would make an expensive, lengthy commitment to a reliever. He outlined alternatives on the free-agent and trade markets, while stressing the need for additional left-handed protection after Brent Headrick’s heavy 2026 workload.
Adrian Morejon offers the kind of combination that can turn that concern into a bidding contest. His average four-seam fastball reached 99.4 mph in 2026. He generated a 38.6% chase rate, a 34.2% whiff rate and a 58% ground-ball rate, pairing strikeout ability with contact management.
Those figures help explain Morejon’s appeal as a potential setup option for the Yankees even if Bednar returns. Kline’s Toronto prediction is an assessment of a possible fit, not reporting that the Blue Jays have made an offer or entered negotiations.
A familiar target enters a crowded market
That calculation puts San Diego left-hander Morejon back into the Yankees’ offseason discussion. The 27-year-old is headed toward free agency after a career-high 107 strikeouts in 86 innings, a 9-3 record and a 2.83 ERA over 76 appearances in 2026.
The Yankees have previously checked on Morejon’s availability. An August report described a proposed exchange involving starter Will Warren, but subsequent reporting citing team sources disputed that a formal Warren-for-Morejon offer was ever made. The reported inquiry establishes past interest, not an active negotiation.
FanSided writer Christopher Kline projected Morejon to sign with the Blue Jays for four years and $68 million on Oct. 18. Bleacher Report writer Joel Reuter separately projected a five-year, $90 million contract on Oct. 16, without naming a destination. Neither forecast describes a Yankees offer or predicts what New York will pay.
Kansas City has also been identified as a possible fit. Its bullpen posted a 5.07 ERA in 2026, creating a clear incentive to investigate high-leverage options. San Diego could still seek to retain Morejon, who has expressed an interest in staying with the Padres.
What the two contract forecasts actually measure
Comparing Kline’s and Reuter’s estimates produces a $22 million difference in total guarantees. Kline’s Toronto projection averages $17 million annually, while Reuter’s estimate averages $18 million over an additional season. This arithmetic compares two writers’ forecasts. It does not establish the Yankees’ budget, Morejon’s asking price or competing team bids.
Morejon would turn 28 before the 2027 season, making a longer contract easier to envision than it would be for an older reliever. Still, his strongest major league work has come primarily in relief. A team paying closer-level money would be betting on continued durability and effectiveness, not an established history closing games.
His 2025 All-Star campaign included a 2.08 ERA, and he has now logged three consecutive seasons with an ERA of 2.83 or better. Those results give bidders more evidence than a single breakout year. The Yankees would nevertheless have to decide whether one premium signing is preferable to several less costly bullpen additions.
New York’s bullpen rebuild could involve re-signing Bednar, retaining other familiar options, developing another converted starter or pursuing a high-priced lefty. Whether Morejon becomes part of that plan will depend on the market, San Diego’s efforts to keep him and how far Cashman is willing to extend a contract.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
