ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — The Yankees have a date circled. They will not say what it is.
That silence has become its own story. Somewhere on an internal calendar sits the day Aaron Judge gets a new set of images taken of his right first rib. The organization knows it. The player knows it. Nobody outside the building has been told.
Wednesday night at Tropicana Field made the withholding harder to defend. New York was shut out 3-0 by Tampa Bay. Gerrit Cole allowed three runs in six and a third innings and lost. Shane McClanahan won. Bryan Baker closed it.
It was not the score that stung. The loss tied a franchise record: 20 consecutive games without scoring more than five runs. The Yankees sit at 50-42, five games behind the Rays in the AL East, per MLB standings.
An offense that stopped functioning
Judge last played May 31. He went on the injured list June 4 with a stress fracture of the first rib on his right side. At the time, the club said he would be reimaged in four to six weeks to gauge healing and determine next steps.
The team was 36-23 when he went down. They have gone 14-17 since. Over the last 20 games they are 5-15.
The collapse is not gradual. Before the injury the Yankees averaged 5.32 runs per game. Since a June 20 loss to Cincinnati, that figure has fallen to 2.88.
Across that 16-game stretch, they rank last in the majors in batting average, on-base percentage, slugging, runs, strikeouts and weighted runs created plus. They have faced one team with a winning record in those 16 games and gone 4-12.
Since June 1 the numbers are similarly bleak. The Yankees rank last in MLB in batting average at .217, on-base percentage at .279 and strikeout rate at 27 percent, and 26th in runs per game at 3.97, per ESPN.
No hitter has escaped. Not one Yankees regular has been above average at the plate for two weeks.
An insider says the Yankees know something they will not share
The reporting came during the Rays series, on a podcast. Co-host Joel Sherman pressed the question fans have been asking. The answer came from Jon Heyman, who covers the team and has sources inside it.
Heyman said the front office is sitting on information it has chosen not to release.
“I’ve heard they do have a date in mind, which can change,” Heyman said.
He was blunter about what the club will not confirm. The Yankees have declined to announce even when the scan happens, let alone what happens after it.
“They won’t even say when he’s getting the reimaging,” Heyman said.
Sherman then asked directly whether the team peaked in mid-June and was now in trouble. Heyman allowed that the peak may have passed. He attached a single condition to everything else.
“It’s possible they peaked. I don’t think they’re in trouble, with one caveat,” Heyman said.
The caveat was Judge failing to return at all. That is a worst-case scenario, and no evidence currently points to it.
The math on the calendar
Count six weeks from the June 4 injured list placement and the clock lands on Thursday, July 16. That is the outer edge of the window the Yankees themselves described.
A clean scan does not put Judge in the lineup. He would need to resume baseball activity, then hit, then face live pitching, then play games. Two weeks is an optimistic ramp for a hitter who has not swung in six weeks.
August, then. Not July.
One prominent voice has already pushed the estimate further. ESPN’s Buster Olney said a return in mid-August or early September would not surprise him.
Judge was hitting .248 with 17 home runs and 38 RBIs in 59 games when the injury stopped his season. Not his usual dominance. Enough to keep the Yankees in first place.
The 2023 warning nobody wants to repeat
Rushing a hitter back has a recent precedent in the Bronx, and it did not work.
Judge missed 42 games in 2023 with a toe injury. New York was 35-25 when he went out and went 19-23 without him. The shape of that season matches this one almost exactly.
He returned in August. He hit .196 across 28 games that month, and the Yankees lost 18 of them. The captain came back and the slide continued.
That is the argument for patience, and the front office appears to be making it. The refusal to name a date reads less like a team preparing to gamble and more like one guarding against an announcement it might have to walk back.
The pressure argues the other way. Every shutout, every game the Rays pull further ahead, raises the cost of caution. A Yankees team five games out in July does not have the luxury a first-place team has.
Where the Yankees’ desperation stand
Yankees manager Aaron Boone has no replacement to summon. Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger were the insurance, and both have gone cold. The bullpen and rotation have largely held. The lineup has not.
New York closes the series against the Rays on Thursday afternoon, then visits Washington for its final set before the All-Star break. The trade deadline follows on July 31.
The Yankees front office weighing whether to buy needs to know whether its best hitter is walking through the door in August. Right now it will not say. Whether that is discipline or a decision not yet made is the question hanging over the second half.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
