Devin Williams’ first Yankees loss reveals concerns that demand attention

Follow Us

The New York Yankees’ perfect start to the Pittsburgh series jolted Sunday afternoon at PNC Park when closer Devin Williams allowed a walk-off single to Tommy Pham in the 11th inning. The dramatic 5-4 defeat against the Pirates ended the Bombers’ dream of another series sweep.

Williams, known across baseball for his wicked “Airbender” changeup—a pitch that defies physics with its late, darting movement, engaged in an intense nine-pitch showdown with Pham, who ultimately connected on a full-count changeup, driving it to the warning track in deep left-center to secure the Pirates’ victory and dashing the Yankees’ hopes of extending their unbeaten run.

The loss raised early-season questions about bullpen reliability, clutch execution, and the thin margin between dominance and defeat at the highest level.

The final pitch: A duel to the end

Devin Williams entered a tied game in the 11th inning with automatic runner Jack Suwinski on second base. After Suwinski swiped third, Williams faced veteran outfielder Tommy Pham in what became a tense, nine-pitch duel.

Pham fouled off four two-strike pitches before finally connecting on a full-count changeup that drifted slightly over the plate, despite catcher Austin Wells setting up outside. The ball soared to the warning track in left-center, sealing the win for Pittsburgh and delivering Williams his first loss in Yankees pinstripes.

“I was just trying to keep it down,” Williams said postgame. “He put some good swings on balls and really made me work there.”

While slow-motion replays revealed the pitch dropping below the strike zone, it drifted more toward the middle than catcher Austin Wells’ intended outside target. Though not a terrible pitch, it provided just enough for Pham to make solid contact.

Yankees manager Aaron Boone quickly defended his reliever’s performance.

“Pham clearly just selling out,” Boone noted. “Was able to get the barrel to it. Pretty good at-bat there, obviously against a really tough customer. I don’t think Devin made a big mistake with it.”

Williams tagged with loss, but not blame

By rule, Williams was charged with the loss despite the run being unearned, as Suwinski began the inning at second base per extra-inning regulations. Williams’ performance followed Luke Weaver’s impressive two scoreless frames that extended the contest after the Yankees had mounted a thrilling ninth-inning comeback.

New York squandered opportunities to score with their own automatic runners in both the 10th and 11th innings. These missed chances transformed Williams’ appearance from a potential save situation into a do-or-die scenario.

“They did a great job battling back there in the ninth, giving us a chance to win,” Williams acknowledged. “Weave did a great job keeping them off the board there for two innings. I couldn’t get it done.”

No excuses from Williams

Williams had just rejoined the team following a brief stint on the paternity list. When questioned whether his absence affected his performance, he responded straightforwardly.

“That’s part of the job,” he stated. “We adjust and I’m expected to do a job. I didn’t do it today.”

Sunday’s setback represents a rare misstep for Williams, who arrived in a major offseason trade from the Milwaukee Brewers and had impressed in his early appearances for New York. Despite his reputation as one of baseball’s elite closers with exceptional strikeout ability and a formidable off-speed arsenal, Sunday proved that even the best relievers have vulnerable moments.

Yankees’ missed opportunities prove costly

The Yankees had multiple chances to complete the sweep. After falling behind 4-2 heading into the ninth, they orchestrated a two-out rally to even the score and force extra innings. However, in both the 10th and 11th frames, they failed to advance a runner who started on second base with nobody out.

The clutch hitting that had characterized their hot start to the season vanished when most needed. Despite strong offensive contributions from the middle of the order throughout the series, their inability to convert in extra innings magnified the bullpen’s slim margin for error—ultimately costing them the game.

One bump doesn’t derail but detent

Even with the defeat, the Yankees boast an impressive record. They remain among baseball’s elite teams as they travel to Detroit to begin their next series against the Tigers.

Williams maintains his role as the team’s closer, with Boone emphasizing after the game that there’s “no concern” regarding his status moving forward.

Boone described Williams as a competitor, praising Pham’s at-bat while defending his closer’s pitch selection. The manager characterized the outcome as simply part of baseball and emphasized the team would move forward.

Every dominant closer eventually faces adversity—Sunday happened to be Devin Williams’ turn. This wasn’t a collapse but rather a closely contested battle decided by the slimmest of margins.

The Yankees’ relief corps remains among baseball’s finest. The offense continues to produce. Judging by Williams’ composed demeanor following the game, this setback won’t linger.

The team resumes action Monday in Detroit, ready to begin a new winning streak.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us