Who is Allan Winans, Yankees rookie arm on cusp of rotation debut after Cole injury?

Follow Us

In the pressure-cooker environment of Yankees spring training, where expectations soar as high as the franchise’s 27 championship banners, an unexpected name has emerged from relative obscurity to potentially solve one of the team’s most pressing concerns. Allan Winans, a 29-year-old journeyman who has bounced between organizations, finds himself on the precipice of a career-defining opportunity as injuries mount in the Yankees’ pitching corps.

With ace Gerrit Cole facing injury scare and promising youngster Luis Gil also nursing an injury, the spotlight has suddenly shifted to Winans, whose winding path to the Bronx epitomizes baseball’s unpredictable nature.

The long Road to pinstripes

Winans’ baseball journey began in Bakersfield, California, where his love for the game took root early. After developing his skills at Frontier High School, he continued his baseball education at Bakersfield College before transferring to Campbell University in North Carolina to pitch for the Fighting Camels.

The New York Mets saw enough potential to select Winans in the 17th round of the 2018 MLB Draft, though few could have predicted the circuitous route his career would take from that point. His professional debut with the Kingsport Mets yielded a modest 4.66 ERA across 11 appearances, hardly the numbers that forecast future major league success.

Yet the following season hinted at his potential, as Winans posted an impressive 2.74 ERA with 11 saves for the Columbia Fireflies. After the pandemic-canceled 2020 season, he returned in 2021 to split time between Brooklyn and Binghamton, recording a combined 1.72 ERA that began turning heads within the organization.

Despite this success, Winans found himself selected by the Atlanta Braves in the minor league phase of the 2021 Rule 5 Draft, beginning another chapter in his professional odyssey.

Breaking through with the Braves

After spending much of 2022 recovering from injuries, Winans roared back in 2023 with the Triple-A Gwinnett Stripers, compiling a stellar 7-3 record with a 2.81 ERA that earned him his first major league call-up in July.

His major league debut came on July 22, 2023, against the Milwaukee Brewers, where he allowed two earned runs over 4⅓ innings before being optioned back to Triple-A. Winans’ perseverance paid off when he earned his first major league victory on August 12, shutting down the Mets over seven scoreless innings in a lopsided 21-3 Atlanta win.

By season’s end, Winans had accumulated six starts for the Braves, posting a 1-2 record with a 5.29 ERA and 34 strikeouts in 32⅓ innings – respectable numbers for a rookie thrust into a pennant race.
The 2024 season saw Winans bounce between Atlanta and Triple-A, struggling in limited major league action with a 15.26 ERA across two starts spanning just 7⅔ innings. By January 17, 2025, the Braves had designated him for assignment, seemingly closing another chapter in his professional journey.

A New York homecoming of sorts with Yankees

When the Yankees claimed Winans off waivers on January 23, 2025, it represented both a fresh start and a return to the organization that shares a city with his original MLB employer. The Yankees’ interest proved tentative at first – they designated him for assignment on February 5, but after he cleared waivers two days later, they outrighted him to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre.

What initially appeared to be a depth move has taken on greater significance as injuries have mounted in the Yankees’ rotation. With Cole sidelined and other question marks emerging, Winans has capitalized on every opportunity presented during spring training.

His most recent audition on March 8 particularly turned heads, as he blanked the formidable Houston Astros lineup over 3⅓ innings, scattering five hits while striking out four. The performance showcased the craftiness that has kept his career alive despite lacking overwhelming velocity.

Winans defying convention with finesse

In an era dominated by flamethrowers, Winans represents a throwback to a different pitching philosophy. His fastball rarely touches 90 mph – practically pedestrian by modern standards – but he compensates with a changeup featuring elite downward movement that keeps hitters off balance.

“His ability to manipulate the baseball and change speeds is impressive,” noted one Yankees scout. “He’s not going to overwhelm anyone, but he knows how to pitch, and that’s becoming a lost art.”

This approach has served Winans well throughout the minors, and now he must prove it can translate consistently at baseball’s highest level, where the margin for error shrinks dramatically.
The Opportunity of a Lifetime

As Opening Day approaches and the Yankees continue assessing their rotation options, Winans stands at a career crossroads. At 29, he’s older than the typical “rookie” prospect, but his relative inexperience at the major league level still affords him that classification.

The Yankees’ pitching depth has been tested early with injuries extending beyond Cole and Gil to include bullpen concerns. This perfect storm of circumstances has created an unexpected opening that Winans is determined to seize.

“Every day I’m just trying to show what I can do,” Winans told reporters after his impressive outing against Houston. “I’ve waited a long time for an opportunity like this, and all I can do is make the most of every inning I get.”

Looking ahead

The Yankees’ brain trust faces difficult decisions in the coming weeks as they finalize their pitching plans. While Winans wasn’t in the conversation when spring training began, his performances have forced the organization to consider him as a legitimate option.

Whether Winans ultimately breaks camp with the big league club or begins the season in Scranton/Wilkes-Barre remains to be seen. Either way, his journey from 17th-round selection to the cusp of the Yankees rotation stands as testament to perseverance in a sport that often quickly discards those who don’t immediately succeed.

For a Yankees team harboring championship aspirations, unexpected contributors often make the difference in a long season. As the club navigates early-season pitching challenges, Allan Winans has positioned himself to potentially become one of those critical supporting cast members who help bridge the gap until the stars return.

The California native who once seemed destined for baseball obscurity now stands one phone call away from taking the mound in pinstripes when games count. In the unpredictable world of baseball, sometimes the most unlikely candidates emerge as solutions to the most pressing problems.

What do you think? Leave your comments below.

Follow Us