ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — The angriest the Yankees looked all night, they were not even swinging a bat.
A hand went up in the Yankees dugout. A phone came off the hook. Seconds bled away while two men tried to decide whether to ask a machine for help.
By the time the signal reached home plate, the window had closed. What followed was the only real fight the Yankees showed at Tropicana Field on Wednesday night, and it came from the coaching staff.
The sequence began with a strikeout. Paul Goldschmidt went down swinging against Shane McClanahan in the sixth inning. Jose Caballero broke for second and was thrown out to complete the double play. He tried a swim move around Ben Williamson’s tag. The umpire called him out anyway.
It was the kind of call the automated ball-strike system was built to settle. Hawk-Eye cameras track every pitch. A tap of the helmet and a machine renders a verdict in seconds. The Yankees had a challenge available. They could not spend it fast enough.
The Yankees lost 3-0 to the Rays at Tropicana Field, a shutout that dropped them five games behind Tampa Bay in the American League East. Gerrit Cole pitched well enough to win. The lineup produced six hits and no walks.
It was the second time this month a Yankees challenge died before it reached an umpire’s ears. Frustration does not stay filed away that long.
For three weeks the Yankees have lost in every available manner. They have been out-pitched and out-hit. In the sixth inning Wednesday, they were simply out-clocked, and the reaction it triggered said more about the state of this team than the box score did.
But the lasting image of the night was not a strikeout. It was a manager walking onto the field to argue a review he never got, then walking off ejected. Aaron Boone’s postgame explanation revealed something that had been building for weeks inside the Yankees dugout, and it had almost nothing to do with Jose Caballero’s slide.
A challenge that arrived seconds too late
The delay was procedural. Boone raised his hand from the dugout rail while Ausmus worked the phone, awaiting word from the Yankees video room. Ausmus signaled Boone. Boone signaled Eddings. The clock had already run out.
Ausmus began arguing from the dugout and was ejected first, his first ejection of the season. Boone walked onto the field without knowing who had been tossed. He argued. Eddings ran him too.
It was Boone’s third ejection this season and the 49th of his career. With the manager and bench coach both gone, the Yankees passed the lineup card to Tanner Swanson, the club’s director of catching and major league field coordinator.
Caballero did not argue the ruling so much as the temperature around it.
“It got out of hand, but it’s part of the game,” the Yankees star said.
Boone concedes he crossed his own line
Boone did not defend himself afterward. He believed his club had beaten the clock, though he admitted he had not checked the replay. What he did not dispute was his own conduct.
“I should have kept myself in the game there,” the Yankees manager said.
Then came the admission that separated this ejection from the dozens before it. The Yankees skipper conceded his argument was not really about Caballero. It was about accumulated grievance with the men working the plate.
“That’s not a good time to go out there and get personal with it,” Boone said.
He was pointing at history. On Monday, Jasson Dominguez tapped his helmet to challenge a high strike. Umpire Emil Jimenez refused, telling Boone the rookie had been influenced by voices on the bench. Dominguez struck out in that at-bat.
That was not the first time. A nearly identical dispute involving Dominguez and Jimenez unfolded last month at Yankee Stadium. Boone referenced both incidents Wednesday, then stopped himself.
“I don’t like to make it personal like that,” the Yankees boss said. “I shouldn’t have done that.”
He knew the moment demanded restraint for a simpler reason. Once his bench coach was gone, the manager could not follow him.
“Once it’s Brad being thrown out, I got to stay in the game absolutely,” Boone said.
The skid fuels the frustration
The outburst did not arrive in a vacuum. The loss dropped the Yankees to 50-42 and marked their 15th loss in 20 games, the worst mark in the majors across that stretch. They have lost 11 of 13. They sit five games behind Tampa Bay in the American League East.
The offense is the wound. Across 12 games from June 25 through last Tuesday, the Yankees hit .164 with a .220 on-base percentage and a .295 slugging mark, striking out 30.9 percent of the time.
Cole gave the Yankees three earned runs with six strikeouts over 6 1/3 innings. Jonathan Aranda drove in every Tampa Bay run, on a third-inning single, a fifth-inning double and a seventh-inning sacrifice fly.
Cole was blunt about where that leaves a club with championship expectations.
“It’s not good enough to compete for first place right now,” the Yankees ace said.
Caballero suggested the slump has turned psychological, with players carrying the streak into every at-bat.
“You think about it too long, and it doesn’t get easier,” Caballero said.
Boone rejects the defeated feeling
Boone wants that thinking out of the Yankees clubhouse. Surrendering to it, he argued, is the one unaffordable luxury.
“We gotta avoid that because this game waits for no one,” Boone said.
On the offense, Boone offered no remedy. The Yankees skipper said the preparation is sound and the hitting room conversations are right, then repeated a line he has grown tired of saying.
“There’s no magic pill,” Boone said.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
