Are the 2025 Yankees better than the 2024 squad? Inside push for No. 28

Follow Us

NEW YORK — Last fall, the New York Yankees came two wins shy of a championship. They bulldozed through the American League, captured the pennant, and went toe-to-toe with the Dodgers in the World Series—before unraveling in Game 5.

The New York Yankees entered the 2025 season with one goal: finish the job. As the 2025 season hits its halfway point, the Bronx Bombers not only remain in first place but look deeper, sharper and more balanced than the team that reached the World Series last October.

Now, the question isn’t just whether the Yankees can return to October. It’s whether this version of the Bronx Bombers might be better positioned to finish the job.

Through June 26, the Yankees lead the AL East with a 46–33 record and hold a 98.1% chance to make postseason and 16.1% to win championship, according to Baseball Reference. With a deeper rotation, a more complete lineup, and improved defense, the 2025 Yankees might just be the most complete team in baseball.

Same standings, better shape

The 2024 Yankees finished 94–68, won the division, and reached the World Series, only to fall to the Dodgers in five games. This year’s club is pacing similarly, but the underlying numbers suggest a stronger overall team.

Through 80 games, the Yankees rank top five in MLB in home runs (121), runs scored (407), and team OPS (.786). They lead the league in opponent batting average (.255), are among the top six in team ERA (3.47), and sport a +70 run differential—up from +54 at the same point last season.

Offense: More than just muscle

The 2024 offense leaned on its stars. Aaron Judge returned to MVP form. Juan Soto provided balance. And Giancarlo Stanton went nuclear in the playoffs—hitting four home runs in the ALCS and winning MVP honors after his 446-foot shot sparked a pennant-clinching rally.

But there were holes. Anthony Rizzo faded late, catcher production was minimal, and the lineup often lacked contact balance.

The 2025 Yankees fixed that.

Judge is having one of the best seasons of his career, leading the league in average, OBP, SLG, and WAR. Paul Goldschmidt, acquired in a quiet offseason move, has rejuvenated the heart of the lineup. Cody Bellinger adds lefty pop and speed. And younger bats—like Austin Wells and J.C. Escarra behind the plate and Jasson Domínguez in the outfield—have added both energy and timely hitting.

Jazz Chisholm Jr., acquired midseason in 2024, now provides power and flair from the top of the order.

“His energy is so infectious,” shortstop Anthony Volpe said earlier this month. “He’s brought juice to the clubhouse.”

Through June, the Yankees’ team batting average (.255) and slugging percentage (.450) are both up from last year. The result? A deeper, less streaky lineup capable of scoring in more ways.

Rotation: No Cole, not much problem

Losing Gerrit Cole—who opted out after the 2024 season—could’ve crippled the rotation. Instead, the Yankees replaced him with Max Fried, and the left-hander has delivered ace-caliber production.

Fried owns a 1.92 ERA and leads all pitchers in Defensive Runs Saved. Carlos Rodon, healthy again, has posted a 2.92 ERA and racked up nine wins. Clarke Schmidt has emerged as a dependable mid-rotation starter, pitching with newfound confidence and command.

Collectively, the 2025 rotation’s ERA (3.51) is better than the 3.74 it posted in 2024. Opposing teams are slugging less and striking out more. Even with Marcus Stroman sidelined, the Yankees have weathered the loss with internal depth and prospects like Will Warren.

Bullpen: Recharged amid concerns

After Clay Holmes’ departure, the Yankees handed the closer role to Devin Williams. While April was rocky, Williams has rebounded, and the bullpen has remained among the best in baseball. Luke Weaver has emerged as their crowing glory.

Fernando Cruz has emerged as a dominant setup man, boasting a strikeout rate over 40 percent. Mark Leiter Jr., and Tim Hill round out a group that ranks top five in bullpen ERA. Combined with elite defense, the relievers have consistently protected narrow leads.

Manager Aaron Boone has more high-leverage options than at any time during his tenure.

“They pass the baton to each other,” Boone said recently. “Everyone knows their role, and they embrace it.”

Defense: A visible turnaround

One of the biggest differences between 2024 and 2025? Run prevention.

The Yankees rank among the top five teams in Defensive Runs Saved, led by Bellinger, Volpe, and Goldschmidt. Fried leads all pitchers in DRS, and the staff as a whole is among MLB’s best at fielding their position.

The 2024 Yankees committed two costly errors in Game 5 of the World Series. This year’s team has cleaned that up, ranking top five in defensive efficiency. “Run prevention is the name of the game,” one analyst said on MLB Network. “And this Yankees team is among the best at it.”

Clubhouse culture and roster flexibility

The Yankees didn’t just upgrade talent—they rebuilt the roster around chemistry and flexibility.

Veterans like Judge, Goldschmidt, and Stanton set the tone. Younger players like Chisholm, Volpe, and Domínguez provide energy. And new voices—like Bellinger and Chisholm—have meshed quickly.

“Once a Yankee, always a Yankee,” Domínguez said in May. “But this group feels different. We’re all in.”

The bench, too, is deeper. Ben Rice, Trent Grisham, DJ LeMahieu, and Oswaldo Cabrera give Boone matchup options and injury insurance that last year’s team lacked.

Are the 2025 Yankees built to finish the job?

The 2024 Yankees came close. The 2025 version might be better suited to win it all.

They hit more. They pitch better. They field better. And they’ve learned from last year’s heartbreak.

October is unpredictable. But if the Yankees stay healthy and keep executing, 2025 may finally be the year they bring championship No. 28 back to the Bronx.

“This ain’t the trophy I want,” Stanton said after the ALCS last year. “I want the next one.”

So does everyone in the Bronx. And this time, they might just get it.

What do you think?

Follow Us