Juan Soto faces full New York rebuke as Mets fans turn on slugger

Follow Us

Nowhere to hide: Juan Soto is now facing heat from both Yankees and Mets fans

Juan Soto anticipated the hostile reception awaiting him at Yankee Stadium this weekend. What likely caught him off guard was the fierce criticism now coming from his own Mets fanbase.

After weathering three days of relentless jeers from Yankees supporters during the 2025 Subway Series, Soto now finds himself under scrutiny from Mets fans, not for his offseason borough selection, but for what many perceived as insufficient effort during Sunday’s decisive defeat.

The Yankees secured the series with an explosive six-run eighth inning, ultimately prevailing 8-2 before an energized Bronx crowd. However, attention quickly shifted to Soto’s actions during the top half of that pivotal frame.

Controversial play ignites fan frustration

Opening the inning with the score deadlocked at 2-2, Soto made weak contact—a ground ball registering just 92.7 mph—toward the right side. Yankees second baseman DJ LeMahieu executed a sliding backhand stop and, from his knees, fired accurately to first for the out.

The issue wasn’t the result, but Soto’s response. Following a half-hearted check-swing, the Mets’ $765 million investment merely jogged up the baseline, making minimal effort to beat what some viewed as a potentially close play. Replays confirmed the throw narrowly beat him, but the damage extended beyond just another out—it wounded team morale and inflamed fan sentiment.

Social media erupts with Soto criticism

The reaction across digital platforms was swift and severe. Mets fans blame him for “selfish behavior” and claiming “$765 million for a guy who doesn’t want to play here.”

“No excuses. This was beyond embarrassing,” a longtime Mets fan tweeted.

“Massive contracts equal a tendency for laziness,” another wrote.

A fan took a postshot at him, “It’s more like his pockets got real real heavy or the waist line expanded.”

“They should have benched him after this. Total disgrace,” a Mets fan tweeted. Another added, “am now legit fed up with all this Juan Soto dogshit. He didn’t choose the Yankees, he signed with the Mets. Get over it and move on.”

Yankees supporters—still bitter about Soto’s departure—viewed the incident as validation of their grievances.

Soto’s Subway Series performance fell dramatically short of expectations. He managed just 1-for-10 with four walks and zero RBIs across three games. Sunday’s contest saw him go hitless in four at-bats, including two weak fly outs alongside the contentious ground ball.

Yankees’ Fried dominates Soto

While Soto struggled, Yankees ace Max Fried delivered a commanding performance. Just hours after his viral refusal to sign a Mets cap at a public autograph event, Fried took control, silencing Mets hitters with seven innings of one-run baseball.

When Soto approached the plate for his first at-bat on Sunday, thunderous disapproval cascaded from the stands. Those same jeers transformed into celebration just moments later when Fried induced a harmless flyout to right field.

Defining moment or passing storm?

Soto’s transition between New York teams ranked among the offseason’s most scrutinized moves. His record-breaking Mets contract, reportedly following tepid Yankees negotiations, reverberated throughout the baseball landscape.

The Mets believed they were acquiring a franchise cornerstone capable of thriving under intense scrutiny. Instead, three games into baseball’s most electric intracity rivalry, Soto faces criticism from both fanbases and mounting questions regarding effort and leadership.

While one isolated play doesn’t define a player of Soto’s caliber, New York sports culture places a premium value on hustle. With tensions already elevated following a lopsided defeat and costly defensive miscues, His perceived lack of effort arrived at the worst possible moment.

Path forward for star and team

The Mets (29-18) now travel to Boston, confronting a challenging Red Sox series while attempting to overcome their rivalry disappointment. Soto remains central to their long-term aspirations, though short-term fan patience appears increasingly limited.

For the Yankees (28-19), Sunday’s victory reinforced team cohesion amid a compelling narrative contrast. While Soto faced criticism, Yankees players demonstrated maximum effort, capitalizing on opportunities and displaying the focused intensity New York demands.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us