Yankees’ title chase at risk with Boone’s third base strategy

Follow Us

As the New York Yankees prepare for their 2025 campaign, a significant roster weakness threatens to undermine their championship ambitions. The hot corner remains conspicuously unsettled, with manager Aaron Boone recently outlining a trio of internal candidates during his appearance on WFAN. While DJ LeMahieu, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza represent available options, each potential solution carries considerable risk for a franchise with October expectations.

The situation appears particularly precarious given Jazz Chisholm’s firm grasp on second base duties, where his exceptional range and athletic abilities make him invaluable. Though external acquisitions remain possible, Boone’s public acknowledgment of these internal candidates suggests the organization might be preparing to address their third base vacancy from within—a strategy that warrants careful scrutiny.

DJ LeMahieu: Veteran presence but offensive decline

The potential deployment of DJ LeMahieu at third base illustrates the challenging nature of the Yankees’ predicament. Once a cornerstone of the lineup’s success, LeMahieu’s offensive production has deteriorated dramatically over the past two seasons. His 2024 performance paints a particularly concerning picture: a meager .204/.269/.259 slash line accompanied by just two home runs and 26 RBIs across 67 games. Perhaps most alarming, his 52 wRC+ indicates he performed 48% below league average offensively—a stark departure from his earlier excellence.

At 36, LeMahieu’s diminished bat speed and reduced power generation raise serious questions about his viability as an everyday player. While his defensive reliability at third base remains admirable, the severe offensive limitations make him a problematic solution for a team with championship aspirations. Boone’s inclusion of LeMahieu among potential options might reflect organizational hope for a renaissance, but statistical evidence suggests such optimism could be misplaced.

Oswaldo Cabrera: Super-utility value vs. everyday demands

Oswaldo Cabrera presents an intriguing yet imperfect solution to the Yankees’ third base quandary. His 2024 offensive output—a .247/.296/.365 line with an 88 wRC+—demonstrates both his potential and limitations. While capable of providing the occasional offensive spark, his production remains 12% below league average, raising concerns about his readiness for everyday responsibilities.

Defensively, Cabrera showed promise at third base, accumulating seven defensive runs saved across 566.1 innings. However, his greatest organizational value lies in his defensive versatility. Converting him to a full-time third baseman could diminish the strategic advantages his multi-positional capabilities provide. The Yankees must weigh whether anchoring Cabrera to one position outweighs the benefits of maintaining his utility role.

Oswald Peraza: Square peg or round hole?

The consideration of Oswald Peraza as a third-base candidate reflects both creative problem-solving and potential developmental risk. A natural shortstop with limited third base exposure, Peraza possesses elite defensive tools that might translate across the infield. However, forcing this position change could compromise his natural abilities and impede his professional growth.

Peraza’s offensive profile remains a work in progress. His 2024 minor league performance—.246/.341/.394 with 13 home runs, 60 RBIs, and 24 stolen bases—yielded a 94 wRC+, suggesting slightly below-average production. While his speed and defensive excellence offer tantalizing upside, repositioning a developing player at an unfamiliar position could prove counterproductive.

With Anthony Volpe established at shortstop and Chisholm commanding second base, the organization appears to be seeking creative solutions for Peraza’s playing time. However, this approach risks prioritizing roster accommodation over optimal player deployment and development.

Strategic implications: Inside vs. market options

While Boone’s public comments suggest openness to internal solutions, the Yankees’ organizational history indicates potential market activity ahead. The franchise has traditionally demonstrated reluctance to enter seasons with obvious roster deficiencies, particularly at key defensive positions.

General Manager Brian Cashman likely maintains active dialogue regarding external solutions. The trade market could yield immediate upgrades, though acquiring established talent typically requires significant prospect capital. Late-developing free-agent opportunities might also emerge as spring training approaches.

For a team with legitimate championship aspirations, relying exclusively on LeMahieu, Cabrera, and Peraza represents a strategic gamble. Third base production could significantly impact the Yankees’ competitive ceiling, making external reinforcement less a luxury than a necessity.

Approaching decision point

As spring training looms, the Yankees face increasing pressure to resolve their third base uncertainty. They could proceed with their current internal options, hoping for unexpected emergence or revival. Alternatively, they could leverage their organizational resources to acquire proven talent capable of solidifying the position.

The franchise’s competitive culture and resource advantages suggest passive acceptance of current options remains unlikely. Recent history indicates the Yankees will actively pursue upgrades when clear weaknesses threaten their championship potential. The coming weeks should reveal whether the organization’s actions align with this established pattern of aggressive problem-solving.

The third base situation represents more than a positional question—it reflects the Yankees’ broader commitment to championship pursuit. As they evaluate their options, the organization must balance immediate competitive needs against long-term strategic considerations, all while maintaining their traditional standard of excellence at every position.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us