Mental errors plague as Yankees slide to worst Red Sox loss since 1922

New York Yankees’ Aaron Judge reacts after striking out in the third inning of a baseball game against the Boston Red Sox, Sunday, June 15, 2025, in Boston.
AP Photo/Greg M. Cooper
Sara Molnick
Monday June 16, 2025

Table of Contents

The New York Yankees arrived at Fenway Park riding high. They departed facing harsh reality about their championship aspirations.

Boston’s three-game sweep marked the Yankees’ worst offensive performance against the Red Sox since 1922. New York managed just four runs across three games. The last time they looked this helpless at the plate in Boston was over a century ago.

This series represented more than a rough weekend. It exposed cracks in a team that held a commanding 9.5-game division lead two weeks earlier. The Yankees now hold a precarious 3.5-game advantage over Tampa Bay. Boston sits 6.5 games back after climbing from the depths.

Judge’s weekend to forget

Aaron Judge entered Friday’s opener swinging a scorching bat. Three games later, he looked ordinary against Red Sox pitching.

The MVP candidate finished 1-for-12 with nine strikeouts. His lone hit came via a ninth-inning homer Friday that tied the game. That blast represented the Yankees’ only run against Boston starters all series.

“I’ve got to swing at strikes,” Judge said after Sunday’s loss. “That usually helps any hitter, when you swing at strikes.”

Judge’s strikeout barrage marked unprecedented territory. The Yankees captain had never struck out three times in three consecutive games until this weekend. His batting average tumbled from .392 to .378.

Squandered opportunities define series

The Yankees went 4-for-22 with runners in scoring position. Critical moments slipped away through mental mistakes and poor execution.

Anthony Volpe got picked off attempting to steal third in Friday’s extra innings. Jasson Domínguez lost track of the count Saturday and got caught between bases. Ben Rice was thrown out at second during a botched double steal Sunday.

“We’ve got to be more certain than that,” manager Aaron Boone said. “That’s a play where we can’t get caught like that on a pickoff play there. That one obviously stung us.”

The Yankees failed to score first in any contest. This marked a stunning departure for a club that leads MLB in first-inning production.

Boone’s double speak shows mental lapses

The skipper’s postgame message balanced frustration with optimism.

“It sucks losing to the Red Sox. We never like that,” Boone said. “But it’s why teams don’t win 120 games. We’re really good. I think that’s going to continue to show itself.”

New York entered the weekend without a series sweep against them this season. The manner of defeat stung more than the results. Boston appeared hungrier and more focused throughout.

“They took us down this weekend, back-to-back weekends,” Boone added. “You hate that, but we have a really good club and just didn’t play our best.”

Fried delivers another strong start without support

Max Fried continued his stellar campaign Sunday despite the loss. The left-hander worked seven innings, surrendering two runs while striking out nine. His 1.89 ERA ranks among the American League’s best.

The Yankees’ anemic offense wasted another quality outing from their ace.

“I needed to come out and be a little bit better and be able to match them,” Fried said. “(Bello) was throwing a lot of zeros, and in a game like that, I’ve got to come out and be better and match them.”

New York has scored five runs over 36 innings. This represents a complete offensive breakdown for the AL’s top-scoring team.

Yankees offenses stays mum

Brayan Bello silenced New York’s bats Sunday with seven shutout innings. He scattered three hits while striking out eight Yankees. His performance capped a masterful weekend by Boston’s rotation.

Garrett Crochet and Hunter Dobbins also stifled the Yankees earlier in the series. Red Sox starters combined for one earned run across 21.1 innings.

“They executed,” Boone said. “They got some swing-and-miss with [Judge]. Not much there.”

Boston’s pitching staff delivered their most dominant showing against New York in years.

Division race heats Up as Yankees stumble

Ben Rice's pickoff during the third inning ends the Yankees rally and leads to 2-0 defeat to the Red Sox in Boston on June 15, 2025.

New York entered June positioned to eliminate Boston from contention. Instead, they’ve dropped five of six games to their rivals this month.

The longtime rivalry has found new life after years of Yankees dominance.

“It happens,” Boone said. “You’re going to have a weekend where they execute and they get you.”

The Yankees’ struggles extend beyond losing to Boston. Their trademark discipline and power vanished at Fenway Park. Mental mistakes plagued key situations throughout the series.

A crucial homestand against the Los Angeles Angels awaits. New York must rediscover the form that carried them through May.

Yankees face reality check despite division lead

The Yankees maintain first place and remain on pace for 95 wins. However, the AL East no longer appears locked up.

The upcoming series against Tampa Bay and Toronto loom large. A four-game set at Boston in late August could determine the division champion.

“We’re in the middle of a tough stretch right now,” Boone said. “We get home and start anew.”

The Yankees need more than a fresh start. They need to remember how to play October baseball in June.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Join the Pinstripes Nation!

Your Daily Dose of Yankees Magic Delivered to Your Inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Don't Miss Any of the Latest Yankees News, Rumors, and Exclusive Offers!

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x