Two signs in two days, but Yankees’ questions only grow, answers don’t

Follow Us

New York – The Yankees signed two players in two days, yet both moves raise more questions about their championship aspirations than they answer. Joel Kuhnel, a journeyman pitcher with a 5.86 career ERA, and Nicky Lopez, an infielder batting .042 this season, represent the kind of depth additions that won’t fix the Yankees’ fundamental problems.

The Yankees’ recent signings come as the team has collapsed from a seven-game division lead to second place in the AL East. They’ve lost 15 of their last 20 games, including sweeps by Toronto and Boston. These minimal moves highlight a troubling disconnect between the team’s championship window and their current approach.

Depth moves can’t solve Yankees crisis

Kuhnel, 30, signed a minor league deal July 4, just one day after Philadelphia released him. The 6-foot-5 right-hander has bounced between six teams in the past two seasons and compiled a 5.86 ERA across 93⅔ career innings. His best attribute is generating groundballs, but he’s never sustained MLB success.

Lopez, also 30, signed another minor league deal July 3 after opting out of his contract with Arizona. The former Gold Glove finalist is batting .042/.179/.042 in 28 plate appearances this season across multiple teams. He’s been designated for assignment twice and has opted out of contracts three times in 2025 alone.

These signings represent organizational depth, not impact additions. Both players were assigned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre and face uphill battles to contribute meaningfully to a team with championship aspirations.

Yankees’ problems run deeper than personnel

The Yankees’ struggles extend far beyond what depth signings can address. The team is batting just .174 with runners in scoring position over their last 20 games, ranking dead last in MLB during this stretch. Even Aaron Judge, Paul Goldschmidt, and Giancarlo Stanton are combining for a .142 average in clutch situations.

Manager Aaron Boone has acknowledged the team’s deeper issues, calling lineup construction “a daily puzzle with no easy solutions.” The Yankees face what Boone described as the challenge of managing “the six guys” competing for five spots while struggling to “roll out a crooked number.”

The bullpen presents another major problem. Devin Williams, acquired from Milwaukee for Nestor Cortes and prospects, has failed so far in his first season as the Yankees’ closer. Williams has been removed from the closer role multiple times, with the trade failing to boost the Yankees.

Starting rotation injuries compound the issues. Clarke Schmidt was placed on the 15-day IL with forearm tightness, Luis Gil remains out with a lat strain, and Gerrit Cole is out for all season. Ryan Yarbrough is also nusring an injury on the IL.

Expert criticism mounts

Former Yankees All-Star Dellin Betances publicly called for major moves after the team’s recent collapse. “It just shows you maybe you have to make a big move here, to make sure that they can get back to that promised land, which is the World Series,” Betances said on the Foul Territory podcast.

The criticism reflects growing frustration with the Yankees’ conservative approach. While other contenders make aggressive moves, the Yankees are signing players with sub-.050 batting averages and career journeymen to minor league deals.

The contrast with competitors is stark. The San Francisco Giants acquired Rafael Devers in a blockbuster trade that ESPN called the season’s biggest splash. The Chicago Cubs have been “extremely active” with multiple major acquisitions. The Boston Red Sox made aggressive winter moves acquiring Garrett Crochet, Alex Bregman, and Walker Buehler.

Financial constraints or organizational philosophy?

The Yankees’ payroll sits at $289 million, third-highest in MLB. They spent heavily in the winter, signing Max Fried to a $218 million contract and trading for Cody Bellinger and Williams. But their current approach suggests either financial constraints or an organizational philosophy that prioritizes depth over impact.

GM Brian Cashman described the team’s strategy as completing “light lifting” after winter’s “heavy lifting.” This methodology focuses on targeted, specific needs rather than major splash moves. The Yankees emphasize what Cashman calls “pro scouting” over analytics, preferring durability and character in acquisitions.

Championship window closing

The Yankees’ conservative approach comes as their championship window narrows. Judge enters his age-33 season, Cole is 34 and missed the entire 2025 season, and the team hasn’t won a World Series since 2009. Experts estimate the Yankees have a three-year window while Judge remains elite.

The pressure is mounting. ESPN analysts note the Yankees “play in the game’s most tightly bunched division from top to bottom,” with improved competition from Boston and Toronto. Some analysts are picking Boston over New York for the AL pennant despite the Yankees’ offseason moves.

Band-aid solutions for systemic problems

The Kuhnel and Lopez signings exemplify what critics call “band-aid” solutions to systemic problems. These depth additions don’t address the team’s .174 batting average with runners in scoring position, their closer’s 11.25 ERA, or their rotation injury concerns.

Aaron Boone’s admission that the team has “makings of a special group” but “we’re not that right now” suggests even management recognizes these aren’t temporary issues.

“I do believe that, but we’re not that right now,” Boone said. He was asked if the Yankees were the best team in the league. “We’re not a complete team. We’ve got a long way to go in this thing. But I feel like we have the makings of a special group.”

The Yankees’ 15-year championship drought creates additional pressure on Cashman’s tenure and the organization’s approach.

Gaps clearly visible

The Yankees signed two players in two days, yet both moves underscore the gap between their championship aspirations and current strategy. While competitors make aggressive moves, the Yankees are signing organizational depth that won’t address their fundamental problems. With a narrowing championship window and mounting pressure, these minimal moves raise more questions than they answer about the organization’s commitment to winning now.

The trade deadline approaches July 31. The Yankees’ recent signings suggest they’re preparing for various scenarios, but depth additions won’t fix what ails this team. The clock is ticking on their championship window, and two signings in two days may not be nearly enough.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us