How Yankees’ nostalgia from 1990s fuels 2024 team’s playoff push


Sara Molnick
More Stories By Sara Molnick
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- Former Yankees duo makes career history with unprecedented performances
- Fried misses Yankees’ magnificent-13 status but still finds elite company
- Yankees’ interest in trade for ex-Astros ring leader raises questions
- Yankees’ infield flaw costs Fried a chance at history for good
Table of Contents
The New York Yankees, a team steeped in championship tradition, have recently embraced a nostalgic nod to their glory days. As they aim for their first World Series appearance in 15 years, some players have revived a classic look from the franchise’s most dominant era.
Fans have noticed Yankees players donning turtlenecks during the postseason, a style reminiscent of the iconic late-1990s and early-2000s teams. The look evokes memories of legends like Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and Jorge Posada, who sported the same attire during their October heroics.

In a twist that adds authenticity to the trend, YES Network’s Justin Shackil revealed that these aren’t just replicas. The turtlenecks worn by the current team are the very same ones from the Yankees’ dynasty years, pulled out of storage and back into action.
This postseason, multiple Yankees have opted for the “old school” turtlenecks that conjure up great memories from the past. Turns out, those turtlenecks ARE from the past. I’m told they were in storage for years, and the players chose them b/c they prefer the cotton material.
— Justin Shackil (@JustinShackil) October 19, 2024
While the retro gear may be a fashion statement, it also seems to have injected a sense of renewed energy into the club. Wearing the same gear as past champions, the Yankees appear to be channeling the spirit of those title-winning teams as they chase another championship after a lengthy drought.
This move highlights a familiar theme in baseball: when hunting for a World Series title, teams will embrace any tradition or edge they can find. For the Yankees, that includes literally wearing their history—wrapped snugly around their necks.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada, Mariano Rivera, News
- Tags: 2024 Yankees, aaron judge, derek jeter
