NEW YORK — Michael Kay pushed back Monday on a call for the Yankees to bring back the Core Four as special advisers, saying Brian Cashman is unlikely to hire former champions who disagree with how he runs the club.
On ESPN New York, Kay was answering a listener named Andrew about giving the dynasty players a voice with the current Yankees. He said some of those players learned a different game from the one today’s front offices ask coaches to teach. He named Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada and fellow dynasty teammate David Cone as men fans would like to see return.
“As long as the Yankees are functioning the way they function now and the control from the top down, you’re not going to bring in people that don’t believe [in that approach],” Kay said.
Kay said fans could reasonably disagree with Cashman. He was offering his reading of the Yankees’ thinking. He also challenged Andrew on how much of the case for a reunion rested on what those men had done as players.
“You guys are leading with your heart and you’re not doing it with your head,” Kay said.
Andy Pettitte already has a role with Yankees pitchers
Pettitte’s assignment dates to July 2023, when Aaron Boone confirmed that the left-hander would work alongside pitching coach Matt Blake and his staff. MLB.com later described Pettitte watching Gerrit Cole and Clarke Schmidt warm up in the bullpen and throwing batting practice when the Yankees were preparing to face a left-hander.
Kay told Andrew how often Pettitte works with the Yankees’ pitchers and how the players receive him when he walks into the clubhouse.
“the weird part is andy pettit is intimately involved In the pitching situation with the yankees he is there probably 80 or 90 games a year.
“He’s not a full-time coach He is readily accepted into what they do. He’s in the clubhouse the players love him,” Kay said.
Kay said Pettitte already gives pitchers the kind of guidance Andrew wanted the Core Four to provide.
“So there is somebody there to tell them how to be a bulldog and how to win and things like that,” Kay said.
Kay followed that endorsement with an observation about the results. The Yankees have had access to Pettitte’s experience and are still seeking their first World Series title since 2009.
How the Core Four can help the Yankees
Pettitte gives the Yankees a former starter to consult between outings. The other three bring experience in different jobs. Jeter ran baseball operations in Miami, where Posada joined him in 2019. According to MLB.com, Posada took part in player meetings and on-field instruction, work with a closer parallel to the advisory jobs Andrew proposed.
For a Yankees reliever, Mariano Rivera’s experience protecting leads in October would be particularly relevant. The National Baseball Hall of Fame credits him with 42 postseason saves. Kay did not discuss a role for Rivera in the exchange.
Kay questions whether Jeter wants a daily role
Kay said he believes Jeter does not want a large day-to-day role with the Yankees. That was Kay’s assessment of the former captain’s circumstances. He cited Jeter’s four young children and his broadcasting work.
“He’s got four young children, he’s got a great job at Fox. You really think he wants to come in as a full-time coach?” Kay said.
Kay’s question concerned a full-time coaching job. He did not say Jeter had been offered an advisory position or had turned one down.
Why Kay doubts Jorge Posada will join Boone’s bench
Kay said he thought Posada would make a great bench coach. The opening on Aaron Boone’s staff came Nov. 11, when Brad Ausmus left to manage Houston. What Kay doubted was whether the Yankees would give that job to a catcher who has publicly criticized the way the game is played today.
“Either you have to change the way you think about the way the game should be played or you’re not going to bring these people in,” Kay said.
Kay saw one difference between Posada and Jeter. Posada’s children are older and have moved out, he said, so the former catcher might be interested. Kay also pointed to what Posada himself had said about returning to the Yankees.
Posada had raised a more personal issue in October. Speaking with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman on The Show, he said his difficult final season still weighed on him when he returned. He described feeling unwelcome even at spring training.
“I don’t think they want me there,” Posada said.
Cashman said at the general managers meetings in Las Vegas that the Yankees invite Posada to spring training and Old-Timers’ Day. He said the two had spoken. Neither man indicated that the conversation concerned a job on Boone’s staff.
“He is welcome. I did obviously have those conversations with him,” Cashman said.
Why Kay invoked Goose Gossage in the Core Four debate
Kay asked the caller to imagine the Yankees hiring Goose Gossage to work in the bullpen. He described the Hall of Famer as one of the greatest relievers ever, then asked whether Cashman would want Gossage teaching current pitchers when Gossage himself objects to how teams play.
“He doesn’t believe in the way the game is played right now,” Kay said.
Kay used Gossage to challenge the reasoning behind a Core Four reunion. The caller remembered what the dynasty players had accomplished together. The Yankees would have to decide what each man could contribute on his own. Kay cautioned against treating a playing record as a coaching credential.
“Don’t fall in love with names and don’t fall in love with playing careers because players don’t necessarily make the great mat great managers or coaches Ted williams greatest hitter of all time terrible manager with the washington senators terrible And that goes in all sports,” Kay said.
Kay offered a counterexample from football in John Lynch, the former player he credited with becoming a successful executive with the San Francisco 49ers.
For an advisory job, Kay said, the same question applies to judging talent. He recalled watching former players recommend someone they believed would help a team, only to see that evaluation miss.
Kay ended where he began, with Andrew’s wish to bring back the Yankees’ championship years. As he reminded the listener, one of the men who pitched through those Octobers is already in the clubhouse.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
















