Yankees advance in securing Cody Bellinger deal after Grisham outcome
Table of Contents
Follow UsNew York — The New York Yankees’ pursuit of outfielder Cody Bellinger set to end on positive note despite Trent Grisham accepting his qualifying offer.
General manager Brian Cashman has made the former MVP a top priority this offseason. Latest team intel suggest they are near to formalizing a deal with the slugger.
Yankees maintain Bellinger focus despite payroll crunch
Grisham surprised many in the organization Tuesday when he accepted the one-year, $22.025 million qualifying offer. The decision reduced the Yankees’ luxury tax flexibility from roughly $70 million to approximately $48 million.
But the move hasn’t altered New York’s plans for Bellinger.
“Grisham decision doesn’t affect Yankees pursuit of Cody Bellinger, a priority,” MLB insider Jon Heyman of the New York Post reported.
Multiple sources confirmed the Yankees view Bellinger as essential to their 2026 roster construction. The 30-year-old outfielder posted impressive numbers during his first season in pinstripes, batting .272 with 29 home runs and 98 RBIs across 152 games. His production marked the best overall campaign he’s had since winning NL MVP honors in 2019.
Cashman commits to continuing negotiations
The Yankees acquired Bellinger from the Chicago Cubs last December in exchange for pitcher Cody Poteet. His impact was immediate, providing both offensive firepower and defensive versatility across multiple positions.
MLB insider Greg Joyce revealed that Cashman intends to maintain dialogue with Bellinger’s agent, Scott Boras, regardless of the Grisham situation.
“The return of Grisham should not impact the top Yankees priority — re-signing Cody Bellinger — as GM Brian Cashman said recently he would continue to have conversations with Bellinger’s agent, Scott Boras,” Joyce reported Tuesday.
Heyman added context about potential surprise within the organization over Grisham’s choice.
“I think there were some Yankees people that were somewhat surprised by (Grisham’s) decision,” Heyman noted. “Not going to say all of them. I think several understood that this was a realistic possibility.”
Financial considerations loom large
The Yankees face challenging budget mathematics this winter. With Grisham’s $22 million commitment and a potential Bellinger deal projected around $30 million annually, New York must carefully allocate remaining resources.
“But now, if they have Cody Bellinger, who’s going to make presumably around $30 million, plus $22 million for Grisham, how much money does that leave for the bullpen, for maybe an extra starter?” Heyman questioned during his analysis.
The Yankees finished slightly above the $300 million luxury tax threshold in 2025. Ownership has expressed reluctance to exceed that mark significantly, though circumstances may force their hand.
Contract projections for Bellinger vary across the industry. MLB Trade Rumors estimates a five-year, $140 million deal. Bleacher Report’s Zachary Rymer predicted a seven-year, $175 million contract. ESPN projects six years at $165 million.
All scenarios would represent substantial financial commitments for a player entering his age-31 season.
Yankee Stadium proves perfect fit
The short right-field porch at Yankee Stadium consistently favored Bellinger’s left-handed swing throughout 2025. His .814 OPS represented a significant improvement over recent seasons with the Cubs.
“New York is the clear favorite to sign Bellinger,” MLB insider Mark Feinsand wrote. The Yankees and [Cody] Bellinger were a perfect match, and a reunion here makes sense for both parties. Yankee Stadium is built perfectly for his swing, evidenced by Bellinger’s career .912 OPS in the Bronx.”
Bellinger’s defensive flexibility gives manager Aaron Boone valuable lineup options. He can handle all three outfield positions plus first base, providing coverage across multiple defensive alignments.
His father, Clay Bellinger, won two World Series championships with the Yankees from 1999 to 2001. The family connection adds sentimental value to potential negotiations.
Boras signals mutual interest
Agent Scott Boras recently addressed the situation, suggesting the Yankees recognize Bellinger’s value.
“I think the Yankees are looking to improve, not subtract,” Boras stated. “Bellinger’s placement among the outfielders, he now has, particularly after being MVP, has a three-year track record of consistency, power and elite performance.”
The comment signals confidence that negotiations will progress favorably for both sides.
Competition emerges from multiple fronts
Several teams have expressed interest in Bellinger’s services. The New York Mets, Toronto Blue Jays and Los Angeles Dodgers all reportedly remain in the mix.
Bleacher Report analyst Joel Reuter even predicted the Mets could land Bellinger on a five-year, $135 million deal, though most insiders view the Yankees as favorites.
The Dodgers connection carries particular significance. Los Angeles drafted Bellinger in 2013 and watched him develop into an MVP-caliber player before non-tendering him after the 2022 season.
Outfield configuration questions persist
With Grisham locked in for 2026 and Aaron Judge firmly entrenched in right field, the Yankees must determine optimal outfield alignment.
Young prospects Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones wait in the wings for opportunities. Both players represent significant organizational investments who could factor into long-term planning.
However, team officials appear willing to prioritize present-day competitiveness over prospect development timelines.
Grisham’s defensive metrics declined significantly in 2025. He posted minus-11 defensive runs saved and minus-2 outs above average in center field after earning two Gold Glove Awards earlier in his career. Questions remain whether age or positioning caused the defensive regression.
Critical decisions ahead
The Yankees must balance multiple priorities beyond the outfield. Their bullpen requires reinforcements, particularly left-handed relief options. The starting rotation could use additional depth behind ace Gerrit Cole. First base remains another potential area of need depending on roster construction.
All these considerations factor into the Bellinger equation. The Yankees cannot simply add his projected $30 million salary without examining broader roster implications.
Yet Cashman has repeatedly emphasized Bellinger’s importance to the organization’s plans. The general manager appears determined to find financial pathways that accommodate the outfielder’s return.
Bellinger opted out of his contract earlier this month, turning down a guaranteed $25 million for 2026 in favor free agency. The decision signaled confidence in securing a more lucrative long-term deal.
His representatives believe the market will reward his performance. Three consecutive seasons of above-average production have positioned him for one final significant contract before declining into his mid-30s.
The Yankees understand these dynamics. They recognize Bellinger’s window of peak performance may be narrowing but believe his immediate contributions justify substantial investment.
Whether ownership will authorize spending levels necessary to retain him alongside Grisham remains the pivotal question. Early indications suggest affirmative answers are coming.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
