Analyst bets on Yankees’ Chisholm as AL’s ‘single best Swiss Army knife’ this season
Table of Contents
Follow UsAs the Yankees prepare for Opening Day amid a wave of significant injuries, one player has stepped forward as the vital component holding everything together: Jazz Chisholm Jr.
Since arriving via trade last season, Chisholm has quickly established himself as not merely one of the most explosive talents on the Yankees roster—but perhaps their most essential player. While injuries continue to disrupt the projected starting lineup and test organizational depth, the 26-year-old is demonstrating why he’s earned recognition as the premier utility player in the American League.
“After the first 10 days of the season, Jazz Chisholm Jr. will be the single best Swiss Army knife among American League players,” ESPN’s Jeff Passan wrote recently. “Only Mookie Betts has a better combination of production and positional eligibility than Chisholm, who can be played at second, third or outfield.”
This positional flexibility arrives at precisely the moment the Yankees need it most.
Chisholm stands out as Yankees’ injury woes mounting
The Yankees enter the 2025 campaign hampered by injuries throughout their roster. Staff ace Gerrit Cole will miss the entire season recovering from Tommy John surgery while reigning AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil is sidelined with a lat strain expected to keep him out for multiple months.
The relief corps hasn’t escaped unscathed either. While Ian Hamilton shows promising progress and may be available for Opening Day, Jake Cousins continues rehabilitation from a forearm strain without a definitive return timeline.
On the offensive side, the Yankees are missing two projected lineup fixtures. Designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton remains unavailable indefinitely due to bilateral elbow tears and a recently reported calf issue, while third baseman DJ LeMahieu departed spring training after just two at-bats because of his own calf injury.
To address these lineup voids, manager Aaron Boone is deploying a combination of emerging talent and veterans. Ben Rice and Oswaldo Cabrera are poised to fill in for Stanton and LeMahieu, while Dominic Smith, Pablo Reyes, and Oswald Peraza could all see action as the team considers platoon arrangements—particularly at third base.
Yet amid this shifting personnel landscape, Chisholm stands out as the singular player Boone can confidently deploy wherever the needs arise.
Chisholm’s value goes beyond versatility
Though Chisholm’s defensive adaptability proves critical, his offensive contributions truly distinguish him. In just 191 plate appearances following his acquisition by the Yankees last season, the former All-Star produced an impressive .273/.325/.500 slash line, launching 11 home runs, adding eight doubles, and stealing 18 bases. His dynamic combination of power and speed injects essential energy into a lineup missing several of its most formidable hitters.
The Bahamas native primarily played second base in 2024 but handled third base capably during crucial late-season games—despite having no professional experience at the position previously. He’s also accumulated significant time in center field and has prior experience at shortstop, providing Boone with unmatched roster flexibility.
Whether covering third until LeMahieu returns, patrolling center field, or returning to second base depending on matchups and health situations, Chisholm offers New York options unavailable from anyone else on the roster.
Jazz succor as Boone faces roster chess
Aaron Boone’s greatest challenge to begin the season may not involve managing personalities, but rather managing positions. With third base lacking a clear solution and the DH role in flux, Boone could rotate multiple players through various infield and outfield positions. The emergence of Rice and Cabrera adds promising options but also creates additional variables.
This scenario highlights Chisholm’s value as a difference-maker. His capacity to move across different defensive positions at a moment’s notice enables Boone to maintain a more fluid lineup construction. If another infielder performs exceptionally at second, Chisholm can shift to third. If late-game defensive alignment becomes crucial, he can move to the outfield. Need baserunning speed or left-handed power in the heart of the order? He satisfies both requirements.
A foundation for 2025
With Judge anchoring the outfield and Anthony Volpe continuing his development as the everyday shortstop, the Yankees possess the foundation of a postseason-caliber team. However, if they aim to return to the World Series and advance further than their 2024 five-game defeat to the Dodgers, they’ll require players who not only fill positional gaps—but excel while doing so.
Chisholm represents more than a versatile stopgap solution. He’s a game-changing talent capable of producing All-Star caliber numbers while impacting contests defensively and on the basepaths.
And with Stanton and LeMahieu both sidelined indefinitely, the Yankees may need him to be exactly that.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Jazz Chisholm Jr., News
- Tags: Jazz Chisholm Jr.
